Evidence of Obama Administration Political Surveillance Beginning Mid-2012….

Repost by Request – Considering the upcoming declassification window…between Trump’s state visit in Japan (5/25 – 5/28) and the state visit with the U.K (6/3 – 6/5).

Bucket FiveIntelligence documents that were presented to the Gang of Eight in 2016 that pertain to the FISA application used against U.S. person Carter Page; including all exculpatory intelligence documents that may not have been presented to the FISA Court.  Presumably this would include the recently revealed State Dept Kavalac email; and the FBI transcripts from wiretaps of George Papadopoulos (also listed in Carter Page FISA).

Now that we have significant research files on the 2015 and 2016 political surveillance program; which includes the trail evident within the Weissmann/Mueller report; in combination with the Obama-era DOJ “secret research project” (their words, not mine); we are able to overlay the entire objective and gain a full understanding of how political surveillance was conducted over a period of approximately four to six years.
This is why there’s panic.
Working with a timeline, but also referencing origination material in 2015/2016 – CTH hopes to show how the program operated. This explains an evolution from The IRS Files in 2010 to the FISA Files in 2016.
More importantly, research indicates the modern political exploitation of the NSA database, for weaponized intelligence surveillance of politicians, began mid 2012.

The FISA-702 database extraction process, and utilization of the protections within the smaller intelligence community, was the primary process. We start by reviewing the established record from the 99-page FISC opinion rendered by Presiding Judge Rosemary Collyer on April 26th, 2017; and explain the details within the FISC opinion.
I would strongly urge everyone to read the FISC report (full pdf below) because Judge Collyer outlines how the DOJ, which includes the FBI, had an “institutional lack of candor” in responses to the FISA court. In essence, the Obama administration was continually lying to the court about their activity, and the rate of fourth amendment violations for illegal searches and seizures of U.S. persons’ private information for multiple years.
Unfortunately, due to intelligence terminology Judge Collyer’s brief and ruling is not an easy read for anyone unfamiliar with the FISA processes outlined. The complexity also helps the media avoid discussing, and as a result most Americans have no idea the scale and scope of the issues. So we’ll try to break down the language.
[scribd id=349542716 key=key-72P5FzpI44KMOuOPZrt1 mode=scroll]
For the sake of brevity and common understanding CTH will highlight the most pertinent segments showing just how systemic and troublesome the unlawful electronic surveillance was.
Early in 2016 NSA Director Admiral Mike Rogers was alerted of a significant uptick in FISA-702(17) “About” queries using the FBI/NSA database that holds all metadata records on every form of electronic communication.
The NSA compliance officer alerted Admiral Mike Rogers who then initiated a full compliance audit on/around March 9th, 2016, for the period of November 1st, 2015, through May 1st, 2016.
While the audit was ongoing, due to the severity of the results that were identified, Admiral Mike Rogers stopped anyone from using the 702(17) “about query” option, and went to the extraordinary step of blocking all FBI contractor access to the database on April 18, 2016 (keep these dates in mind).

Here are some significant segments:

The key takeaway from these first paragraphs is how the search query results were exported from the NSA database to users who were not authorized to see the material. The FBI contractors were conducting searches and then removing, or ‘exporting’, the results. Later on, the FBI said all of the exported material was deleted.

Searching the highly classified NSA database is essentially a function of filling out search boxes to identify the user-initiated search parameter and get a return on the search result.
FISA-702(16) is a search of the system returning a U.S. person (“702”); and the “16” is a check box to initiate a search based on “To and From“. Example, if you put in a date and a phone number and check “16” as the search parameter the user will get the returns on everything “To and From” that identified phone number for the specific date. Calls, texts, contacts etc. Including results for the inbound and outbound contacts.
FISA-702(17) is a search of the system returning a U.S. person (702); and the “17” is a check box to initiate a search based on everything “About” the search qualifier. Example, if you put a date and a phone number and check “17” as the search parameter the user will get the returns of everything about that phone. Calls, texts, contacts, geolocation (or gps results), account information, user, service provider etc. As a result, 702(17) can actually be used to locate where the phone (and user) was located on a specific date or sequentially over a specific period of time which is simply a matter of changing the date parameters.
And that’s just from a phone number.
Search an ip address “about” and read all data into that server; put in an email address and gain everything about that account. Or use the electronic address of a GPS enabled vehicle (about) and you can withdraw more electronic data and monitor in real time. Search a credit card number and get everything about the account including what was purchased, where, when, etc. Search a bank account number, get everything about transactions and electronic records etc. Just about anything and everything can be electronically searched; everything has an electronic ‘identifier’.
The search parameter is only limited by the originating field filled out. Names, places, numbers, addresses, etc. By using the “About” parameter there may be thousands or millions of returns. Imagine if you put “@realdonaldtrump” into the search parameter? You could extract all following accounts who interacted on Twitter, or Facebook etc. You are only limited by your imagination and the scale of the electronic connectivity.
As you can see below, on March 9th, 2016, internal auditors noted the FBI was sharing “raw FISA information, including but not limited to Section 702-acquired information”.
In plain English the raw search returns were being shared with unknown entities without any attempt to “minimize” or redact the results. The person(s) attached to the results were named and obvious. There was no effort to hide their identity or protect their 4th amendment rights of privacy:

But what’s the scale here? This is where the story really lies.
Read this next excerpt carefully.
The operators were searching “U.S Persons”. The review of November 1, 2015, to May 1, 2016, showed “eighty-five percent of those queries” were unlawful or “non compliant”.

85% !! “representing [redacted number]”.

We can tell from the space of the redaction the number of searches were between 1,000 and 9,999 [five digits]. If we take the middle number of 5,000 – that means 4,250 unlawful searches out of 5,000.

The [five digit] amount (more than 1,000, less than 10,000), and 85% error rate, was captured in a six month period.
Also notice this very important quote: “many of these non-compliant queries involved the use of the same identifiers over different date ranges.” So they were searching the same phone number, email address, electronic “identifier”, or people, repeatedly over different dates. Specific people were being tracked/monitored.
Additionally, notice the last quote: “while the government reports it is unable to provide a reliable estimate of” these non lawful searches “since 2012, there is no apparent reason to believe the November 2015 [to] April 2016 coincided with an unusually high error rate”.
That means the 85% unlawful FISA-702(16)(17) database abuse has likely been happening since 2012. (Again, remember that date, 2012) Who was FBI Director? Who was his chief-of-staff? Who was CIA Director? ODNI? etc. Remember, the NSA is inside the Pentagon (Defense Dept) command structure. Who was Defense Secretary? And finally, who wrote and signed-off-on the January 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment?
Tens of thousands of searches over four years (since 2012), and 85% of them are illegal. The results were extracted for?…. (I believe this is all political opposition use; and I’ll explain why momentarily.)
OK, that’s the stunning scale; but who was involved?
Private contractors with access to “raw FISA information that went well beyond what was necessary to respond to FBI’s requests“:
And as noted, the contractor access was finally halted on April 18th, 2016.
[Coincidentally (or not), the wife of Fusion-GPS founder Glenn Simpson, Mary Jacoby, goes to the White House the next day on April 19th, 2016.]
None of this is conspiracy theory.
All of this is laid out inside this 99-page opinion from FISC Presiding Judge Rosemary Collyer who also noted that none of this FISA abuse was accidental in a footnote on page 87: “deliberate decisionmaking“:

This specific footnote, if declassified, would be key.  Note the phrase: “([redacted] access to FBI systems was the subject of an interagency memorandum of understanding entered into [redacted])”, this sentence has the potential to expose an internal decision; withheld from congress and the FISA court by the Obama administration; that outlines a process for access and distribution of surveillance data.
Note: “no notice of this practice was given to the FISC until 2016“, that is important.
Summary of this aspect: The FISA court identified and quantified tens-of-thousands of search queries of the NSA/FBI database using the FISA-702(16)(17) system. The database was repeatedly used by persons with contractor access who unlawfully searched and extracted the raw results without redacting the information and shared it with an unknown number of entities.
The outlined process certainly points toward a political spying and surveillance operation; and we are not the only one to think that’s what this system is being used for.
Back in 2017 when House Intelligence Committee Chairman Devin Nunes was working to reauthorize the FISA legislation, Nunes wrote a letter to ODNI Dan Coats about this specific issue:

SIDEBAR: To solve the issue, well, actually attempt to ensure it never happened again, NSA Director Admiral Mike Rogers eventually took away the “About” query option permanently in 2017. NSA Director Rogers said the abuse was so inherent there was no way to stop it except to remove the process completely. [SEE HERE] Additionally, the NSA database operates as a function of the Pentagon, so the Trump administration went one step further. On his last day as NSA Director Admiral Mike Rogers -together with ODNI Dan Coats- put U.S. cyber-command, the database steward, fully into the U.S. military as a full combatant command. [SEE HERE]
There is little doubt the FISA-702(16)(17) database system was used by Obama-era officials, from 2012 through April 2016, as a way to spy on their political opposition. Quite simply there is no other intellectually honest explanation for the scale and volume of database abuse that was taking place.
When we reconcile what was taking place and who was involved, then the actions of the exact same principle participants take on a jaw-dropping amount of clarity.
All of the action taken by CIA Director Brennan, FBI Director Comey, ODNI Clapper and Defense Secretary Ashton Carter make sense. Including their effort to get NSA Director Mike Rogers fired.
Everything after March 9th, 2016, was done to cover up the weaponization of the FISA database. [Explained Here] Spygate, Russia-Gate, the Steele Dossier, and even the 2017 Intelligence Community Assessment (drawn from the dossier and signed by the above) were needed to create a cover-story and protect themselves from discovery of this four year weaponization, political surveillance and unlawful spying. Even the appointment of Robert Mueller as special counsel makes sense; he was FBI Director when this began.
The beginning decision to use FISA(702) as a domestic surveillance and political spy mechanism appears to have started in/around 2012. Perhaps sometime shortly before the 2012 presidential election and before John Brennan left the White House and moved to CIA. However, there was an earlier version of data assembly that preceded this effort.
Political spying 1.0 was actually the weaponization of the IRS. This is where the term “Secret Research Project” originated as a description from the Obama team. It involved the U.S. Department of Justice under Eric Holder and the FBI under Robert Mueller. It never made sense why Eric Holder requested over 1 million tax records via CD ROM, until overlaying the timeline of the FISA abuse:

The IRS sent the FBI “21 disks constituting a 1.1 million page database of information from 501(c)(4) tax exempt organizations, to the Federal Bureau of Investigation.” The transaction occurred in October 2010 (link)

Why disks? Why send a stack of DISKS to the DOJ and FBI when there’s a pre-existing financial crimes unit within the IRS. All of the evidence within this sketchy operation came directly to the surface in early spring 2012.
The IRS scandal was never really about the IRS, it was always about the DOJ asking the IRS for the database of information. That is why it was transparently a conflict when the same DOJ was tasked with investigating the DOJ/IRS scandal. Additionally, Obama sent his chief-of-staff Jack Lew to become Treasury Secretary; effectively placing an ally to oversee/cover-up any issues. As Treasury Secretary Lew did just that.
Lesson Learned – It would appear the Obama administration learned a lesson from attempting to gather a large opposition research database operation inside a functioning organization large enough to have some good people that might blow the whistle.
The timeline reflects a few months after realizing the “Secret Research Project” was now worthless (June 2012), they focused more deliberately on a smaller network within the intelligence apparatus and began weaponizing the FBI/NSA database.  If our hunch is correct, that is what will be visible in footnote #69:

How this all comes together in 2019

Fusion GPS was not hired in April 2016 to research Donald Trump. As shown in the evidence provided by the FISC, the intelligence community was already doing surveillance and spy operations. The Obama administration already knew everything about the Trump campaign, and were monitoring everything by exploiting the FISA database.
However, after the NSA alerts in/around March 9th, 2016, and particularly after the April 18th shutdown of contractor access, the Obama intelligence community needed Fusion GPS to create a legal albeit ex post facto justification for the pre-existing surveillance and spy operations. Fusion GPS gave them that justification in the Steele Dossier.
That’s why the FBI small group, which later transitioned into the Mueller team, are so strongly committed to and defending the formation of the Steele Dossier and its dubious content. The Steele Dossier contains the cover-story and justification for the pre-existing surveillance operation.
During a rather innocuous podcast discussion panel April 12th, 2019, one of President Trump’s personal lawyers Jay Sekulow mentioned the FBI had three FISA applications denied by the FISA court in 2016. [Podcast Here – Note comment at 25:05] The denials were always suspected; however, until now no-one in/around the administration has ever confirmed.
If Sekulow is accurate, this adds additional context to the actions of the FBI in the aftermath of Admiral Mike Rogers and an increased urgency in gaining legal justification for surveillance and spy operation unlawfully taking place. A valid FISA warrant would help the FBI cover-up the surveillance. The likely targets were Manafort, Flynn and Papadopoulos…. but it appears the DOJ/FBI were rebuked.
These FISC denials would then initiate institutional panic dependent on the election outcome. An insurance policy would be needed. The Steele Dossier becomes the investigative virus the FBI wanted inside the system. To get the virus into official status, they used the FISA application as the delivery method and injected it into Carter Page. The FBI already knew Carter Page; essentially Carter Page was irrelevant, what they needed was the FISA warrant and the Dossier in the system {Go Deep}.
Fusion GPS was not hired to research Trump, the intelligence community was already doing surveillance and spy operations. The intelligence community needed Fusion GPS to give them a plausible justification for already existing surveillance and spy operations.
Fusion-GPS gave them the justification they needed for a FISA warrant with the Steele Dossier. Ultimately that’s why the Steele Dossier is so important; without it, the DOJ and FBI are naked with their FISA-702 abuse as outlined by John Ratcliffe.

No-one really knows the extent of the current documents and/or information that may be subject to the AG Bill Barr declassification. However, this is the original list as outlined in September 2018, and the agencies who would be involved in the declassification process:

  1. All versions of the Carter Page FISA applications (DOJ) (DoS) (FBI) (ODNI).
  2. All of the Bruce Ohr 302’s filled out by the FBI. (FBI) (ODNI)
  3. All of Bruce Ohr’s emails (FBI) (DOJ) (CIA) (ODNI), and supportive documents and material provided by Bruce Ohr to the FBI. (FBI)
  4. All relevant documents pertaining to the supportive material within the FISA application. (FBI) (DOJ-NSD ) (DoS) (CIA) (DNI) (NSA) (ODNI);
  5. All intelligence documents that were presented to the Gang of Eight in 2016 that pertain to the FISA application used against U.S. person Carter Page; including all exculpatory intelligence documents that may not have been presented to the FISA Court. (CIA) (FBI) (DOJ) (ODNI) (DoS) (NSA)
  6. All unredacted text messages and email content between Lisa Page and Peter Strzok on all devices. (FBI) (DOJ) (DOJ-NSD) (ODNI)
  7. The originating CIA “EC” or two-page electronic communication from former CIA Director John Brennan to FBI Director James Comey that started Operation Crossfire Hurricane in July 2016. (CIA) (FBI) (ODNI)

♦ President Trump can prove the July 31st, 2016, Crossfire Hurricane counterintelligence operation originated from a scheme within the intelligence apparatus by exposing the preceding CIA operation that created the originating “Electronic Communication” memo. Declassify that two-page “EC” document that Brennan gave to Comey.  [The trail is found within the Weissmann report and the use of Alexander Downer – SEE HERE]
♦ Release and declassify all of the Comey memos that document the investigative steps taken by the FBI as an outcome of the operation coordinated by CIA Director John Brennan in early 2016.  [The trail was memorialized by James Comey – SEE HERE]
♦ Reveal the November 2015 through April 2016 FISA-702 search query abuse by declassifying the April 2017 court opinion written by FISC Presiding Judge Rosemary Collyer. Show the FBI contractors behind the 85% fraudulent search queries. [Crowdstrike? Fusion-GPS? Nellie Ohr? Daniel Richman?]  This was a weaponized surveillance and domestic political spying operation. [The trail was laid down in specific detail by Judge Collyer – SEE HERE]
♦ Subpoena former DOJ-NSD (National Security Division) head John Carlin, or haul him in front of a grand jury, and get his testimony about why he hid the abuse from the FISA court in October 2016; why the DOJ-NSD rushed the Carter Page application to beat NSA Director Admiral Mike Rogers to the FISA court; and why Carlin quit immediately thereafter.
♦ Prove the Carter Page FISA application (October 2016) was fraudulent and based on deceptions to the FISA Court. Declassify the entire document, and release the transcripts of those who signed the application(s); and/or depose those who have not yet testified. The creation of the Steele Dossier was the cover-up operation. [SEE HERE]
♦ Release all of the Lisa Page and Peter Strzok text messages without redactions. Let sunlight pour in on the actual conversation(s) that were taking place when Crossfire Hurricane (July ’16) and the FISA Application (Oct ’16) were taking place.  The current redactions were made by the people who weaponized the intelligence system for political surveillance and spy operation.  This is why Page and Strzok texts are redacted!
♦ Release all of Bruce Ohr 302’s, FBI notes from interviews and debriefing sessions, and other relevant documents associated with the interviews of Bruce Ohr and his internal communications. Including exculpatory evidence that Bruce Ohr may have shared with FBI Agent Joseph Pientka. [And get a deposition from this Pientka fella] Bruce Ohr is the courier, carrying information from those outside to those on the inside.
♦ Release the August 2nd, 2017, two-page scope memo provided by DAG Rod Rosenstein to special counsel Robert Mueller to advance the fraudulent Trump investigation, and initiate the more purposeful obstruction of justice investigation. Also Release the October 20th, 2017, second scope memo recently discovered.  The Scope Memos are keys to unlocking the underlying spy/surveillance cover-up. [SEE HERE and SEE HERE]

This entry was posted in 4th Amendment, 6th Amendment, AG Bill Barr, Big Government, Big Stupid Government, CIA, Clinton(s), Cold Anger, Conspiracy ?, Decepticons, Deep State, Dem Hypocrisy, Dept Of Justice, Desperately Seeking Hillary, DHS, Donald Trump, Donald Trump Transition, Election 2012, Election 2014, Election 2016, Election 2017, Election 2018, FBI, IG Report Clinton Investigation, IG Report FISA Abuse, IG Report McCabe, Legislation, media bias, Notorious Liars, NSA, President Trump, Russia, Spygate, Spying, THE BIG UGLY, Uncategorized, White House Coverup. Bookmark the permalink.

530 Responses to Evidence of Obama Administration Political Surveillance Beginning Mid-2012….

  1. Sammy Hains says:

    Robert Mueller was FBI Director in 2012.
    Robert Mueller was FBI Director in 2012.
    Robert Mueller was FBI Director in 2012.
    Robert Mueller was FBI Director in 2012.
    It was his baby.
    It is why they brought him back for one last hurrah.

    • grandmotherpatriot says:

      Yes and was the Director when the Woods Procedure was created.

      • Sammy Hains says:

        Mueller was supposed to leave in 2011. The law calls for the FBI Director to serve for no more than 10 years. This was put in place after the corrupt tenure of J. Edgar Hoover.
        0bama kept Mueller on until after the 2012 election.
        Because Mueller was 0bama’s political spy chief.
        I’m betting Mueller also knows what went “wrong” with Romney’s Project ORCA on election day in 2012.

        • grandmotherpatriot says:

          It would not surprise me at all as Obama and the Chicago political machine have been stealing elections for years.
          Like I stated the Woods Procedure for the FISA Court was created under Meuller ‘s FBI.
          Even now as I type and we are all focused on the shiny object in the room Spygate and the Russian Hoax, Obama and Holder have been busy redistricting Key States for the 2020 election. They’re using judges nuked in under Dirty Harry Reid.
          The perfect Rules for Radicals scam – cause chaos to keep the focus off what is happening behind the scenes.

          • Fish and hunt says:

            SCOTUS issued a stay on redistricting in Ohio and Michigan today

            • nikkichico7 says:

              HOORAY‼️‼️‼️‼️ Thank God for that … we now have a shitty demoncrat for Governor and I know the miserable scum bag didn’t win the election was jury rigged … I’m sick of them spit ???

            • grandmotherpatriot says:

              Wonderful news ! Now we must secure Texas and Florida.

          • grandmotherpatriot says:

            19 minutes

            4h4 hours ago
            BREAKING: Supreme Court grants Republican request to block drawing of new congressional maps in Ohio and Michigan before 2020 elections – Reuters
            Good news !

            • Dennis Leonard says:

              And also WI is out of the picture with the defeat of the liberal Wi supreme court judge couple months ago.

        • Ready Steady Go says:

          So why didn’t Mueller make up a phony obstruction charge against POTUS, don Jr, or kushner??? He could have set them up easily and the MSM would have carried the lie. What happened? Who and how was Mueller nuetred??? Was a deal made???

          • dd_sc says:

            I suspect the Uniparty doesn’t want to actually go to an impeachment and senate trial where evidence needs to be introduced. The goal is to get Trump to resign, or provide Senate RINOs enough cover to pressure Trump to resign.

            • TheLastDemocrat says:

              Or, convince voters to elect someone else in 2020. Plain ol’ political slander. Cast a taint on Trump – no need to prove anything, just give voters this impression.

              • Dutchman says:

                Nah, they have,already admitted they can’t beat him at the ballot box. Oh, they will TRY, but will work as,well as every Uniparty plan has worked against DJT, since the escalator ride,…which is to say it will backfire.

            • Dutchman says:

              “Trump to resign, or provide Senate Rinos enough cover to pressure Trump to resign.”
              THIS. The MAIN plan for Mueller, was to never need to right a report that actually mattered.
              PDJT was SUPPOSED to get p.o.’d and fire Mueller, Rosie etc. THATS what they wanted. Then McConnell sends Graham over to tell POTUS if we put it to a vote, you WILL be impeached.
              Problem is, PDJT didn’t accomodate them, and they could only delay for so long. The whole thrust of Mueller, from his interview on, was to build obstruction case to give cover for Republicans to vote for impeachment.

          • pucecatt says:

            My guess is mueller knew the lovebirds and others left a mess that couldn’t be explained away , so he had to play it “ by the book “ too much evidence that would contradict his findings if they were negative towards Potus , plus there was no evidence of wrongdoing, the only wrongdoing was coming from the other side . His investigation was nothing more than a tool to muddy the waters for almost 3 years .

          • nikkichico7 says:

            I read somewhere that muller .. spit? … delivered the uranium sample to Russia so his gonads are in hock so to speak … and I dearly hope it’s true … miserable creep

        • dd_sc says:

          I believe it requires Senate approval for FBI Director to serve past 10 years; but not another confirmation hearing, just a vote. So a Democrat Senate rubber stamped that approval.

        • jackphatz says:

          “Twitchy recorded widespread real-time complaints and criticisms on Twitter by Project Orca volunteers. At one point during Election Day, the system had malfunctioned so badly that desperate volunteers wondered if the program had been hacked. ”
          Interesting thought.

          • FanGirl says:

            He was a crap candidate that handed the election to Obama. I’m more inclined to believe he was neutered. He never spoke so much vile towards Obama that he does toward Trump.

            • jackphatz says:

              Yep, not one word against Obama’s anti American policies before or after 2012. Kinda makes it look like any Republican candidate was going to pass out in the 11th hour.

        • Tl Howard says:

          I remember Barack Obama CRYING during a campaign stop in the last week or two of the campaign. He was in tears….I figured the Dems internal polling had him losing…but voila, he won.

      • Tparty says:

        … and Mewller was brought in right before 911

      • Tparty says:

        … and Mewller was brought into the FIB right before 911

    • Tall Texan says:

      Reason #427 Mueller will never testify

      • Ready Steady Go says:

        How did team Trump shut him and Weissman down??? Did they give Mueller a pass if he stood down and let them take down Comey and company??? Did Mueller decide that he would save his own ass, give POTUS a clean report, and then him take down some of the coup members.

        • bgood says:

          Agree that it’s mysterious as hell. Maybe they realized the secrets were coming out no matter what they did (imagine the buzzkill for them when that finally sunk in).
          The list of who was being tracked would be interesting to see.

          • Dutchman says:

            Personally, I think it was the flight on AF1, with Rosie. PDJT could be confident of no bugs or witnesses, except MAYBE ‘HIS’ when he had a tete a tete, perhaps one on one, with Rosie.
            Sang him a little Phil Collins, “know what you did, and all been a pack of lies”. For me, that seemed to be a turning point, somehow.

            • Fubu says:

              I think that Trump raised the Barr too high to allow Mueller to continue. If you know what i mean.

    • sarasotosfan says:

      He had the mother of conflicts because he had to know where that exported data went.
      And his reluctance to testify is completely understandable when viewed with that little factoid in mind.

    • Mark L. says:

      He had no choice. Defend his actions or go up in smoke

    • Heika says:

      Bingo. Mueller was back in to cover up his own dalliances. He started it all. What a mind blower.

      • bertdilbert says:

        Maxine seems to be saying that Obama would be in control of the presidency even after leaving office. Let that sink in.

      • Deplorable_Vespucciland says:

        Perhaps she was talking about OFA’s election database of avowed democrats; from their general electorate donors to their street fanatics, not the overall public. That voter database he intended to hand off or sell to the next democrat presidential candidate.

        • Dutchman says:

          EXACTLY! We have enough REAL spying without perpetuating this myth.
          No maybe about it, LISTEN to the interviewers question, and,where he interjects a clarifying question.
          The NSA database is NOT a,501C.

      • jackphatz says:

        Organizing for America is no longer linked to Barry’s website.

    • Ted Koehl says:

      I think it is very important to recall Auntie Maxine Waters bragging about the “organization Obama has put together like no one has ever seen in life.” https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIA1lQBqH1s

    • Derrufo Konepke says:

      one of the biggest reports sundance has ever done … happy Memorial Day Holiday !

  2. Nigella says:

    A lot to take in, but obviously obama is up to his eyeballs in this

    • J Gottfred says:

      The DOD could not do a drone strike in the Middle East without Obama’s approval. O micro managed everything, everything! Including HIS surveillance program. Infact, it should be called The Obama’s Surveillance Program…

    • Bailey Howe says:

      Gee willikers….the bamster is now stating hes not going to publish right away…when one REALLY has to do the work any beach hut in Bali will do. Extradition & all that nonsense, you know…

      • Dabigragu says:

        Who is “the bamster”?

      • jackphatz says:

        Several people have noticed a lack of wedding ring on Barry’s finger. Then he comes out with that comment about Michelle.
        Except for that book tour ( which I do not believe those books sold numbers), Michelle has made only two media appearances in this country and the only thing we see of Barry is out of the country. (Bush’s funeral doesn’t count) For a power couple whose lifestyle is predicated on ‘in your face’ this seems odd.

  3. calbear84 says:

    Pulitzer for Sundance!
    As shocking as this is, can we really be surprised that tyrants would take maximum advantage of a weapon as potent as the ability to spy on anyone they choose?

    • Niagara Frontier says:

      Be prepared to hear at least a dozen reasons why they acted with such disregard for the law.
      As we know from an old fable, “The Wolf and the Lamb,” the tyrant will always find a pretext for his tyranny.

  4. Gadsden says:

    Lines up with when Brennan took over at CIA.

    • DevilDawg4Ever says:

      Also, do not forget Gen Vincent Stewart. He is as dirty as they come, and he is a vicious racist to boot. He seems to be slotted into the right billets at the right crucial times in the overall timeline, yet he has stayed off everyone’s radar.
      Was the Head of USMC intelligence 2009-2013 and was supposed to go over to the CIA but suddenly the assignment was changed and he was moved to CG, USMC Cyberspace Forces, NSA. He was CG Cyberspace command Ft Meade/NSA 2013-2015, and leading up to the 2016 election when General Mike Flynn was removed, guess who took General Flynn’s place as head of the DIA? (Defense Intelligence Agency). Why, none other than Stewart. There was alot that went on at DIA during this timeframe under Stewart’s “Command” that hopefully will come out in the declass.

  5. Papoose says:

    I heard our President say, today, it was a Coup.
    CONSTITUTIONAL Crises in the first degree.
    Yeah, they want President’s entire Family’s Financial records, but, Barry Soetero can seal his bona fides.
    They had BIGLY plans for the 2016 Olympics in Chicago… crooks and slumlords…

    • vikingmom says:

      Will never forget the look on his face when Chicago lost in the first round of voting by the IOC! Bahahaha!!

    • Rex70 says:

      I wonder–and for over a decade, hardly any media outlet ever did or does–about Valerie Jarrett and whether she still, literally, resides in the 0bama’s Washington, D.C. house…??? Why did she move in with the 0bamas in the first place (imagine if Karl Rove had moved in with Dubya and Laura immediately after 43’s Presidential term ended)? What was and is she actually doing there? Justice will not be served completely unless her activities over, at least, the last 10 years are exposed with all of the other nefarious, 0bama hard-leftists–because VJar certainly is one if them and always has been.

  6. grandmotherpatriot says:

    Excellent Sundance!
    A ton of information here that I will read on the plane tomorrow.

  7. Gadsden says:

    Let’s not forget how Petraeus was taken out even prior to this. His email was being surveilled supposedly based on a tip from a woman who was receiving jealous emails from his mistress. This woman had been to the White House and had attended a symposium with John Kerry…what a coincidence! ?

    • Rudolph says:

      Yes, Petraeus’ downfall always smelled foul. He bowed out without any resistance. I also think of Obama’s Illinois State Senate opponent Ryan, whose divorce records were unsealed to take him out of the race.

  8. vikingmom says:

    I want to see Admiral Mike Rogers presented with the Medal of Freedom when this is all said and done!!

    • lolli says:

      And it took tremendous courage for Nunez to come out early and reveal what he saw. He held all this time. Good man.

    • Bing says:

      I like that, but I wonder who the compliance officer was that alerted Admiral Rodgers. Was the compliance officer new to the post? If they were not new to the post what caused the sudden concern, if the abuse had been on going for years. Something drastic changed in early 2016 and it may have been that a new compliance officer is also a hero along side Admiral Rodgers.

  9. I wouldn’t be surprised to see that they monetized these searches as a lucrative private “research” business

    • The Boss says:

      I suspect that is exactly what Glenn Simpson did.

      • sundance says:

        Agree with both. 100%

        • The dirt Obama harvested on our Judges and Members of Congress to blackmail and extort is likely massive.
          This dirt has likely been copied and recopied in multiple repositories.
          Every single “victim” remains COMPROMISED.
          They cannot be fired.
          IMO there is only one solution:
          PUBLISH the dirt on every single person who has been compromised to eliminate the possibility of future actions to abuse their offices or undermine the country.
          Then leave it to Congress to Impeach the Judges and Voters to Replace the Congress.

          • Maquis says:

            It’s the only way.
            The revelations will explain many actions and “rulings” of those that betrayed this nation and feigned honor rather than defy the extortionists.

            • A true treasure trove for do-overs.

              • trnathens says:

                Have you truly thought of the consequences, global in effect, psyche-shifting, complete disconnect to reality, violent reaction is going to take place?
                Listen, when Comey, and Brendan, and Clapper said that declassification would destroy our country…they weren’t lying. Step back from the political “win”. What does the rest of the world see? Chaos, civil unrest, courts, legislators, Congress, the Office of President…all compromised, in a big way. Are we strong enough to retain the trust of our allies? Will our enemies pounce (is the China decouple really a way to take away ALL Chinese leverage that WOULD have existed, but for the decoupling?, if they thought we were mortally weak after it is revealed that for years, if not decades there has been a shadow government run by, controlled by, and blackmailed by the Intelligence Community?!
                Why do you think the reveal had been slow?! And enough with the “why isn’t everyone in jail!” PDJT and his team are figuring out how to destroy and quick rebuild our nation from the ground up. I did not believe this is hyperbole. And they MUST be prepared for every contingency: economic, military, whatever.
                It’s coming, it’s big, it’s ugly, and it’s going to take a lot of backbone to get through. Pray, and have Faith.

                • trnathens says:

                  By “destroy” I simply meant reveal the depth and level of corruption, thereby causing the collapse of the Democratic party, and quite a few Republicans as well. I meant shock the system to the core. I did NOT mean destroy in any negative way or connotation. I apologize if any such reference seemed implied or explicit.

                • RE: PDJT and his team are figuring out how to destroy and quick rebuild our nation from the ground up.
                  … immediately following the 2020 Tsunami Election that will remove Demo☭rats from power at both Federal and State level.

          • MTeresa says:

            I think maybe a better way of handling that information is to let the “victim” know that their information is out there and then let them decide what they want to do (resign or fess up). Not exactly the most stellar choices but broad brush publishing victimizes the victim a second time. It’s possible that a lot of good people could be destroyed. Some of these people may have been entrapped.

            • Resignations leave room for return.
              Why would we allow compromised people into positions of power.
              We’ll never know what OTHER DIRT we haven’t discovered.
              America MUST learn the scale and scope of the corruption to be shocked into reform.

            • FanGirl says:

              Once they folded to blackmail, they victimized the country and the constitution. IMO, no longer get the victim card.

        • Tom says:

          Very curious to know how Hillary gets pulled into the Steele Dossier if it started out as a launder operation. At some point Hillary gets her henchmen (Sid Blumenthal and Cody Shearer) to feed Steele too. Was Hillary approached by Simpson? Was Hilllary encouraged to join in to obscure the original funding for the Steele Dossier? We’re talking about a den of thieves with no honor.

    • Doppler says:

      I feel that it was inevitable that people with hidden access would monetize that access by selling information on demand to hedge funds, who could easily profit from surveilling CFOs responsible for any publicly traded security. Such access would by itself pay for every nickel ever donated to a political campaign by a hedge fund billionaire, a thousand times over.
      And what would prevent them from doing so? Remember, Peter Strzok’s wife got a promotion within SEC just at the time Strzok was to review the Weiner laptop and pronounce it “clean.”
      If you’re going to buy politicians, why not use them to gain access to global surveillance as well as appoint the senior enforcement personnel supervising any ugly enforcement actions.

  10. montanamel says:

    Keep piling it on…
    Another sleepless night in ‘ol DC tonight… Stock up well, 2 AM rolls around too soon!
    This one will just lead into a full-blown 3-day binge!…
    Check the duty board…there’s going to be some NAT flights soonest…
    Might even route via Moscow…..for the ME destinations….no extradition, eh?
    (It’s only a “technical stop for fuel and toilet cleaning”….but, you can’t be sure when on the run!).

    • donna kovacevic says:

      Nah not Moscow, Putin would eat them up for disgracing Russia and her people. Try it and I would love to see the outcome. Hahaha.

  11. Tall Texan says:

    And yet 64-D Jeff Sessions let Lois Lerner skate (yet again.) This whole mess – spanning 2012 into the Trump Administration – would never have happened had there been accountability for the IRS’ earlier criminality.

    • lolli says:

      Yes Tall Texan, among many other travesties that occurred while Sessions hid under his desk.

    • Gadsden says:

      An interesting question for Barr to look into…who convinced Sessions to recuse himself from 90% of his duties as AG? Where they among the same people who approved FISA warrants etc?

      • Dutchman says:

        If not ‘the same people’, certainly their allies.

      • lolli says:

        I have a little different take on sessions. I know most will not agree, that’s fine, I could easily be wrong.
        I think sessions insisted on being the AG, PT said sessions refused any other position, because he went in knowing he would recuse.
        He recused immediately and PT was out of the country.
        PT told us over and over sessions betrayed him.
        Many ignored PTs warnings.
        Sessions not only recused from Russia crap, he let Rosie run the show.
        Many illegal activities took place while sessions turned his head.
        The raiding of a law office. Louis Lerner. Raid and continous torture of P Manafort
        So much that could have been done if he really loved his country.
        If I am wrong, I truly hope to find out because then I could forgive this man.

    • Perhaps the most important disclosure is the Dirt Obama used to Blackmail Sessions.

  12. lolli says:

    Wow Sundance.
    Thank you for your tenacious investigative writing.
    You are a gift to patriots world wide.
    God bless you in all your endeavors

  13. SpotTheSpook says:

    I wonder if Dan Bongino will rip off this article like he did to the one from last night on his Podcast today. EXACT SAME TALKING POINTS from this: https://theconservativetreehouse.com/2019/05/23/president-trumps-declassification-directive-outlines-specific-process-and-direction/
    Listen to the first 5 minutes: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=8&v=N3oqJmNDtOU
    I wonder where he got all those talking points?

    • joeknuckles says:

      Why complain about a guy that is on the same side? I don’t think Sundance is out for glory anyway (why use a pseudonym if you are looking for fame?). Bongino is a good guy and his entertaining delivery helps to get the word out that much more. Besides, he usually gives credit when he uses somebody else’s stuff. Who knows, maybe they have common sources or come to the same conclusions at times.
      Get over it.

      • SpotTheSpook says:

        You obviously aren’t aware of the twitter spat they had. Ever since, Dan has refused to even mention CTH. Today’s Podcast was an obvious steal with no H/T to SD. It pissed me off so YOU get over it!

        • sickconservative says:

          Really who cares at this point, we need all the source’s speaking about it as we can.

      • CNN_sucks says:

        Agreed. Bongino is our fellow travelers.

    • Gadsden says:

      Dan Bongino has been covering this just as closely as Sundance for years now. He regularly gives credit to CTH when he uses their material, there’s no reason to accuse him of “ripping” anybody off in this case. How about we stay on target and focus our energy where it belongs?

    • Mark McQueen says:

      Let’s not get into some kind of juvenile “blog war”. Not necessary.

    • Ilcon says:

      Yeah he’s a plagiarist. Sundance’s material was how he got started. Hell the thin skinned egoist even blocked him on twitter when he was corrected on some of his material.

    • Vicus says:

      Do you know Sundance’s real name?

  14. purpleibby says:

    Thank you Sundance for your awesome analysis and research. You’re a patriot and doing a great service for your country! TY!

  15. GSparrow says:

    The minority of American citizens and politicians that have been taking this coup seriously and have been trying to expose it and confront the corrupt participants are the kind of people that have kept America strong, democratic and free since its formation. (Sundance is clearly in that group) The Coup participants that tried to depose a POTUS are the exact opposite.
    The media are supposed to be the country’s watchdogs but most seem to be either fools or part of the cover up. The questions at P Trump’s pre-flight presser were mind boggling. Despite their disinterest, the coup was a serious threat to American democracy and if the voters ever believe that a coup against any candidate has just become another political tactic, then democracy or the belief in it would collapse. There are enough despicable tactics, lies and dirty tricks already in politics and voters need to be certain that another coup attempt like this one never has a chance to occur again.
    A/G Barr has an enormous and crucially important task on his shoulders and yet all some of these corrupt reporters can do is question his integrity and impartiality while ignoring the evils that were unleashed on the nation by the zealots in the Obama admin.

    • Rudolph says:

      I can’t understand why Biden is getting a free pass. He needs to be linked to his administration’s corruption and abuse of power. No way should he have a shot at becoming his party’s nominee, let alone POTUS.

  16. sarasotosfan says:

    Now I understand.
    All that exported data, where did it go? Where did the IRS data go?
    Is it possible it was centralized in the DNC server? Is it possible the FBI knew it went there and were covering for the DNC when they said the exported material had been deleted?
    Now I understand the panic because that data would certainly provide a much better picture of how long pervasive abuse occurred and who knew about it.

    • joeknuckles says:

      It now resides in Obama’s operation center.

    • TheLastDemocrat says:

      This is a lot of data we are talking about.
      If we are talking about: IRS records, plus a few more similarly large data sets, this is a very big data base. You cannot just plop it on a 12 terabyte hard drive and examine it with Excel.
      If it is outside of NSA now, with ValJar as chief “administrator,” they have to have IT experts keeping it safe from hackers, keeping the processors cool, and polling any data out of it…

    • Rhoda R says:

      And it may explain why the DNC didn’t want the FBI to do a forensic investigation on their ‘hacked’ server.

    • distracted2 says:

      This would explain so much. All of their actions regarding the server made them look like a bunch of Keystone cops. And they knew it made them look like Keystone cops. Yet they did it anyway because they had no choice.

  17. mtk says:

    The FBI contractors were conducting searches and then removing, or ‘exporting’, the results. Later on, the FBI said all of the exported material was deleted.
    With my understanding SQL, exporting has two meanings, and is throughly left ambitious.
    Exporting does mean the search results “image” is copied, however, exporting can also as easily mean “cut” from the database.
    In addition, the lengthy discussion leads one to believe these contractors where searching only political opponents, i.e. looking for intelligence, or dirt on them.
    Nothing can be further the truth. As in searching on allied political individuals, and removing inconvenient or even criminal activities from the database.
    Just saying. It is a two way street.

    • grandmotherpatriot says:

      Obama is from the Chicago Political Machine. The IRS is not a Two-way street for anyone let alone a President of the United States to access information.
      We have the right to privacy and clearly, Conservatives were targeted and spied on by Obama and company.

      • mtk says:

        To clarify, I am suggestion two observations based on what I just read and have read in the pass.
        It is based on more than just minimal passing knowledge of database servers and sql commands.
        The first is the discussions and articles on the FISA abuse across a wide range media reporting.
        All the reports are viewing the nature of these contracted users of the FISA(702)(16)(17) as a one way street. That of looking for dirt on political opponents.
        While that is true.
        My “Nothing could be further from the truth” statement is a two-way street observation.
        These contractors could also have been searching for incriminating intelligence that was swept up by the NSA and removing it.
        Second, while it is quite hard to put into layman terms, I am also suggesting that these contracted analysts could have been using their own tools to access the NSA databases, either through the credentials granted to them to acess the databases, or by having fraudulently attained credentials in addition the contracted credentials to do administrative tasks on the databases with the returned ‘image’ of the search results.
        While it is very likely the custodians of the NSA databases have safe guards in place, technically by starting with the observation that these contractors where not showing up for work in the Pentagon with some security officer looking their shoulders, but that they where remotely acessing the database. Then add the possibility they may have been proxying to the Database server through a trusted network. At that point, anything and everything I am suggesting is MOST definately within the capacity of someone who has an inside knowledge of the workings and failsafes of the NSA database servers.
        As in exporting(still not sure) if this means making a copy of the database records OR sending a SQL command to the server to remove(delete) them.

        • grandmotherpatriot says:

          Great point!
          Excellent post.
          Getting ready to fly out for the weekend. Will follow up with a more detailed response after my flight tomorrow.

        • Zorro says:

          Interesting. If contractors had CRUD abilities beside READ it adds a whole new level of FUBAR.

          • Bubba Cow says:

            why would contractors have CRUD permissions? makes no sense to remove the data because of future data needs, even your own

      • clive hoskin says:

        There only seems to be”Privacy”if your a DemocRAT.Why is that?Maybe we should”Investigate”some of these DemocRATS and RINO”s and find out how they are becoming”Multi-Millionaires”whilst in”Congress”Since they seem to be able to do it to the President and ALL his family and associates,why not them?

    • mtk says:

      Just because the NSA has these search tools pre-built for servlet/http requests and responces along with servlet/http visualization of queries on the NSA databases.
      Does not mean that these contractors where using them, they could have been using their own tools that provided additional functionality.
      It is all based on credentials/privileges, the tech industry calls it handshaking.
      Once the credentials are verified, access/premission is granted.
      To recap the search tool inquiries known as FISA(702)(16)(17), are essentially web browser based applications designed to interact with a Database Server. This server has zero, I repeat zero to do with http/tcpip server. Yes, very often it is intrograted into the http/tcpip server.
      However, theoretically once credentials along with level of privileges are verified, the full range of SQL commands can be sent to the database server.

  18. Carson Napier says:

    And so it came to pass that Barack Obama fundamentally transformed America by waving his magic wand and turning the FBI into the Gestapo, the CIA into the KGB and the FISA Court into a Dark Ages Star Chamber. If history is accurately written, this will be the retrograde throwback Barack Obama’s legacy.

  19. SD, thanks for the crystal clear and detailed (though lengthy) explanation and analysis of the corrupt Ozero White House.
    Looks like PDJT gave Barr releasing authority (allowing Barr to bypassing Coates). Also Barr will be releasing more than just Spygate. Emailgate? U1gate?
    Gate this and gate that evil doers!

    • mr.piddles says:

      I got yer gate right heeyuh!
      I’ll take what’s behind Gate Number Three, Monty!

  20. hoghead says:

    The sotero gang didn’t lose their virginity on the 2016 campaign did they? Since sotero won in 2012, we have no idea what was “investigated” then, do we? And mit romney is pro-deep state. Even after they scrud him in 2012. (Unless, of course, he was scripted to “lose” to sotero.)
    And who else was “investigated” in 2016? Was the sotero gang so sure that DJT would be the nominee that they saw no need to “investigate” other candidates? Like maybe Sen. Cruz?
    These bolsheviks just can’t help themselves…all that private information floating around out there, and someone should be looking at it!
    I am going to greatly enjoy watching these vermin get a dose of Justice.

    • Mittens colluded with Zero to give him the election. I wonder what Zero promised him.

    • Revelation says:

      You dont think Barry had his thugs go up Trump’s wazoo after the birther nonsense?

      • Joemama says:

        First of all the birther thing was not nonsense. Obama is a Kenyan, not an American. His college education was paid for by saudi royalty. He is a complete fraud and a sexual deviant.
        And yes, the deep state totally attacked our Extremely Stable Genius President Donald J. Trump, but they never got “up his wazoo”.
        No, Obama took it up the wazoo from his semi-transgender “wife” Michael.

    • chuckyschmucky says:

      The sotero gang didn’t lose their virginity on the 2016 campaign did they?
      We know for a fact that they were caught illegally spying on reporters, members of Congress and, of course, the Trump campaign.
      These were merely the few times they were caught. Anybody think those were the only times they engaged in this criminal behavior?
      No, it’s quite clear that they had been doing it for so long and had become so efficient at it that it became almost routine for them. And on the rare occasion they got caught, the corrupt leftwing media gave them a minor slap on the wrist and moved right along. And the hapless Republicans in Congress did nothing to stop it.
      Nobody was holding them accountable, so there was no reason for them to stop doing it. That’s why I expect they got a bit complacent and left a trail of evidence behind.

  21. simicharmed says:

    Actually…WE do not know ANYTHING about this former “Obama Candidate”. A Manchurian Candidate indeed.
    This Obama creature remains “unknown” and I believe revealing his actual true history would damage the Nation….sadly.
    The historic future will indeed reveal this imposter…but “we” (as a Nation), are not ready for such “reality”.
    Imagine the wide-range damage revealing this imposter would create throughout the US and the World….(imposter signed 1000’s of documents. etc).

    • Gadsden says:

      I believe he was a Manchurian Candidate, but for the CIA/CFR etc. apparently his grandmother and mother had CIA connections. How many pothead college students gain a former NSA Director as a mentor at the age of 20? I theorize that he was groomed from a young age to be president.

    • Mark L. says:

      And I always thought the sordid history of ancient Rome was a marker in human History.
      When this all unfolds, shall we fair any better

    • TheLastDemocrat says:

      Either way, we voted him in.
      I would not be too skeptical of any claims of voter fraud for either of his elections, but I do believe he had enough votes to win, legitimately. There was a LOT of excitement in primary voting, and post-primary voting caucusing, over on our (D) side of the school cafeteria. Like I had never seen, and my childhood memories include hanging out as my parents served as volunteers at the polls for most elections.
      Frankly, if he were to be proven ineligible to be president, I doubt anything would get reversed or annulled. It would be nice to have it all go in the history books, however.

    • donna kovacevic says:

      Many of us knew what Obama was all about, please give people more credit, I mean people with some grey matter outside the USA

  22. Kleen says:

    I wonder if Justice Roberts was one of Obama’s spy victims?
    Who else?
    I hope many celebrities were victims, lol!

  23. The Boss says:

    The discussion of the footnote re: “deliberate decision making” and “inter agency memorandum of understanding” brings to mind a more recent example of the same “things”. Specifically, the deliberate, written plan (reported here) to bring impeachment proceedings against the president by changing House and committee rules AND having key committee chairs execute MOUs.
    I’ll put up a dozen donuts and say that the illegal spying process not only served as inspiration for the current House conspiracy, but also the same people are involved in laying the groundwork for Pelosi and her flying monkey committee chairs to impeach the president.

    • mr.piddles says:

      Well, I *do* like donuts…
      But I think everything we’ve been seeing starting 12AM Nov 9, 2016 is a complex scheme to obfuscate and misdirect in order to ultimately protect The Obama Administration, and specifically the man himself. The Big Donkey in the room is that everybody knows, and has known for a while, where all the arrows point. And articles like Sundance’s above, and T.V. commentary from the likes of Sara Carter are jus bold enough to cut through The Crap that nobody wants to cut through (because it’s complicated and fairly disturbing). So instead we need to talk about Russia and Obstruction Of Justice and Wells Fargo and Porn Stars and Taxi Medallions and Two Scoops Of Vanilla Ice Cream and Dot Dot Dot. I give Adam Schiff credit for one thing: he’s at least TRYING. I mean, that guy is COMMITTED. He’s taking his role in this whole charade SERIOUSLY (for example, his recent 180-Degree Projection Tweet). But other than that, I don’t particularly care for the man.

      • donna kovacevic says:

        I can’t help myself when you said donkey, in serbian, Magarac, and often referred to a lazy, uneducated,primitive peasant with no brain cells. Sorry but I had a chuckle when I read it.

      • Joemama says:

        Are you saying that you support the pedophile schiff? Please elucidate.
        Schiff in my world is evil incarnate.

  24. sarasotosfan says:

    I’d like to wager the DNC obtained Trump’s tax returns and have already done an autopsy on them. The only obstacle they have yet to clear is permission to obtain them legally.

    • Mark L. says:


    • mr.piddles says:

      I asked my daughter’s Magic Eight Ball: “Have Trump’s tax returns already been leaked by IRS Deep State Insiders?”
      The response (I kid you not… and, yes, I was surprised): “Use your brain, dipsh*t”

    • snarkybeach says:

      and there is nothing there the evil Dems can use to advance their agenda

  25. Kleen says:

    Scandal free Obama.
    Obama’s botched communist takeover.

    • woohoowee says:

      The Commies were actually insane enough to think their one party state was fait acccompli.

  26. Excellent work as always from the master, Sundance. The treachery that was taking place during the Hussein administration is bone chilling. God bless and keep our President Trump.

  27. buanadha says:

    Following this website for quite some time and paying attention to what the Obama administration was doing all of those years has pushed me so strongly in this direction. It was only a matter of time, IMO, before it became clear that there wasn’t a single decision, vote or activity by Washington that wasn’t likely to have been gotten by illegal surveillance and leverage.
    The Rot started long before, but Obama was probably the most corrupt person to have ever been President.. and that’s saying a lot

    • distracted2 says:

      I agree that the rot started long before. The Democrats have a long history of choosing their candidate for the presidency, just as Sundance outlined this week. Their choice had to be someone who would continue the rot, which is another reason Biden is expecting this to be “his turn”.
      Remember when Hillary said, “They were never going to let me be President”? She had agreed to allow the status quo just so she could be the first female president.
      There was just one problem with their plan: “They” never thought for one minute the American public would wake up and choose the right person for the job – someone who cannot be controlled.

  28. History Teacher says:

    Just wow!
    Stunning when the granular details are exposed and a timeline and motives are overlaid.
    But so depressing and disheartening seeing all the cold, Machiavellian cynicism at the heart of the government institutions.
    This was the day to day, ‘business as usual’ operational activity orchestrated by the ‘community organizer.’ If not treason, then what the h*’ll is it?
    I seriously think that a national referendum about extending this presidential term at least two more years should be considered.
    The level of treason is unprecedented, and this administration has been held hostage like no other. If/when the exposure is complete and irrefutable then we enter new unexplored frontiers. A clean slate and new beginning need not wait till 2020. Years have been wasted with the intentional disruption of normal governance.
    The globalists will still have won a partial victory by obstructing and distracting with their witch hunt. It will be at least three years or more while this circus eats up time and focus. The President earned a four year term to govern. While still in his prime and healthy he has been handicapped from full on action.
    Time lost should now be recovered and extended. And future MAGA disciples need to be fully ready to enter the fray when necessary.

  29. Asciimom says:

    So why cant the doj good guys query the 702 database using search criteria of Brennan, Comey, Jarrett etc ?

  30. Heika says:

    My bet has been for some time that Obama won the 2012 election as a result of meddling that was already going on prior. I know the ‘contender’ was hardly desirable, but who was ‘knocked out’ due to scandal prior (the Republicans) through something leaking or some accusation. Was a viable contender to Obama ruined before the final race as a result of some internal plot like what was attempted on Trump?

  31. Kleen says:

    Anyone else believes RINOs took advantage of the same abuse of power to destroy Tea Party candidates?
    I do, I think many RINOs are acting really strange, right Romney? Unprecedented attacks againt a POTUS. Getting cozy with fake news/ propagandists. That never happened before.
    Ryan leaving so soon when most politicians in the club stay until they become dead zombies like Pelosi.

  32. Retired USMC says:

    Sounds like a Barr-B-Q! I have some BBQ ‘Rat please….on a STICK.

  33. Marco says:

    We were waiting for THE BIG UGLY!
    But it turns out we are going to get THE REALLY BIG UGLY!!
    No, looks like we are going to get THE THERMONUCLEAR REALLY BIG UGLY!!!!

  34. woohoowee says:

    Yep, the creation of the Steele Dossier was the cover-up and Campaign Crooked paid for it!

    • konagirl says:

      Thanks Sundance for re-posting. I was just arguing with my husband about what declassification can mean to our knowledge. He accused me of falling for conspiracy theories. I accuse him of being brainwashed by MSNBC (he listens 22 hours a day, sometimes more). I’ll give him copy of this and see if he reads. It’s hard not to talk politics with him anymore, but impossible for last 3 years or so.

      • I have the same problem with my husband. He laughed at me for believing conspiracy theories. But once the Mueller report came out it truly dawned on him that he’s the one who believed in conspiracy theories. He was a never Trumper and voted for Hillary but L think he’s voting for Trump next time.

  35. Kleen says:

    Fake news was in neck deep into this coup. They tried.
    Amorosa, and just about any mentally unstable clown like Creepy Porn Lawyer received all the air time they wanted.
    Obama’s Pravda even sided with the Korean teletubbie Kim Jon Un.

  36. Heika says:

    We need more courage like this below, where the woman used by Halper and ‘Sir Richard Dearlove’ as a so called honeytrap as hit back. Dearlove is the former head of the British Secret Service – their CIA, is there any wonder he was working alongside Halper to bring down Flynn? We need more than bucket 5 opened… we need to smash the whole filthy cesspool apart. Will their ‘methods’ for gaining the so called IC be revealed? They should, but they wont I imagine in the first round, however surely Brennan’s so called intelligence used to justify the first FISA would need to include evidence of some sort (if as he says he didnt use the Dossier). I want to know how much, and I hope Barr is more curious than ‘taking it at face value’.
    Sunlight is the only thing that will sort this out. Barr must be able to be brave and NOT back down for the sake of justice. He has to make a decision on what road he is going to take. That of Justice or that of ‘coverup and damage control.
    Good opening there… describes the whole gang of them. I wish her well. https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019-05-24/ratfuker-and-spy-stefan-halper-sued-cambridge-academic-smeared-flynns-honeypot

  37. ?Gunny66 says:

    I understand the Documents / de-classification..
    But….Here is the question:
    If these people were gathering all this information, everyday….for years…it also has to be on a computer / computers somewhere…All these directive and files must be on computers
    Where are those computers?…Would they still exist?
    If so, even if erased….can all of the information be recovered?
    Can you just imagine:
    Where is Judge Scalia going to be on a certain date?.
    What do we have on Roberts?… activate McCain…..force Merkell to allow the Muslims in….

  38. GuessAgain says:

    I wonder? Can/will the NSA database/FISA warrants be used to investigate all suspects?

  39. Deplorable_Vespucciland says:

    “Inventor and software designer Dennis Montgomery, a CIA/DOD/DHS/NSA/FBI contractor-turned-whistleblower, alerted FBI Director James Comey’s office in 2015 that President Obama’s CIA chief John Brennan and Obama’s DNI James Clapper had turned the super-surveillance system that Montgomery designed for foreign surveillance known as THE HAMMER into a domestic surveillance system. Montgomery became alarmed when Obama and his intelligence chiefs Brennan and Clapper turned the super-surveillance system against Americans.
    Montgomery asserts that Obama, Brennan, and Clapper used THE HAMMER in a diabolically intrusive manner in order to spy on American people and collect massive amounts of surveillance data for leverage and blackmail. THE HAMMER was supposed to be only used for foreign surveillance; not to be weaponized for domestic surveillance against Americans
    According to U.S. military sources, Montgomery’s surveillance technology not only saved American lives as America’s War on Terror broadened, but also featured built-in safeguards to prevent the system from ever being used for domestic surveillance. Multiple echelons of government, including the FISA court, had to sign off on each and every foreign surveillance operation conducted with the use of THE HAMMER, those sources say.
    Montgomery claims that Brennan and Clapper even used the super-surveillance system to spy on ——-> Federal Judges including the onetime head of the FISA court Judge Reggie Walton, US Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, and Chief Justice of US Supreme Court John Roberts.” ~ TheAmericanReportDotOrg
    Sure, we spied on Trump. Whatcha gonna do about it? (March 2017)
    EvelynFarkas spinning up the Russia Hoax and bragging to her MS13NBC friends what she told her spook pals “Get as much information as you can. Get as much intelligence as you can before President Obama leaves the administration because I have the fear that somehow that information would disappear with the senior people who left. So it would be hidden away in the bureaucracy, umm, that the Trump folks if they found out how we knew what we knew about their, the staff, the Trump staff dealing with Russians; that they would try to compromise those sources & methods, meaning we would no longer have access to that intelligence.”

    • TheLastDemocrat says:

      Montgomery warns in 2015.
      And so the bad guys figure two work-arounds:
      1. Open an investigation of foreigners, and trip across Americans along the way.
      2. Examine USA data through a foreign intelligence ally.

  40. All Too Much says:

    This river sure runs deep.
    Who knew 504c-gate would lead to Operation Crossfire, and related -gates.
    SD finding the trail back to 2010 is magnum cum laude analytical work. I just appreciate being allowed to sit in on the lectures.

  41. Mercenary says:

    Isn’t this essentially what former CBS reporter Sharyl Attkisson said?
    That the biggest reason they pulled the trigger on the coup was because they couldn’t afford for Trump to look into what they’d been doing for years?
    She basically said they’d been doing it way before 2016. Who was hacking her computer? Who was spying on her?
    What about journalist Michael Hastings who died under suspicious circumstances in June 2013?
    I think 2012 is an excellent starting point, considering Obama had just won re-election and they knew they would have the entire executive branch for the rest of his last term. If I was a subversive dictator, that’s when I activate all of the illegal police state programs I’ve wanted to do.
    Brennan comes in on March 2013.
    We may learn that they were basically spying on all of Obama’s enemies – journalists, politicians, cultural figures, judges, etc.. ALL OF THEM. I think Sharyl Attkisson is correct.

    • Jim in TN says:

      Obama spied on his friends. Democrat Senators. Of course he spied on all of his enemies.

      • Mercenary says:

        I’m glad you so cavalierly accuse Obama of committing multiple felonies.

        • mac says:

          He’s dirty as Hell and YOU KNOW IT.

          • Mercenary says:

            I think the reason conservatives are not taken seriously sometimes is because they don’t weigh their words carefully. Simply stating that a President committed multiple felonies as a matter of fact is pretty ridiculous. We may all suspect it, but let’s stick to the known facts. It just makes you look non-credible otherwise.

        • chuckyschmucky says:

          Well, we know his administration illegally spied on Dianne Feinstein. Of course, Brennan denied it until the facts proved otherwise, and he later admitted it.
          So, it’s just a fact that his administration spied on Democrat Senators.
          And, as Jim in TN notes, if he spied on his “friends,” do you doubt he spied on his enemies?

          • Mercenary says:

            I may speculate, but I don’t definitively state as fact that a US President committed multiple felonies. It’s kind of a big deal. Maybe we should weigh our words.

  42. Ketchikan says:

    Operation Hammer

  43. Kleen says:

    Can Obama still be “peeched” ( low IQ Maxine)
    That would be funny!

    • KnowSERENoFear says:

      Sure can. US Grant’s Sec of War handed in his resignation minutes before the House impeached him…it stuck. Later the Senate acquitted him…but the precedent was made…one can be impeached post facto. An impeached person can never serve public office…or even consult with the government EVER again.

      • Rhoda R says:

        A person found GUILTY as a result of the impeachment process. Being impeached in and of itself is nothing more that an indictment. The actual trial is in the Senate.

  44. ichicinnabar says:

    Thank you for your exhaustive and detailed research. I pray that history will credit you for your piviral role in this revolution.
    Many of us have suspected this for a while. Bongino has been hinting at it as well. They were just too practiced and comfortable with this scam for it to be their first time.
    They were so confident because they had been getting away with it for years.

  45. butch cassidy says:

    Wow! If Barr does what we hope/expect him to do, he might just go down in history as one of the most patriotic Americans ever. Sure hope he has a little vanity in him.

    • mr.piddles says:

      I was JUST thinking along those same lines last night…
      AG Barr is in a position to go down as a KEY FIGURE in the Nation’s History. Dare I say: a notch above President Trump himself (‘scuse me while I put on this flame-retardant jumpsuit). This is like Turning Point level stuff… and if Barr CLEANS HOUSE and effectuates a TOTAL RESET for that which needs resetting… Hoo boy… that’s quite the legacy. Of course, it WILL have to be a team effort. :^)

      • butch cassidy says:

        Piddles, and just think if some hot shot Wapo/NYT reporter decides to do the right thing and exposes even more for the public, this would even put more pressure on Barr and others. Indictments are nice but to have all this exposed by the msm would be the cherry on top. Maybe that’s too much wishful thinking on my part.

  46. M. B. Lamar says:

    Almighty God, I ask that you bless President Trump and his allies with the strength and wisdom necessary to expose these evil tyrants. The President’s enemies will not willingly cooperate with Barr’s requests. They will fight to the death to conceal their crimes. Give us the fighting spirit and empower us to support our President, as he fights to save our Republic.

  47. Beigun says:

    The stench of the “Banquet of Sedition” carries far and wide. Those that inhale the dream of power usurped become themselves most foul and corrupt. Sedition is the other side of the coin of Treason. The cure for the body politic, while painful, is required to prevent a reoccurrence that would destroy the Republic.
    Now, hang ‘em high!
    Otherwise, the future is dim. 5G, facial & voice recognition, AI surveillance, and robots means game over for the Yellow Vests, Deplorables, and Brexiters. Remember HAL in the classic movie 2001? HAL is in China now and coming to your neighborhood soon!

  48. Jim in TN says:

    The current directive involves the 2016 election only. This may include spying on Jeb! and Bernie etc., but it is not going to include spying on Romney in 2012, or the tax spying in 2010-2012.
    I hope there is enough information for them to expand the totality of the Obama corruption that is revealed.
    But remember, the blackmail victim complies because he doesn’t want the information released either. I noticed that the Lankford questions and Roger’s answers totally avoided mention of the contractors, and of the scope of the surveillance of Americans.
    Lankford also spent the last of his time trying to deceive us into thinking this was all about investigating overseas terrorists with only occasional spying on Americans. Yet 702 is solely about spying on Americans. Notice there were no questions for Roger’s to respond with clarification, and he immediately gave back his time.

  49. “Fusion GPS was not hired in April 2016 to research Donald Trump. As shown in the evidence provided by the FISC, the intelligence community was already doing surveillance and spy operations. The Obama administration already knew everything about the Trump campaign, and were monitoring everything by exploiting the FISA database.”
    I believe this kind of tail-wag-dog backwarded logic is not the natural province of Gd-fearing men and women. I think it’s diabolical logic. Right-minded individuals have to struggle at it.
    Think of devastating natural disasters. Decent people instinctively feel immediate concern. Yet there is a group of folks who, with comparable reflexivity, start devising fraudulent schemes to steal from victims and donors alike. That’s the kind of mind behind the Steele Dossier pretense.

  50. Benedict Comey says:

    Hmm. Is it just me, or is this right about the time Elijah “Captain Underpants 2.0” Cummings’ IRS targeting abuse blew up?

  51. alliwantissometruth says:

    What Sundance has laid out here is the line between right and wrong, with absolutely no grey area in between
    A Republic based on true freedom, one in which honesty, integrity, ethics and the rule of law are above all else, for the good of it’s people, versus a perversion of of the concept, where the corrupt and criminal pervert the system in the name of power and/or ideology
    No matter which side of the political coin one falls, the pure concepts of a true Republic must be adhered to if we the people are to remain free and in charge of our own destinies
    Allowing and/or agreeing with the perversion of the system because one agrees with the corrupt and criminal’s politics/ideology is never righteous, is always wrong and in fact makes one a willing accomplice in the corrupt and criminal acts
    Just as I favor a conservative ideology, I would never want that ideology to gain power via corrupt/criminal acts, as it not only destroys the entire concept of what I believe in, but could also be used to put the ideology I loathe into power in the future
    Freedom, honor, integrity and the right to self governance can never be achieved through corrupt/criminal acts, and those concepts must be in place without interference of politics
    I’d tell my democrat voter friends to think before choosing a side on this issue, as it relates to the kind of country we and our children will live in in the future

  52. clipe says:

    The MSM has gone Washington Postal

  53. Jim in TN says:

    Four options.
    A) Barr stops with direct spying on Trump using Crossfire Hurricane and the run up to CH.
    B) Barr includes spying on other 2016 candidates and Trump with 702’s.
    C) Barr expands 702 abuse to include all abuse mentioned in Collyer’s report.
    D) Barr conducts a massive sweeping investigation into all of Obama’s illegal spying.
    C) & D) are outside the present scope of Trump’s instructions to Barr.
    What would be best, and how can we help make it happen?

    • There’s nothing keeping Barr from following the evidence (as long as it’s credible and follows a logical flow from one piece of evidence to another). Jumping to a new avenue of investigation without sufficient predicate (which is what’s being investigated in the first place) won’t happen with Barr.

    • alligatriot says:

      From the President’s memorandum:
      Section 1. Agency Cooperation.
      The Attorney General is currently conducting a review of intelligence activities relating to the campaigns in the 2016 Presidential election and certain related matters.
      “… and certain related matters.”
      Jim in TN,
      Seems to me that might put C) & D) (and potentially a whole lot more) well within the AG’s scope from the President.

  54. Howard Ellis says:

    I have assumed since 2013 that Dinesh D’Souza was caught up in an abuse of the NSA data back in 2012 as it was far to unlikely that the FBI simply stumbled upon some fishy bank transactions. Far more likely that he was a political target and “they” were reading his texts, email and phone calls looking for dirt and found some.

    • Ospreyzone says:


    • Dutchman says:

      I submit we DON’T KNOW how far this goes, and won’t without an audit going back to day one.
      Is the ‘mindless’ way that corporate media parrots the ‘party line’a result of ideology, or blackmail?
      Don’t NEED to target individual talking heads; get comprompt on the COMPANIES, or the HEADS of the companies.
      RepubliCON party leadership in Congress, get ‘leaders’ of party, in Senate and House, and you control party.
      Court decisions? Compromise the Judge, the ‘prosecutor’ if necessary.
      And their are ‘opinion makers’, people who shape public opinion.
      Once you HAVE this power, and have established as SOP ways to game the system, and get,around the safeguards, why WOULDN’T you USE it, to forward your agenda?
      Silence those opposing your agenda, “help” your allies by using it to target THEIR opponents.
      Nasty business, folks. Nasty business!

      • GB Bari says:

        I think you’re Spot On, Dutch.

      • Chewbarkah says:

        Dutchman — Your first sentence is like a flashing neon sign, telling us something that should be obvious:

    • Jederman says:

      I now see what many of those R house investigations into Benghazi, FF, IRS… went nowhere. obama was likely monitoring the R investigators. One wrong move and he’ll know, then let them know he knows. Chicago, all the way.

      • Dutchman says:

        Reread the emails from the reporters to John Podesta, in this light and its,CHILLING!
        John, (Paraphrasing) am enclosing in attachmentvmy article for youvto review, and let me know if you have any problems with it, or want any changes BEFORE i send it to my EDITOR.
        Please, please don’t sic the FBI on me, for that kiddie porn on my phone. I SWEAR I don’t know how it got there!
        Sincerely, scared shiteless of you and will write WHATEVER you or media matters telks me to, I PROMISE! Just hoping you will keep ourclittle,secret,….secret.
        Signed, one of MANY reporters.

    • TrustyHaste says:

      This was also the same timeframe that “they” were surveilling Sharyl Attkinson’s computers.

    • snarkybeach says:

      Dinesh had a target on his back ever since his Obama movie became the highest grossing documentary of the time.

      • Dutchman says:

        Sheriff Joe, in Az. was a loud ‘birther’, and immigration enforcement advocate, for years.
        Finally a judges ruling just before an election forced him out.
        Then, in 2018 midterms for Senate, in primaries Dr.Kelli Ward, MAGA since before the escalator ride, (and a thorn in the side of State RNC) is running, as is a RINO, McSally.
        Ward SHOULD have won hands down, in a Republican primary in Az. But, Arpio throws his hat in the ring, doesn’t campaign AT ALL. Splits MAGA voters, McSally gets nomination to general.
        MAGA voters, of both the,Arpio and Ward camp stay home, disgusted. A little ballot fraud puts Kirsten Synema over the top.
        WHY did Arpio do that? Lots of rumors of corruption, of Arpio,…..maybe 702 searches uncovered evidence? Coerced.

        • FanGirl says:

          Doesn’t have to be corruption, could have been a secret, a family member’s secret (or made up secret) or something planted/faked. They were deleting stuff off of Sharyl Atkinson computer, then they can put stuff ON your computer.

          • Dutchman says:

            Atkinson said they found stuff, classified material HAD been put on her conputer; they WERE trying to frame her.
            Makes me wonder, how hard would it be to put ‘kiddie porn’on someones computer?
            Its ubiquitous on the I-net, and not only has,Social stigma, but MAJOR legal consequences.
            And so, they go to target, and say your (adult ) son has this on his phone/computer. Do what,we want, we will make you and family rich.
            Otherwise, we,will destroy you and family. Few could withstand.

    • iwasthere says:

      Parallel construction?

    • 22denizen says:

      Very inciteful. I wonder how many more people they ‘closed down’, like D’Souza, I bet there were plenty, some maybe not so well-known, but their lives destroyed never-the-less.

  55. Benedict Comey says:

    I think it goes back a lat further. All the way to the 90s when the “missing” FBI files of political opponents “magically” appeared on Hitlery’s dressing table …

  56. CNN_sucks says:

    If spying started in 2012, John Roberts must have been snagged with surveillance then.

  57. budklatsch says:

    Recall when the Clintons took control of hundreds of FBI files in their first administration.

  58. Jambo says:

    So as soon as Obama got his second term in 2012 it was on for all money with the weaponisation of the intelligence services.
    It worked for the IRS no reason not to expand.
    Literally scares me to think where the USA would have been had Hillary been allowed to continue the march to a police stare.
    All good people dodged a bullet, to the back of the head, at night, from a govt issued weapon.
    Take them all down. Every last corrupt traitor.

    • Jim in TN says:

      2012 is mostly before Obama’s second election.
      That year Roberts decided that no matter how tortured and twisted the logic needed, that ObamaDoesn’tCare was Constitutional.
      And Romney chickened out after the first debate showed he could win.

      • Retired USMC says:

        He didnt chicken out…he took a dive…got to be dirty to be part of the big club…its your blood right. He was told to stand down.

      • Roni says:

        My impressions from the Benghazi portion of the 2012 debate re the term “demonstration” were, the moment Crawley interfered and backed Obama’s claim, Romney seemed uncertain if his facts were accurate so he let Obama slide or, he didn’t want to appear to be aggressive toward a black President…..and it cost him.

        • Dutchman says:

          If it was ONLY that, I might buy that explanation for Romneys behavior, but I don’t at all when I put it in context.
          He’s RINO, if he reached down and pulled off his mask, like,a,scene from Mission Impossible, he’s Obama underneath.
          Ditto Kasich, Flake, Ryan, McConnell, McCarthy, ….

      • grumpyqs says:

        I was watching the night Romney let Candi Crowley of CNN “correct” him on a question that Obama clearly didn’t know. Everyone knew in that moment, including him, that he took a “dive” to let Obama win the debate. Worse acting ever! Romney is NOT interested in our nation!

    • littleanniefannie says:

      Thus Mad Max’s reference to the comprehensive database that Obama had.
      Yep, she outed him!

  59. Holmes says:

    I’ve got to hand it to Sundance. This is just one of many great analyses on his part.
    Not to take anything away John Solomon, Sara Carter, et. al. They do great work and I’m glad they’re on our side. But they have sources feeding them info and telling them what it means.
    Sundance might have sources also. I don’t know. But he DISCERNS the meaning from source documents. Clearly. For the layman. He’s in a league of his own.

    • WSB says:

      Indeed, Holmes. SD makes us all look like Sherlocks at cocktail parties and family dinners!
      Seriously though, the leadership at CTH and SD’s gut honest investigations that Andrew Breitbart ignited are breath taking. We Treepers are truly blessed!
      And we may be saving the last Shining City on the Hill in the process!

    • boogywstew says:

      If there was any justice in this Universe, Sundance would be honored with a Pulitzer Prize.

  60. Do Stop Thinking About Tomorrow says:

    Sunlight sunlight sunlight

  61. sDee says:

    The NSA’s Hidden Spy Hubs in Eight U.S. Cities

    • Landslide says:

      Read alot of the article, not all. Wow. Every communication, search, etc. can be retrieved and also monitored in real-time. The article talks about the 8 AT&T hubs (in the US) that do this. They must have many auxiliary buildings around the country because there is one about 3 miles down the road from me. It has an address, but is “not there” on Google Maps! It is unmarked, gated, and has an occasional AT&T van in the parking lot. I’ve always wondered about it….now I know!

  62. Do Stop Thinking About Tomorrow says:

    These programs must be stop the temptation to defeat ones enemies is so easily justified.

  63. k4jjj says:

    The question is not when did the CIA and FBI begin spying on innocent Americans and sharing the results with political insiders. The question is WHO first ordered these agencies to unlawfully do it and by what authority.
    If that question is not asked and the answer publicly given, the people themselves will have to physically rise up against this tyranny.
    The corrupt actors obviously include judges and the law enforcers who cannot be relied upon to remedy the problem.
    Are these people going to try and argue they were all duped to try and play us for fools? Who would want such scoundrels in authority who dare to argue they were hapless idiots?
    This spying demonstrates the U.S. Constitution is not doing its job to restrain the lawless corruption inside the United States government. If the Constitution has become void, the nation is now void.

    • madeline says:

      Donald J. Trump

      Verified account
      Following Following @realDonaldTrump
      An ‘extremely credible source’ has called my office and told me that @BarackObama’s birth certificate is a fraud.
      1:23 PM – 6 Aug 2012

      • Doreen Scott says:

        I have always believed the spying on President Trump started after he talked about Obama’s fake birth certificate.

      • Pyrthroes says:

        Of course it’s fraudulent– Gangrenous was born in Mombasa, Kenya. But surname DNA attests that he is not the son of a drunken Kenyan goatherd but of Comintern pedophile Frank Marshal Davis, an American citizen– thus a full-blown, birthright U.S. citizen himself.
        Gangrenous’ real problem is that from age six, as an adoptive son of Sunni Muslump Indonesian citizen Lolo Soetoro, he became a naturalized Javanese Indonesian resident of Djakarta– an affiliation which he kept while sliming his way to Ayers-Dohrn “red diaper” terrorist venues in Chicago from about age 22 in 1983. This was for purposes of claiming exotic Foreign Student status on admission to Columbia and Hah-vahd, sponsored by billionaire Saudi Wahabist al-Walid bin Talal as a crypyo-Sunni agent-of-influence under Iranian handler Valerie Jarrett (worth $1.5 billion to Teheran’s Shi’ite mullah-dullahs in 2015).
        Since BHO never filed re-naturalization papers with the U.S. State Department from c. 1983, he remained statutorially ineligible to hold any elective U.S. public office, meaning that –despite all manner of fraudulent identity documents from Bar Exam to Draft Registration to Social Security– his Illinois, U.S. Senate, and U.S. Presidential terms were wholly illegitimate. None of this scuttering Rat’s appointments, no legislation, no official Executive or Legislative acts of any nature, have any validity whatever.
        What’s worse– acknowledging this reality, ie. The Truth, or turning shame-facedly away, fearing to admit the American Nation became a literal tool of Black Supremacists, Marxist terrorists, taqiyya Muslump fanatics for eight solid years? Given Rats’ current and ongoing PCBS project to subvert the current Administration by any-and-all means, the answer’s pretty plain.

    • KnowSERENoFear says:

      The FBI began spying on US citizens in 1908…the CIA in 1947.

  64. Shadrach says:

    This specific footnote, if declassified, would be key. Note the phrase: “([redacted] access to FBI systems was the subject of an interagency memorandum of understanding entered into [redacted])”,
    That second redaction is probably a date, especially since the next sentence says that FISC wasn’t notified until 2016.

    • sundance says:

      Yes I believe that last redaction is: “in 2012”

      • Shadrach says:

        The other interesting thing is that in the pg 87 paste you have in your analysis referring to the same footnote…there are two equal sized redactions. The “BLANK access” and the “BLANK contractors” are the same size and probably the same redaction. Since the latter is referring to an interagency agreement, that second blank is a 3 letter agency. I have my guesses….I wonder if Nellie’s previous employment is relevant. Plus, wasn’t Strozk a detailee from one agency to the other?

        • JIM COMEY IS A WEASEL_DOUG says:

          It’s CIA. That’s what the MOU they were refering to. Giving CIA access to NSA database.

          • Jim in TN says:

            The CIA already has access. But they have strong safeguards to protect us from them.
            They got around the safeguards by using the FBI access. And they had ‘contractors’ do the dirty work.

        • CM-TX says:

          Brennan did give him a certain coin that would suggest this.

    • bgood says:

      contractors &secretly fits too.

  65. Jeffry says:

    Watch Maxine Waters talk about Obama’s secret database from this 2012 interview. I wonder if it the same as the FISA abuse or is it the Hammer, a separate secret surveillance system Obama had put in place.

    • James says:

      I’m pretty sure the FISA abuse is one tentacle of The Hammer, which I see as an octopus that illegally pulled information on private citizens from multiple government databases including the IRS and NSA. Also ran illegal surveillance operations against Congress (confirmed), journalists (confirmed), and probably the Supreme Court (suspected).

    • CaptainNonno says:

      THIS ⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️⬆️

    • Dutchman says:

      Jefry; PLEASE read my responce to James, 4 comments down and stop posting this mis-interpretation of what she is saying.
      Listen to what the INTERVIEWER is saying, put it in context.

  66. Kleen says:

    I know nothing about investigations, FBI, FISC, NSA, or specifics about the agencies.
    But commun sense is enough to know those crooks have been breaking the law for a long time.
    You can tell simply by their arrogance. Hillary never took anything against her serious. The whole time she acted like she was being inconvenienced by these nobodies asking her questions. Condescending as she knew she was exonerated before her testimony.
    Also Comey, Brennan… they acted like they had nothing to worry about.
    Their attitude tells me, the abuse of power was business as usual. No shame, just pure arrogance.

  67. Mncpo(ret) says:

    After this article, the first thing I thought of was a line from the Snowdan (sic) film.
    When he said it would be illegal to spy on a private citizen without a FISC court order. The other person said, (paraphrasing), “That rubber stamp ***** court is a joke.”
    There was NO fear of the FISC among contractors, they knew they had free rein. Hell, they spied on old girlfriends, ex-wives, anybody they chose.
    They ran wild for a decade at least.

  68. James says:

    It’s called The Hammer.
    Here’s Maxine Waters describing it in 2013 … https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIA1lQBqH1s

    • Dutchman says:

      I am sorry James
      And many others,who keep posting a link to this video.
      At CTH, we try to aspire to the high standard that Sundance establishes with his posts, and NOT perpetuate false news.
      Firstly, of ALL thecpeople IN THE WHOLE WORLD, that you would NOT want as an accoplice, Mad Max has,GOT to be,at the top of the list!
      Obama may be crazy, but he ain’t stupid.
      Second, LISTEN not only to what max is saying, ans what you WANT to hear, listen to the CONTEXT; what the INTERVIEWER is asking and clarifying.
      She is talking about a database of DEMOCRAT voters, a 501C organisation that could send an email out to BUNCHES of Democrat voters.
      NOT a secret IC spying database.
      Apples and Oranges, and I wish people would quit perpetuating this false misrepresentation.
      Mad max as a conspirator, don’t make me laugh!

      • FanGirl says:

        The only way she would be let in is if one of her aids found out and told her!


        +100% Dutchman. Obama was building Organizing For America “militias” around the
        country. Not for armed conflict but for rallies, and election foot soldiering. I’ve seen it in my own community where they “organized” weekly protests at my previous congressman’s office and eventually gathered the votes to remove him.
        Take nothing away from these people. They are ruthless, relentless, and effective.

      • BitterC says:

        Yup. That’s the way I’ve always seen it.
        No one would confide such a secret with Max & they were talking voter database

  69. LandonK says:

    Great reporting! So was McCain in on the plot also, or was he a useful dupe just trying to get Trump? As this converges more questions arise.

    • annieoakley says:

      McCain was in on the plot.

      • FanGirl says:

        Was he blackmailed or in on it of his own accord. Could be both, but I don’t think he had to be blackmailed. (Though I’m sure there was material to do so)

        • Dutchman says:

          McStain and his protege graham were very involved in ME plan to destabilise the area, in order to drive 10’s of millions of ‘refugees’ into EU.
          Yeah, I don’t think he needed much coercion, he was already there.

  70. sarasotosfan says:

    Debbie Wasserman Schultz has been tighter than a drum throughout this. She knows all the players.
    I’d leak a rumor of her negotiating an immunity deal and see what gets flushed out.

    • Holmes says:

      “I’d leak a rumor of her negotiating an immunity deal and see what gets flushed out.”
      Ha! Like!
      I’ve said hear and elsewhere that once one or two of the perpetrators gets indicted, the singing will begin. Evidence will pour forth like Niagara Falls.

    • Conservative_302 says:

      I’d like to know why her investigation and crimes went nowhere. She seems as dirty as they come.

  71. Jederman says:

    Mueller, it appears is a big whopping FAIL. As the FBI director during the suspect 2012-… period when the abuses occurred, he is in the blowback burst radius. His fingerprints are likely on this too.
    If, as the SC, he wanted to stop PT and or cover his tracks he whiffed. He as far as we can tell, accomplished nothing more than being a pest.

    • Dutchman says:

      But, if PDJT had done what ANY of us would have done, after Mueller teams actions, (arresting friends, aquaintances, campaign workers and personal lawyer in no knock raids, leaking b.s. to a compliant press, etc.) and FIRED his *ss, you wouldn’t be saying Mueller effort was a failure, and he was just a pest!
      PDJT would have been impeached, for a “Saturday nite massacre” and Repubs in Congress would have “in all good conscionce have voted FOR impeachment.
      Only GOD kept PDJT from throwing Rosie out AF1, without a parachute, cause I sure would have!
      So, Mueller/Weisman was a good TRY, but no cigar. “GEE, what do we gotta do ti get fired, here?” Its a George Costanza moment. They kept prodding the bear, and poking the lion,…and he kept his cool.
      It SHOULDA worked!

  72. Mongo Mere Pawn says:

    June 28, 2012 was the date the Chief Justice saved Obama care by switching his vote and authoring the 5-4 decision. Wonder why he switched his vote? Contractor access to his raw electronic communication data?

  73. trapper says:

    Bookmark this article and send it to your friends. It is a seminal article that explains the whole thing from 30,000 feet. The Steele Dossier is the firewall that is supposed to keep everyone from looking earlier than 2016. That is why the FISC opinion and all its exhibits must be declassified and made public with no redactions.

  74. johneb18 says:

    A veritable tour de force!
    Sundance has no peer! 🙂

  75. Boots says:

    Call me when they start hanging some of these SOB’s. Or when the Regulators are being reactivated.

    • Dutchman says:

      Sorry, but when they start the hangings, I’m gonna be doing some HEAVY celebrating, after praying for their immortal souls, of coarse.
      Not so much I pass out,…don’t want to MISS anything, lol!
      But, doubt I’ll be able to use a phone, to call or text, ….sorry.

  76. Kleen says:

    Undercover Huber Retweeted
    Jordan Schachtel
    Statement from DNI Coats seems to insist the IC is already trying to block declassification efforts, citing “long-established standards to protect highly-sensitive classified information.” Sharing notes with the echo chamber? Trump WH should not allow them to block transparency

  77. Another Scott says:

    2012, now what was happening then? Maybe a presidential election where Mitt Romney started stronger than expected while Barak Obama had a weak performance at the first debate? Seems like there was a magic turnaround for Obama after that….

  78. California Joe says:

    Go for the low-hanging fruit first. Samantha Power’s 400 unmaskings that she swore she didn’t do and that someone used her identity. We now know that she unmasked people who supported Israel because she was Pro-Palestinian! There’s your first target and facing ten years in prison she’ll give you her handlers Susan Rice and Obama!

  79. Dutchman says:

    Not crazy about Gowdy, but even a stopped clock is right, twice a day.
    Paraphrasing, he said “Truthfully, MOST of this information isn’t going to change anyones mind. Those who support Trump will follow it, those who hate Trump won’t change their minds because of Spygate.
    And, unfortunately he’s right. Particularly with media bias, and TDS most of this won’t change anyones mind.
    He went on to say HE thought there were,some PapaD transcripts that were totally exculpatory, and he thought would change minds. Personally I doubt it, cause many won’t care.
    But THIS, that,Sundance has posted, it seems to me has SOME potential. Has NOTHING to do with “Trump”, as he wasn’t running in 2012!
    IF it is exposed that elements within the U.S. Govt. were spying on Americans and using the info to blackmail/coerce public figures in order to facilitate policy outcomes (politics) that MAY just break through the TDS.
    Or, maybe nothing can. Maybe its “hearts and minds”, won over one at a time, as each person reaches their red pill moment?
    TDS is the symptom, Russia collusion is the virus, spygate is the infected needle.
    Is SUNLIGHT the CURE? I pray so,…

  80. Dutchman says:

    Not crazy about Gowdy, but even a stopped clock is right, twice a day.
    Paraphrasing, he said “Truthfully, MOST of this information isn’t going to change anyones mind. Those who support Trump will follow it, those who hate Trump won’t change their minds because of Spygate.
    And, unfortunately he’s right. Particularly with media bias, and TDS most of this won’t change anyones mind.
    He went on to say HE thought there were,some PapaD transcripts that were totally exculpatory, and he thought would change minds. Personally I doubt it, cause many won’t care.
    But THIS, that,Sundance has posted, it seems to me has SOME potential. Has NOTHING to do with “Trump”, as he wasn’t running in 2012!
    IF it is exposed that elements within the U.S. Govt. were spying on Americans and using the info to blackmail/coerce public figures in order to facilitate policy outcomes (politics) that MAY just break through the TDS.
    Or, maybe nothing can. Maybe its “hearts and minds”, won over one at a time, as each person reaches their red pill moment?
    TDS is the symptom, Russia collusion is the virus, spygate is the infected needle.
    Is SUNLIGHT the CURE? I pray so,…

    • KnowSERENoFear says:

      Perhaps a good inroad to those with TDS and D’s Is to show that Obama spied on Bernie. Obama talked Bernie into getting out of the race…blackmail?

      • Dutchman says:

        After whats already known (from the DNC and DNCC emails published by wikileaks) of what Hillary did to Bernie and his supporters, any Bernie supporter that still votes D, is a lost cause.
        They used the FBI, and threatened his wife over that bogus land swap deal for the University. Didn’t need the NSA database for that.

  81. wageslave231 says:

    Unreal. And this is just the spying that occurred by Obongo and his lackeys– you can bet the 5 eyes also were also in on this.

  82. Thomas Holsinger says:

    I just saw this on the Free Republic and put the link here for discussion. I never heard of this before and have no clue as to its credibility.

  83. Frederick Miller says:

    Interesting that PDJT’s Memo authorizing that the department’s cooperate with Barr and reclassified also included Dept of Energy (Uranium One?)

  84. Frederick Miller says:


  85. FanGirl says:

    Thank you for posting this. Did not see first time.

  86. Smarty says:

    2012? Obamacare ruling? Judge Roberts ruling like he was blackmailed into verbal gymnastics?

    • madeline says:

      March 23, 2010
      The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA), often shortened to the Affordable Care Act (ACA) or nicknamed Obamacare, is a United States federal statute enacted by the 111th United States Congress and signed into law by President Barack Obama on March 23, 2010.

  87. Jenevive says:

    I wonder we have been told we would be shocked
    by some of the unmasking.. It is likely they were spying
    on the Trump family even FLOTUS but I wonder if they
    went so far as to do it to Barron.. unmasking him..There would
    be no credible explanation they could give for that..
    I think people on both sides would be upset about that one.

    • annieoakley says:

      The Dems could will never be upset about any spying. It is likely they were and still are spying on everyone. They probably broke up Donald Jr’s marriage by scaring his wife and she was terrified that they would go after their children too.

    • Paulie says:

      Don’t kid yourself.

    • Conservative_302 says:

      They used Flynn Jr. To threaten Flynn. Any kind of leverage. They people are evil.

  88. Mac says:

    The IC and DOJ/FBI illegal surveillance operation was one of the reasons why the the Trump insurance project was run. But, do not put on blinders to as to the extent of the activities which caused this.
    In 2016, Adm. Rogers shut down the 702(16)(17) system at the NSA. If the Obama Administration had stopped then, it is very likely that that would have been the end of that matter. At worst, some middle management types would have been fired or, possibly, indicted. But, the upper level people would not have been touched. The bureaucracy would have stonewalled, as they have in the past, and it would be largely ignored or forgotten. After all, the FBI surveilled JFKennedy and MLKing and a number of other political figures and nothing ever came of it. So, what was different in 2016? Was it Trump? Perhaps. Trump was less likely to be subject to political pressure than career politicians. Was it Trump’s supporters calling for HRClinton’s imprisonment over Servergate? Wwweelll…
    The best way to do this investigation is to backtrack. Start with the Mueller report and work backward. Who was involved in the operation at that time? What motivation did, or might, they have for their actions. Then it is investigation of how we ended up with a SC investigation which was merely the moving of the entire Crossfire Hurricane CoInt operation and the Trump obstruction of justice investigation, which McCabe opened following the firing of Jim Comey, from the FBI/DOJ to the SC. Who orchestrated the firing of Comey, the establishment of the SC and recruited Mueller as SC? Keep going backward to Comey’s excusing HRC’s actions in the Servergate operation. Why would he do that, after the case had been ignored for almost three years [2012-2015]? Why attempt to gain FISA coverage for FUTURE electronic surveillance? These warrants will have NO effect on previous illegal acts of surveillance. Why place everything at risk by basing the warrant applications on a “dossier” which was not only totally unverified, but was filled with inaccuracies? Go back to the origins of the dossier. Who compiled the dossier? Who was involved in the funding and dissemination of the dossier? Where did the supposed intelligence come from to establish the possibility of Russian involvement with the Trump campaign? Finally, which people were involved in this operation who also directly benefited from it? Once you get to that point, you are going to find a number of off-shoots; Uranium One, Benghazi [the CIA/DoS operation, not the massacre], the support for the Syrian Civil War, and a host of other scandals. While political surveillance was one of the scandals involved in the insurance policy, it was not the sole reason, nor was it the triggering one.

  89. Brant says:

    A light bulb for me from one of the comments. There have been big populist wins in other countries recently. Why? Sure, popular uprising, but also no intel swaps from US. The info pipeline has dried up. The results speak for themselves…….and will only continue and expand……

    • Brant says:

      Or they have been reversed…….I kinda hope not that…..only kinda since there has been cheating on the other side for decades.

  90. Absolutely amazing the scope of this scandal!!! Two questions/points. I’m wondering why the effort to destroy Flynn and not the same effort to destroy Rodgers? Also, has Mary Jacoby ever been called to testify anywhere? She and her family are long time cronies of the Clinton’s way back to their early grifter days in Arkansas. Was she the bag lady in this process? I almost worry that there is too much scandal, so much that the avg person won’t understand the level of threat this represented to our Constitution…

    • Zorro says:

      If people can’t be bothered to put a little effort into understanding then they probably don’t have much interest in the constitution.

  91. jjk says:

    The roots of the spying are in the Iran deal and general Obama administration conflict with Israel over Iran deal. Netanyahu gave speech to Congreas in March 2015 — against Iran deal. Obama IC was monitoring Israeli officials and US supporters of Israel officials — in 2014 and into 2015. Then it just morphed into monitoring Trump —- then Trump unexpectedly won the election and the frantic coverup started. UK and Europeans were probably in on watching the Israeli’s too. Talk for the sake of the Iran deal. That is the start of it all the Obama nd European obsession with appeasing Iran. Israel’s speaking out against that started all the spying. And with so many Americans supporting Israel and opposing Iran. It had to include domestic US spying.

    • Dutchman says:

      Yes, and wasn’t Bebe attacked with an Oct. Surprise scandal, in his recent reelection?

    • felipe says:

      jjk – Interesting take. That would certainly dovetail with the hundreds of unmaskings done by Samantha Powers to spy on pro-Israeli organizations and persons.

  92. jbrickley says:

    That is one YUGE UGLY STICK! My Gawd… I knew a lot of that was likely going on as far as surveillance by the NSA. They do indeed have hooks into all forms of digital communications and analog prior. The technology is definitely capable. One would think they would have an audit log of all users of the systems logging all their activity when using the system showing all the queries they ran, etc. Opening this up to multi-agency access is insane. All this happened because of 9/11 and a knee-jerk reaction to an enemy living among us.
    What is even worse, is how many times did Google and the other social media elite meet with Obama? Talk about a political weapon… Ugh!
    Enemy of the State – 1998 Movie
    – In God we trust. The rest we monitor
    – The only privacy left is inside your head
    Robert Clayton Dean:
    What the hell is happening?
    I blew up the building!
    Robert Clayton Dean:
    Because you made a phone call!
    Admiral Shaffer:
    I want the entire history of this device, from birth to abortion on my desk in 2 hours. I want the name of the tech who made it. I want to know who authorized its use, who checked it out of inventory and for what purpose. And most important, how in God’s green earth it got into Congressman Albert’s hotel room? Listen people, everyone knows where this is going. If this was a legit op, and i can’t imagine how it could be, then so be it. But if this was someone’s unilateral wet dream, then someone is going to prison!

    • Dutchman says:

      Good movie, prescient even. My favorite though is final scene from 3 days of the Condor when Cliff Roberts says, in effect” Sure, you can TALE the story to NYT’s and WaPo,….but HOW do you know they’ll PRINT it?

  93. Vince says:

    I think what they are really afraid of right now is Barr finding the name “Mitt Romney.” Once we start seeing documents that all serious republicans were being spied on for several years, the excuse that they had to spy on Trump for national security’s sake goes out the window.
    This is a complex scandal with lots of players and side issues, and a lot of flack and misdirection. Its understandable that most Americans can’t follow all of this. But if Americans hear that Mitt Romney and Donald Trump were spied on by democrats, using agencies of the government, well that’s easy to understand. The democrat party would be finished.

    • Dee says:

      I bet there will be some Pubs who are in this mess as well. McCain there must be others, the turtle sure has been very quiet.

    • simona says:

      It would serve Romney right if he had been spied on during his run. Then he can experience what our President suffered but overcame.

  94. HickTick says:

    Just imagine how much corporate espionage has been going on with this intel for sale from these contractors . Knowing what to bid , Knowing what stocks to deal . The contractors must have made billions since 2010 or so . The political spying was just icing on the cake . Sure been a lot of mergers and take-overs not to mention CEO’s , here today , gone tomorrow .

  95. Zorro says:

    Not a smidgen of scandal, just a whole schiffload.

  96. There’s going to be so much hitting the fan, we’re going to need oversized blades.

  97. Curt says:

    The wheels are coming off! If Sundance can lay out this sequence of events then you can bet BARR and company are on this and a whole lot more. When Barr says there are now more questions then when he started, this is what he means. John Durham has been working on this and has had the facts since approximately January 2019. The Obama administration way back in 2012 was dirty. This thing is going expand exponentially. The Democrats are going demonic for a reason. They know what’s coming down the road and it ain’t going to be pretty. Get set for more Democrat bizarre and ugly behavior. They’re dirty as hell. It won’t stop Barr and company.
    There are still deep state rats operating within the administration and trying to impede Barr’s efforts. One of those is FBI director Christopher Wray. This guy is an empty suit and not too bright. His time is coming. James Baker is a third rate lawyer who made it to the top of the FBI! Go figure. An Obama lackey for sure. There has to be a few honest brokers who saw this criminal behavior and are now willing to cooperate with Barr. Let the games begin.

    • Zorro says:

      “If Sundance can lay out this sequence of events then you can bet BARR and company are on this and a whole lot more.”

      • BitterC says:

        Barr and company don’t have to make educated guess about what is behind the redactions in the subset of pertinent documents the public has been given access to

    • Now look at Pelosi and Nadler and what IS HAPPENING TO THEM this week —>
      1) Pelosi functioning in abnormal capacity — Slurred speech, face contorted and hands look shriveled.
      2) Nadler having what looks like a PANIC ATTACK…again, the blank look on his face when that was happening does not bode well for this human being.
      Would not be surprised that BOTH of these individuals have diminished capacity going forward and the EXTREME STRESS and the stressors will be unrelenting from here on out…Pity to be them…

  98. StuckInBlue says:

    In addition to all of this intelligence, I’d like to know what they were tracking via the newly created CFPB.

  99. Lucille says:

    I was puzzled as to whose photo is on the bottom right in the collage…finally realized it was the lackey Ben Rhodes.
    The photo depicted in this link…
    …is so fitting…Rhodes looks unwashed and ready for prison garb.

  100. jbowen82 says:

    You know who we haven’t heard a word from, who is out giving speeches on cybersecurity but has not made a single public comment about all this, despite being in a position to be very knowledgeable? John Carlin. The man who resigned the day after the first FISA application. Did he resign in disgust? Is he a whistleblower steering DOJ IG investigators toward the facts?It’s certainly curious that he is very quiet and others are quiet about him.

  101. Pokey says:

    The photo collage includes most of the Communists in Obama’s Apparatchik. Amazing how some of these people just came out of nowhere to play major roles in that Administration.
    Nice work by Sundance this time. The whole enchilada is on its way to the table. Now all we have to do is find the restaurant. A messy order, for sure. 🙂

  102. I’m wondering, with the volume of illegal spying on individuals, how many of these people can file lawsuits against the government for invasion of privacy????

    • Sentient says:


    • All Too Much says:

      Anyone who’s privacy was unlawfully breached has a civil rights claim under Title 28 United States Code Section 1983. That could potentially be hundreds, maybe thousands, of people. Liability won’t be an issue, just the amount of the jury award or settlement. Frankly, I hope my name was umasked somewhere in all this. I can use the money.
      The best news is the perpetrators will all go broke defending the lawsuits and paying off victims. No insurance and no indemnification from the government. Lovely.

      • 7delta says:

        I hear ya, ATM. I sure wouldn’t want a dime of taxpayer money and hopefully, the perps won’t be left with enough to cover the cost of a stamp to mail out restitution checks. I want a year tacked onto the sentences of each and every one of the perps, for each and every infraction. Tens of thousands of violations.
        And, since the Marxist usurper and his band of merry miscreants, weaponized government agencies and their power to glean anything they wanted, don’t they already have POTUS’s tax returns? Not like the IRS wasn’t sending stacks of disks of such info out to its co-conspirators, but Lois failed to include DJT? Hardly. Obviously, they found nothing useful or a construct would have been created to out it long ago.
        The Dems have nothing left, but the wailing. They’ve locked themselves in with Distraction Junk Theater. They misread the sign too. Now the spotlight is plugged in and a hand is on the switch. There’s no way out. “Equal Justice” is coming soon.

        • Sandra Romero says:

          Thank you “7delta” for “the Marxist usurper and his band of merry miscreants”. I borrowed it and shared it with full credit to you. And thank you for your very accurate and hopeful comment.

      • Thanks ATM, I thought so, I also hope my name is there, I’d like to put a new deck on my summer home…

      • Dan says:

        I can just see the late-night lawyer ads. “If you or a loved one was illegally intercepted…”

      • ooicu812 says:

        ” I never would of agreed to the formulation of the Central Intelligence Agency back in forty-seven, if I had known it would become an American Gestapo”. – Harry S. Truman
        33rd President of the United States (1945–1953),

    • Shadrach says:

      This has always been one of the problems with the FISA court. Unless you can prove you have a FISA on you, (you can’t) then you don’t have standing to sue. Carter Page and the other 3 people we know about (Flynn, Papa, and Manafort) are the only 4 people in the country with standing.

      • MelH says:

        Those four are enough to break the thugs for life! Plus, POTUS has enough on them to insure 4 generations of his family will thrive in relative wealth.

    • inspectorudy says:

      As usual, any settlement would be paid by the taxpayers and not the perps. As taxpayers, we lose either way.

  103. FanGirl says:

    Would be interested in how much FISA abuse was done to Chief Justice Roberts.

    • MMA says:

      Indeed! That’s exactly what I was thinking. And the IRS investigations and harassment of so many of the Tea Party. Maxine Waters talked about the secret database. I bet it has everything to do with this information.

      • Conservative_302 says:

        Waters bragged about it which again tells us how stupid she is.

      • sticknca says:

        Not to mention the mass “retirements” of GOP lawmakers in 2018 opening up a lot of seats.

        • Patricia Dolan says:

          Excellent point. OMG. So politically charged. And the surveillance of Scalia, his murder etc……heads will roll if Barr has his way……..

        • We the people know says:

          Mike Rogers goes to the FISA court to blow the whistle on illegal searches (702-17) of the NSA database. Mike Rogers makes the decision to shut down the contractors on April 18, 2016. These searches were of Trump/Trump campaign +++
          Then, wanting to continue searching for Trump/Trump campaign, the FBI shows up with a gussied up, fanciful dossier about Russia and Trump and want a FISA warrant to continue their Trump surveillance. And they GET it in October of 2016.
          So, the FISA court is all clued into the spying on Trump AND YET they give the FBI a warrant to continue spying on them and not an eyebrow was raised? Do they have short-term memory loss? Six month’s earlier they shut down the spying operation and in October of 2016 they approve continued spying. Someone on the FISA court must be compromised and likely have John Roberts giving them cover.
          On August 29, 2018 President Trump tweeted this:
          “Ohr told the FBI it (the Fake Dossier) wasn’t true, it was a lie and the FBI was determined to use it anyway to damage Trump and to perpetrate a fraud on the court to spy on the Trump campaign. This is a fraud on the court. The Chief Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court is in charge of the FISA court. He should direct the Presiding Judge, Rosemary Collier, to hold a hearing, haul all of these people from the DOJ & FBI in there, & if she finds there were crimes committed, and there were, there should be a criminal referral by her.”
          I believe that John Roberts has a problem. A big one.

    • Luz Maria Rodriguez says:

      Definitely something does not fit with his past record.
      If Hillary could garner some 900 FBI files when Slick Willie was prez, how many more were available to Brenner/Clapper for illegal use?
      What a corrupt bunch of unethical, immoral thugs we endured with the O Admin..

    • dasantacroce says:

      Just enough.

    • Mtrollo says:

      It’s there. But, the question must be specific for this to fall under declassification.

    • southernsue says:

      i think is dirt is about adopting his kids
      i am not sure
      sad if true
      sad if he is compromised
      and btw
      where is ruthie?

    • 7delta says:

      “To” him? Not “by” him, right? IMO, nobody got a FISA warrant “on” Roberts. More likely, the Barry Brigade illegally spied on him, then used something to ensure he’d dance to their tune. The way his opinion on the ACA was written was my first clue that “something” happened. The tone was angry…defiant…and he took some generic potshots at both federal and State “government.” He began with a primer on the Constitution, then left bread crumbs throughout on how to take down the ACA, but most people were too angry to look for them. It was the oddest SCOTUS opinion I’d ever read…not that I’ve read every one, but I’ve read a few that span our history. If Roberts was indeed blackmailed, and I think it’s likely, then it explains a lot, including his lack of oversight on the FISA Court abuse.
      In the end, I think a lot depends on what was used against him. Had he done something illegal or was he or his family threatened? And, as we all know, these people weren’t then, or now, above just making something up, then using the power of government and their useful-idiot media to destroy a target. Time will tell.

    • MelH says:

      How did Justice Roberts get to be Chief, with the illegal adoption in his background? Or was he Chief as soon as he was confirmed for the Supreme Court. Did the adoptions occur later, supposedly in secret, or is it just that he was a Democrat so he could break the laws to justify his acts? Can We The People out him? Or is it just my imagination that he is a RINO who can be exposed and lose his position on the Supreme Court?

  104. Frbrdskmi8 says:

    God Bless Sundance and God bless all Treepers and Deplorables….dont know about most of you but I’m sleeping so much better knowing all of you and our VSGDJT are in existence. May all have a very blessed night…..praying for patience, courage and safety in the coming days for our President and all who stand in allegiance with him. The lord our Saviour has promised that Good shall overcome evil, we just need to trust and obey. Vengeance is Mine, saith the Lord. Stay strong and have faith.

    • Conservative_302 says:

      I hope in the end, we get our freedom restored, and I can wear my Women for Trump t shirt without a care in the world.

  105. Kleen says:

    I am very interested in finding out which RINOs abused power to destroy conservatives.
    Maybe if we finally get proof we can get rid of them.
    Most people end up voting for them over and over. They need to slapped with some declassified docs showing RINOs are Democrat plants.

    • jebg46 says:

      McCain participated in taking the Tea Party down and he’s now paying the ultimate price for that betrayal.

      • FanGirl says:

        Hopefully he’s paying for it all.

        • Bob Parker says:

          McCain had punched his ticket down under a long, long time ago. All the way back to his Viet Nam days when his “showboating” in his plane while waiting to take off from his carrier ship directly caused the deaths of 154 Navy men + scores of serious injuries + severe damage to the ship!
          John McCain war hero?? GAG ME! He killed more of US than the Viet Cong!! He should have died in the POW prison camp he was detained in!
          For some icing on McCain’s cake we next look at how he dumped his 1st wife after returning from the war & marrying his 2nd wife Cindy (Hensley) McCain.
          Cindy’s father had deep ties to the AZ mob. In fact her father Jim Hensley went to prison instead of ratting out on his boss Kemper Marley. Marley rewarded Hensley’s loyalty with an AZ Anheuser-Buch distributorship (Hey Jim, This Bud’s for you!).
          So Johnny boy is clearly down there probably right next to Kleagle Bryd & the treasonous womanizing killer Teddy Kennedy.
          You can take that to the bank!!

          • MelH says:

            Bob Parker, many thanks for those links. i must have used the wrong terms in my search for those articles last year. Meghan McCain might change her oh-so-LOUD hatred of our Lion if she knew TRUTH. Vengeance being The Lord’s, I’ll hope she finds the articles herself, some day. The one about him showboating has been all over the internet for a very long time. That’s alot of dead men attributed to John McCain. Shocking that none of the family members sued him, except the crooked courts maybe just were complicit in exonerating him?

      • mickjt says:

        McPain and Lucifer have been good friends for quite a long time…

        • Don L says:

          Does Lucifer trust him?

        • Bob Parker says:

          McCain punched his ticket down under a long, long time ago. All the way back to his Viet Nam days where his wanting to showboat in his plane while parked on deck of the ship 7/29/67 he was on led to the DIRECT DEATHS of 134 US Navymen + scores injured!
          John McCain War hero? GAG ME! The bastard should have died in the Vietnamese POW camp!!
          And to put some icing on McCain’s cake, he dumps his faithful wife following his return from Viet Nam & hooks up with his 2nd wife Cindy (Hensley) whose father was deep in organized crime.
          Cindy’s family acquired their vast wealth when her father went to prison for refusing to rat on his mob boss (Kemper Marley). As a reward for going to prison & taking 1 for his boss, Marley “rewarded Jim Hensley (Cindy’s father) with an Anheuser-Buch beer distributorship in AZ.

          • Bob Parker says:

            My apologies for the double post. Accident. Also McCain ONLY 134 of US & not 154 that I originally posted.
            President Trump had it spot-on correct about McCain when he stated that McCain was no war hero. And the McCain family would be very wise to STFU & slip back into the shadows where they belong.

            • MGBSE says:

              My guess…there are many polite patriots, personally damaged my mccain actions…who are patiently waiting on the one year anniversary of his death…and then they will unload.

            • Peppurr says:

              Well thank goodness he never won the Presidency.

              • MGBSE says:

                That’s the scary part…as evil as mccain is/was and as incompetent as romney is…they are better than an obama or hillary…and we have President Donald J. Trump to thank for that.
                Now we have CRYSTAL CLEAR evidence of the difference between a RAT, a RINO, a RINORAT and a PATRIOT!!!
                Thank you God…Thank you President Trump…MAGA!!!

                • MelH says:

                  RinoRatRomney must be taken down, exposed, is a rabid animal these days! I wish he would run for President again, so we can watch him fail just one more time.

      • Luz Maria Rodriguez says:

        Yes, indeed.
        And, I have heard it is much warmer there than in his former state of Arizona.
        It’s the price one pays for playing with the Devil.

    • Redzone says:

      This needs to happen!

  106. Kleen says:

    Apparently the swampees in the agencies are resisting the declassification orders.
    Coats is fighting against it. These people won’t go down without burning down the house.
    Barr is in for a long fight. The swamp will hide under National Security.
    The system is rotten, desinfecting it will be hard work.
    Too many years of corruption it became the norm. It’s how it is and it has been that way for a long time.

    • Dutchman says:

      As Sundance layed out, it won’t be Cris Wray resisting Barr, it will be Coates.
      From what Sundance wrote, and reading the POTUS orders, it sounds like Coates can TRY to make the case to Barr that some things have tovremain classified, but Barr, it seems to me has a simple answer;
      Barr has,top security clearance; Let ME see the document, unredacted. Then YOU make the case to me, as to ehy it shouldn’t be released but IN THE END ITS MY CALL.
      Our concern is them using “its classified” to avoid releasing embarassing info or evidence of criminal wrongdoing, if thatts what Barr see’s, he can call Coates out on it, and release anyway.
      I really don’t think Barr is going to tolerate much crap, and the most Coates can do is delay a little.
      Or, resign and make a public statement condeming Barr and PDJT, and alleging they are endangering Natl. Security.
      And of coarse the answer to thatcis to release; people will be able to SEE whyvtheycwere trying to block release, and that it has -0- to do with Natl. Security, and everything to do with covering for the coup.

      • Joemama says:

        I would just like to point out that it is explicitly against the law to classify anything in order to conceal mistakes or criminality. I’m not sure, but I think that to do so is a federal felony.
        Almost everything that was classified by the people in the obama administration was classified to hide their criminality.

      • Sugarhillhardrock says:

        Great post, Dutch.
        At this point, given what facts we know and the pregnant likelihood of companion evidence that will buttress the abuse and provide additional detail, embarrassment redactions should be treated as obstruction of justice.
        Were I Barr, I’d point that out to ODNI Coates, BEFORE he presented me with his suggested redactions.

        • strateshooter says:

          I agree.
          If I was Barr I would tell Coates this >
          Dan , it is like I told Bob Mueller a couple of weeks back.
          With information already available in the public domain and with other stuff I have I am developing concrete and irrefutable charges of Sedition and Treason against certain individuals as we speak.
          The free pass to Hilary , the early Mifsud insert on Papa , the Ruskie Lawyer set up of DJ Jr. , FBI informant inserts , the fake FISA on Page , the fake DNC hack and a whole bunch of other stuff the public do not even know about yet.
          People in all the depts. are coming forward daily with more and more info that is making this a lock for us.
          Now, you have a choice.
          You can freely share all requested info and trust me and my guys to treat it with care and common sense or you can choose to stall me. Your call.
          But if at some future time I find you withhold info , or classify info that is not of national security concern, then make no mistake I will indict your ass as co-conspirator in Sedition and Treason against the democratically elected President and Government of the United States of America and I will seek maximum penalties for you along with the others up to and including the death penalty.
          Now… go get yourself a coffee , come back in 10 minutes and let me know your decision.
          How are the kids by the way ? Everything good ?

      • littleanniefannie says:

        Could be PDJT’s plan to give Coats just enough rope to hang himself trying to cover himself. He’s been there long enough to know what info they want to keep in the swamp cooler.
        The patience exhibited by our ESG or VSG will stick in the craw of the Dem talking point spewing MSM as they come to the realization that what they described as a temper tantrum was actually a Zippo being flicked and the heat it generated was not from temper but from the flame of truth. Oh how sweet when they go Nadler (that sinking feeling) as PT gives a wink and nod to acknowledge that the MSM’s lockstep with the Dems has finally done them in!

      • Conservative_302 says:

        The way Trump asked for declassification shows us how smart Trump and Barr are.

      • MGBSE says:

        The only national security risk I’ve seen since 9/11 is the BS that the “religion of peace mean us no harm”…everything else is hashed over cold war baloney.

        • MGBSE says:

          Accidentally posted before finishing.
          …until now…now we know we have the Swamp or Deep State…ALL internal AMERICAN spies, liars and traitors…ALL in government agencies…advancing their own self serving personal agenda…while destroying the Constitution and America.
          The big question…how many of these players would have been Arkancided…in order to protect the “leaders”.

  107. swamph8er says:

    Combine the IRS data theft with the NSA data theft…and you end up with a huge illegal database (Obama’s Project Hammer) in order to blackmail your opposition.
    When politicians like Amash or Romney say ridiculous things. They are probably being blackmailed. Once they are blackmailed into affecting legislation or voting without reporting it to authorities…they are complicit and have a vested interest in the truth never coming out. They are assimilated into the deep state.
    This is why so many Republicans did not run for reelection…they were compromised and some unknown white hat told them to GTFO or face the music when everything is exposed.

    • Dutchman says:

      I think it was some BLACK hat that told them to GTFO, and his name was PAUL RYAN.
      This was part of his plan, to willingly give the Speakership to Pelosi so that she could weaponise the,House, to usevits investigations as Mueller 2.0.
      It ain’t working out too well, like every Uniparty plan, since the escalator ride!
      “DRAT you, Trump!”

    • Joemama says:

      The unknown white hat that told them to GTFO or face the music calls themselves Q. They are enlisted soldiers working for PDJT and have access to the NSA database.
      The good guys in the US military are now using the database against the democrat/rino criminals and the banking families. We “little people” are on the cusp of a glorious new era free from central banks and the satanic banking families that have ruled the world for hundreds of years.

      • farrier105 says:

        If they had access to all of this classified information now then the Trump people and the Q people had it years ago. So, why in the hell are we going through all of this? Why is there a Democrat House (weaponized) when it was not necessary to have to deal with it? This could have been over in 2016. There is no discernible excuse for this IF the conditions you described were the reality all of this time.

        • Petey says:

          DJT has to smoke out every last one of them and make Americans see how corrupt our lawmakers are on both sides. This is coming out with enough time for us to primary RINO s and indict complicit democrats. Can t run for reelection with a felony charge hanging over your head.

          • farrier105 says:

            This could likely still be in the preparation stage when 2020 vote takes place. There will be fights to get some individual documents and some collections. Redactions will be another fight.

        • MGBSE says:

          If President Trump had done ONE THING prior to Muller “concluding” his fake investigation…that action by the President would have been used against him.
          Impeachment based on “obstruction” would have been immediate.
          The whole LIE was drug out by the RATS and RINOS…to… #1 destroy evidence that could be used against all of them including obama & hillary them…#2 hoping the President would react – as you have suggested – so they could impeach for that action…#3 shut down the President’s agenda.
          Muller resigned when the RATS, RINOS and RNC failed to to give all of Congress back to the democRATS. Just the House of democrat nutjobs & quacks is NOT enough to take down Trump, they needed a democrat Senate too.
          Mueller and his band of criminals packed up their stuff, took our 30+ MILLION TAX DOLLARS and left.

          • farrier105 says:

            If President Trump had done ONE THING prior to Muller “concluding” his fake investigation…that action by the President would have been used against him.
            They are going to do that now. Sundance made that clear and the possibility of impeachment was implicit in the Mueller Report Part II reference to CONGRESS. Don’t think for one minute they didn’t hope for a Democrat House from those “safe” Mid-Terms. They will take action against Trump anyway. They have to given what is at stake. It should have started in 2017 to get the unredacted Judge Collyer decision. You get that before the Mid-Terms, you have them all by the long johns.
            Mueller asked for 6 more months on his grand jury, and got it, two months after the Democrats failed to win both houses of Congress. He was likely told to quit since he only used about 2 months of his 6 months extension. Mueller didn’t give a damn about that election as long as the Democrats got the House they can get an impeachment through if they go that route.
            First, Mueller got his extension.
            Second, Barr was confirmed.
            Mueller announces end of investigation.
            Assange is told he will be expelled from the Ecuadorian embassy in London.
            These guys are masters at the stall. They have about half of their opposition in a passive stance waiting for a show to start, so stalling will only get them half the uproar it could have gotten them. They have lots left in their bag of tricks. Once you start with them, you have to finish. This might let you know how long these bastards have doing this stuff, and for how many generations:

  108. steviedawn says:

    I’m just hoping Barr stays the course. Politico has just posted a piece that quotes Gen Hayden’s former Chief of Staff, as saying the IC may not cooperate. I’m very concerned. All of this needs to come out, all of it.

    • Sentient says:

      Start firing MF’ers.

    • Dutchman says:

      WOW, Politico got it from Haydens chief of staff, huh? Sheesh.
      No doubt they will TRY to resist, they tried that once already, with PDJT.
      Let them try it with Barr, I don’t think they are gonna get very far. And what are they gonna,do, take it to COURT?
      9th Circuit perhaps? In the end, like the military, our I.C. works for a ‘Civilian’, and they can not refuse a legitimate lawful order.

    • Arby says:

      Maybe it’s time for a complete overhaul of the IC system. These sound like swamp people trying to protect the swamp. I know there has been good work but an awful number of misses as well, i.g., 9/11 (both times), Boston bombers, Pulse Night Club, the Christmas eve shoe bomber to name a few (and probably more that have not been available to public).

      • RobInPA says:

        Phil Haney, who was one of DHS’s top terrorist hunter’s at the time, was very suspicious of radical islamic extremist activity in the SoCal area. He was sniffing out suspicious mosques in that area, including on in San Bernardino. Holder / obama ordered him to shut down the operation AND to destroy all evidence and collected intel.
        Unfortunately we all now what happened out there.
        For this crime alone, obama, holder and the rest of the ilk responsible for enabling a terrorist attack on USA soil, should rot in prison!

  109. I don’t believe AG Barr will stoop to fight any of them. They either produce promptly at the first request or AG Barr makes a phone call to PDJT and Barr will be dealing with the next in line until he gets 100% cooperation. Mr. Coats and Mr. Wray should be the first to update their resume`s.

    • jx says:

      That’s how to do it. *Any* resistance = immediate firing, as in escort them off the property and tell them their personal effects will be mailed to them.

  110. Blind no Longer says:

    WOW!!! Looks like Blackmail was the name of the game. Team Obama had everybody compromised. Explains a whole hellava lot of crazy behavior and votes from people who campaigned one way but voted the other.
    Boy they could find out everything with the 702…even when you stopped for gas, how much you got, what you paid for it and what time you got home. DAMN…talk about a police state! Orwell’s 1984 ain’t got nothing on this operation by our government!

    • wolfrom1 says:

      Blind/ Obama even “got” a supreme court justice.

    • Monticello says:

      You said it! When pols are all compromised by the demon rats you get surprising results.

    • Sugarhillhardrock says:

      Spot on, Blind.
      Once the full story is out, it will be interesting to see the public’s reaction. I pray AG Barr addresses the extent of the abuse, why it was an invasion of core civil rights under the Constitution, and it’s State equivalents, while he points out that arrests are occurring and prosecutions will occur. That will, guaranteed, get the public’s focus.

    • Jederman says:

      obama never won an election by the strength of his ideas or his personal strength and leadership abilities. It was pure, corrupt chicago style blackmail/destroy your opponent so there is no other choice but the zero.

  111. Blue Moon says:

    I am so damned mad at former President Bush. WHY hasn’t he warned Trump a long time ago what was going on? You know he knew it along with his father. But all you have ever seen from him was kissing up to Odumbo and his wifey. I don’t think for one minute that this didn’t happen just recently. I think Bush was doing the same thing, no on the same scale as Odumbo. I remember when O came into office they talked about filing charges again Bush and his admin for their wrong-doing while in office. Then one day he and Nancy both said they had decided to not prosecute them. Guess they got to them real fast. So I think this has gone on since back to Clinton to maybe even before that. JMO.

    • sDee says:

      Bush the First laid the ground work for the globalization of America when he signed us onto the Rio accord and Agenda21. Clinton and Bush the Second drove it into every federal agency, policy and budget. It is Bush the Second we can thank for the Patriot Act, Faith Based Initiatives,opening of our borders and a massive expansion of government, bailouts and debt.
      The table was set for the Chicago Gang.

      • Dutchman says:

        Two things about the Bushes;
        Firstly remember when they teamed up to rape Haiti, and did those photo ops, saying Barbera had adopted Bill, and George thought of Bill as ‘brother from another mother’?
        There is NO WAY I could stay in the same room with the Clantons, let alone embrace them.
        Second, its obvious illegal mass migration is a method or technique of the NWO Globalist (marxists).
        Now, afghanistan DID had something to do with 911, but as PDJT pointed out just recently, IRAQ had nuffin to do with it.
        But, it and the arab spring, with the Obama/Hillary created Isis triggered a muslim diaspora from ME and africa, up into the EU, where a complicit government, OVER THE OBJECTIONS OF THE CITISENS, insisted on welcoming with open arms.
        In our hemisphere, DRUG CARTELS, using the SAME TACTICS of terrorism, drive 10’s of millions up into the U.S., with a government with policies that encourage it, OVER THE OBJECTIONS OF THE CITISENRY.
        Coincidence? And, LOOK who was in charge of Federal drug interdiction for the U.S. government; Rod Rosenstien.
        Any serious effort to address drugs would mean Drug Cartels, the very people driving people North.
        Hmmm Obama had no success against ISIS, either.
        Illegal immigration isn’t just about votes for Dems, or cheap labor for Reps, its about destroying our country, which is goal of Uniparty, regardless of the letter after their name.

        • mickjt says:

          And of course the key lynch pin…ALL of these govt. officials were and are getting super rich with payoff’s from all those involve in Drugs, Wars, …you name it. That is why I support gathering ALL Financial records on every govt. employee/politician. THEN we will start to see the whole Picture!

        • StanH says:

          Bingo! It was definitely Bush Sr. who moved this country towards totalitarianism with his Thousand Points of Light introducing the us and the world to the NWO. Though the NWO is an old construct of the cabal it was daddy Bush who made it overt and setup the Mistake of 08 Barry O for the kill. This is one link with AG Barr that concerns me? We’ll see.

      • Dabigragu says:

        Very nice catch. 😉

    • Sentient says:

      You mean the Bush that said the Constitution was “just a goddamn piece of paper” or his father who ran the CIA?

    • dustycowpoke says:

      Bush the first did this read about him and JFK. LBJ was in on all of it too!

    • farrier105 says:

      Why hasn’t Bush done something? Because he is on the other side, if there are opposite sides in this thing, whatever it is.

    • FanGirl says:

      Reminder: Bush the First, was CIA before he was Vice President. This is regarding the shooting/attempted assassination of President Reagan.
      From Wikipedia (yeah, I know) – originally from NYT (yeah, I know) “Treaster, Joseph B. (April 1, 1981). “A LIFE THAT STARTED OUT WITH MUCH PROMISE TOOK RECLUSIVE AND HOSTILE PATH”. The New York Times. p. A19. The eldest Hinckley child, Scott, 30, is the vice president of the his [sic] father’s company and a friend of Neil Bush, the son of Vice President Bush. Scott Hinckley and a date had been invited to dinner at the young Bushes’ home last night, but the dinner was canceled after the shooting.”

  112. litenmaus says:

    “April 18, 2016 (Remember the dates)”
    “On or about April 18, 2016, the Conspirators activated X-Agent’s keylog and screenshot functions to steal credentials of a DCCC employee who was authorized to access the DNC network. The Conspirators HACKED into the DNC network FROM the DCCC NETWORK using stolen credentials.”
    Mueller Indictment, July 13, 2018….

    • jx says:

      Good date connection between Mueller indictment and Rogers’ blocking contractor access to the NSA database. Might be that Mueller’s “Russian agents” were FBI contractors.
      A limited hang out? Admit to the hacking but direct attention to “Russian agents’.

    • farrier105 says:

      “On or about April 18, 2016…” is not a definite statement. It either happened on April 18, or it did not. An indictment should contain an exact date that something like this happened. The forensic evidence should have that event recorded with more precision than “on or about…” That is a problem with the entire DNC indictment.

  113. Blind no Longer says:

    Now as I am thinking more and more about what has been exposed, a few things are crystal clear. Obama/Brennan were caught red handed spying on members of his own party and world leaders. Think about it, Feinstein who was spied on wasn’t really that upset, neither was Merkel. Maybe that’s why Merkel decided to turn Germany into a shithole with millions of refugees because Obama had the goods on her. All in the manchurian’s master plan!

  114. Tiffthis says:

    Didn’t sally Yates testify that even tho some unmasking requests had her signature that SHE didn’t actually sign them? But then she never said who she thought it could be- or no one asked her. She better come up with a complete story now

  115. Joanne Avella says:

    Long before Obama spied on Trump he did the same tomother world leaders both those in politics and religion. It’s been written that He surveilled the former Catholic Pope Benedict and together with the liberal socialist cabal assisted in the selecting the Apostate Leftist Pope Francis.
    The wiki leaked Podesta e mails talk about arranging a “Catholic Spring “ in order to bring the church into modernity ie/ gay marriage , abortion , open boarders , social justice etc.

    • Jederman says:

      I believe obama was merely an errand boy. People (DS/globalist/marxists… soros…) came to him and, essentially, requested “assistance” from the WH.
      Assistance=abuse the appropriate/most efficient fed apparatus to take care of the request/issue, whether it’s the public or private sector. obama was there to say yes and enjoy the perks.

    • We the people know says:

      “Modernism is the synthesis of all heresies.”
      Pope Pius X

  116. Smarty says:

    Dear God, the pope resigning in 13, and replaced with a pedo- loving red? Man, the mind is boggled.

  117. Liberty ONE says:

    Predicated on my reading of all this RE: NSA data. They HAVE to have EVERY e/m ( 33,000)that Hitlery dumped. Sadly to say, this criminal corruption is so deep that has been going on since 2012 with so many Obungo Regime members involved, the entire truth will never see daylight!

  118. Juvenal says:

    Now I know what happened to the STAZI after East Germany collapsed. They wound up in the Obama administration! This is the “fundamental transformation” Obama bragged about to his supporters five days before he was inaugurated.

    • Dutchman says:

      Read up on the IDEOLOGICAL ‘geneology’of all the key players, AmericanThinker has a good article probably yesterday by now.
      And there is additional info out there. They are all ‘red diaper’ Merxist embeds. Soviet ‘program’ that outlived the Soviet Union, it was the ‘conquer without firing a shot’ plan of infiltration of ALL elements of society; labor unions, media and entertainment, government buerocracy, education religious hierarchies, and ALL Political parties.
      Undermine from within. When Soviet Union collapsed, just continues work with Red China, same goal. The “One World Government” is a Conmunist one.
      And don’t focus JUST on the Executive; 4 people have absolute control over what happens in the LEGISLATIVE branch, and unlike the President they are NOT term limited.
      The ‘Dem’ and ‘Rep’ leaders in both houses,..4 people have ENORMOUS control. Sure, they pass the gavel back and forth, depending on whats expedient.
      Occasionally one will retire, after grooming his replacement. Means little as they all have same goal. Undermine America.

      • mickjt says:

        Kruschev said the Communists would take over America ‘without firing a single shot’…it is coming to pass and our govt. is helping them!

  119. ~Folks, ALL these Crimes that were committed against Pres.Trump to overturn “We the People” choice for President in 2016 rests SQUARELY on the head of Barack Hussein Obama.~
    1) FBI Dir. 2001-2013…Robert S. Mueller, III
    2) FBI Dir. 2013-2017…James B. Comey
    3) Acting FBI Dir. 2017-2017…Andrew McCabe
    6) DOJ AG 2007-2009…Michael B. Mukasey
    7) DOJ AG 2009-2015…Eric H. Holder, Jr.
    8) DOJ AG 2015-2017…Loretta E. Lynch
    9) Acting DOJ AG 2017-2017…Sally Q. Yates
    10) DOJ Dep. AG 2017-2019…Rod J. Rosenstein
    11) CIA Dir. 2006-2009…Gen. Michael V. Hayden, USAF (Bushy-Lapdog)
    12) CIA Dir. 2009-2011…*Leon E. Panetta*…1994-1997…Bill Clinton WH Chief of Staff
    13) CIA Dir. 2011-2012…David Petraeus, US Army (SPIED On by Obama)
    14) CIA Dir. 2013-2017…John O. Brennan
    15) ODNI 2010-2017…James R. Clapper, Jr.
    16) Sec. of Defence 2011-2013…*Leon E. Panetta*
    17) Sec. of Defence 2015-2017…Ashton B. Carter
    I purposely left off Jeff Sessions as AG because he was a POTTED-PLANT.

  120. 13wasylyna says:

    Maxine Waters knew about this….she should be investigated.
    “And I think some people are missing something here. The president has put in place an organization that contains the kind of database that no one has ever seen before in life. That’s going to be very, very powerful. That database will have information about everything on every individual in ways that it’s never been done before.”

  121. boomerbeth says:

    2014 : Dennis Montgomery admits he has been assisting Kkklpperm& Brennan spying on A,erican citizens for:years:

  122. boomerbeth says:

    2017 Dennis Montgomery Interview

    • Bill says:

      I have a question. If Coates et al try to claim national security and keep stonewalling Barr and Trump and then they fire him to get him out of the way and the next guy claims national security, couldn’t they just keep firing people until they got to someone that wasn’t a crooked POS? How would that work?

      • FanGirl says:

        Great litmus. I truly believe that THE LEAST that needs to be done is REMOVE the top 5 levels of the alphabet agencies, including local offices. How many shootings/terror events should have been prevented, but were not- either purposely or incompetence. Orlando, Parkland, San Bernadino… just from the top of my head.

  123. Conservative_302 says:

    When they expose the crimes, indictments, and criminals, it has to be by public hearings. You can put it on paper, and you can report it in the media, but a picture is worth a thousand words. When I see a picture of a Nazi concentration camp, any opposing argument goes out the window. Also, do a movie or documentary about it before our next election like Watergate. On a related note, those muslims in Congress are an abomination to our constitution.

  124. distracted2 says:

    I have no doubt that sometime in the near future, I will log on to find that Sundance has found evidence that it was occurring in 2008 as well.
    i just wonder how deep this rabbit hole goes.

  125. mickjt says:

    Mr. Barr…Here is a suggestion that will rip this whole criminal enterprise apart…Do the Same searches on Obama and ALL of his Thugs, top to bottom, every person should have this anal exam of all their communications etc. What is that old saying, “What goes around comes around”…in this case in SPADES! If you don’t do this then you are not really serious about the task at hand and we are all watching! You want strong evidence of who did what, when and how…here it is on a Silver Platter!

  126. mickjt says:

    Ps. Those that did the illegal searches had to log in to that NSA database system, and guess what, NSA fully tracks and logs searches of all those who did this illegal activity by name, account etc. This grows the list of criminals significantly…Get the audit logs from the system and viola, immediate irrefutable indictments! At an early point these perps will be singing like Canaries to save their Arses! This will cause the most massive collapse of a house of cards ever witnessed!

    • We the people know says:

      It’s likely that Michael Rogers handed over hard evidence to Rosemary Collyer. There’s no way he went to her without it…and she has it for safekeeping…event though Michael said they deleted the searches…not said: after we made a copy.

  127. Emuuuu says:

    All roads lead to the Oval Office. Lisa Page said it all in a text to Peter Strzok: “POTUS wants to know everything we’re doing.”

  128. Alfred Brown says:

    As an engineer I have to ask:
    1,000 is a Four Digit number.
    10,000 is a Five Digit Number.
    Shouldn’t the number of people surveilled be from
    10,000 to less than 100,000?
    Or in our discussion, are the commas counting as a space on the paper from the typeface? (Shades of the George W. Bush Era! Typeface Analysis! Where are my Pajamas!)
    Seriously though, this could be an order of magnitude Worse that we have imagined.

  129. CM-TX says:

    When I was targeted/hacked, I received an early warning/tip from a possible white-hat.
    The other lurker labeled him “[My] Rat Friend,” ticked upon finding out.
    The EXACT Warning:
    “The Feds have a FILE on you.”
    “They put a BID out on you.” ?
    MARCH 2017: First made aware of someone’s presence on phone.
    (Prior to is possible, but only covertly)
    As my ph grew more crowded, I noticed a two-side dynamic at play.
    One side appeared more nefarious, hoping to push me over the edge. While the other side seemed to be helping me somewhat navigate the invasion.
    Or it could’ve been a *good cop/bad cop routine*, meant to put me falsely at ease.
    The effort went on for several months. It wasn’t limited to cyber-world, so portions carried over into daily life– most threatening in nature.

  130. Bill says:

    Origin of FBI/NSA database: As best I can tell, the FBI/NSA database, in its weaponized format was conceived and developed by Seisint, Inc. in about 2002. Siesint worked under contract with the FBI to build a huge searchable database of all US citizens. The data initially included banking, automobile, airline, legal, criminal and passport data. It was accessible using HPCC software on a data analytics supercomputer. Seisint was purchased by the LexisNexis subsidiary of Reed Elsevier in 2004 and the FBI work continued. The database was subsequently expanded to include IRS, cell phone, land line, internet and email data.

  131. PInky1920 says:

    I’ve been alive a long time, but have never seen anything like this. Out in the open, that is. I knew the usurper was going to be bad news, and that is now an understatement. It will be divine justice if he gets what he deserves,but I am not holding my breath.
    Looking at the photos, it is clear that Roseanne was right about VJ.

  132. StanH says:

    The 2010 Tea Party rebellion freaked out the uni-party. At that point the entire government was weaponized to stop We the People from reclaiming the government, from the sleazy cabal.
    I always recall what Trent Lott (Republican Senator MS) said, who retired in 2010 to form a lobbying firm with John Breaux (Democrat LA) as he made his rounds on the Sunday talk circuit stated “it’s time to make some money.” He later said too paraphrase: ” “We don’t need a lot of Jim DeMint disciples,” Lott said in an interview. “As soon as they get here, we need to co-opt them. How will we get any business done around here!” What business was he referring too, and why was he concerned about Jim DeMint, and how were they co-opted?
    Don’t forget Jim DeMint suddenly retired and was made president of The Heritage Foundation.
    Make no mistake our government is corrupt to it’s core.

  133. waicool says:

    i didn’t just read this article, I printed it out for reference and study. Godspeed Sundance!

  134. Wolfman Jack says:

    Obama was a CIA asset. He went from a lousy student in California to a degree from Columbia University. He had someone greasing his path. His mother and grandparents were likely also spooks. This explains his easy movement within the spy community and his use of it in his presidency.

    • Lulu says:

      He traveled to Pakistan when you could not travel there on a US passport. So either our government made that happen or BO had an Indonesian passport – meaning not a US citizen.

  135. OldParatrooper says:

    As we begin to understand the scale and scope of the abuses during the Obama Administration, it is useful to remember that the NSA database can also be used to determine which Russians were contacted by Chris Steele, and what they did to provide information. IOW, did they contact their previous employers (GRU, FSB, SVR) for instructions and inputs, or did they make the allegations up on their own.
    That would solve the public question of whether or not the Dossier is Russian misinformation. (I’m confident the IC knows and has known for years).

  136. J Gottfred says:

    2012, 2012! This just frosts me to no end.
    Just after Clapper lied to the Senate and Snowden revealed all the capabilities of the NSA programs in March-April 2013, I naively wrote my Senator Feinstein (then chair of the Senate Intelligence Committee) expressing my concern that these massively intrusive NSA “surveillance” programs were just too ripe for abuse in light of the Fourth Amendment. I also complained about Clapper’s prevarications and asked why was he still in his job.
    She wrote me a lovely letter back (which I have posted twice on this site) saying I have nothing to worry about given the safeguards in the program to prevent abuse. She was also writing legislation (which she never did) enshrining these protections against abuse.She did not even address Clapper’s lying under oath on March 13, 2013. I knew we were all screwed the moment I read her response.
    I have been patiently waiting for the day to ram the letter she send me back down her scrawny throat. As soon as a more definitive date in 2012 is revealed is she ever going to hear from me!
    Feinstein is one of the most evil politicians to ever have held office.

    • FanGirl says:

      The corruption is the reason they stay in office until they are carried out. They not only have to cover for themselves, but also their families.

  137. chuckyschmucky says:

    Given that the NSA database corruption was occurring for many years, and that it was an audit that uncovered the abuse, why wasn’t it detected by audits earlier than 2016?

  138. Patricia Dolan says:

    Check out the Christmas video of the gingerbread house in Trump tower elevator last December. The painting above the fireplace of Santa Claus. He is holding a “HAMMER”!!!!!!! https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=6&v=Rp3CGHBJjJc

  139. mark says:

    Dennis Montgomery, Larry Klayman, the Hammer. There’s your proof. Makes me think Gitmo and Military Tribunals are for real.

  140. I’d hate to interrupt his retirement, but it sure would be beneficial to the cause of justice to recall Navy Admiral Rogers to active duty for a period not to exceed six (6) months and let him loose to “clean the bilges” of the USS Corruption.

  141. gary says:

    the news says that a stolen nsa tool is reponsible for the ransom virus that hit bodymore. is it possible these contractors that rogers shut off in april of 16 stole the nsa tool?

  142. Ebl says:

    If Holder got IRS records in 2010 in CD format to FBI, it makes you wonder if the 2010, 2012 and 2014 election outcomes might be suspect. How was it that Obama got reelected, other than Romney seemed to quit running for office during the later debates.
    It certainly looks like 2018 election outcomes were suspicious in at least CA and AZ. I find it odd that that there is little reporting on and no investigation by the US gov. It’s like Agency employees and representatives to the US and State governments conspired to defraud the electorate in 2018.
    How ugly is this baby?

  143. Chuck Arnold says:

    NOW that we have the PROOF that OBAMA and the DIRTY COPS have been using “THE HAMMER’ to SPY on people and then BLACKMAIL THEM, like they did SUPREME COURT CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS, who should be REMOVED from the COURT IMMEDIATELY, WHY haven’t THEY been ARRESSTED yet????

    • strateshooter says:

      because the fake news media would instigate a civil war.
      The Dems ( I believe) need to be exposed as performing
      1. Crimes against Children and /or
      2. Espionage/Treason against the USA
      before the guy in the street walks away in general disgust.
      Anything else , the media will cover for them and hide stuff for them.

  144. litenmaus says:

    “More importantly, research indicates the modern political exploitation of the NSA database, for weaponized intelligence surveillance of politicians, began mid 2012.”
    March 2012 Eric Holder grants the NCTC the authority to collect, store, and analyze extensive data COLLECTIONS OF US CITIZENS compiled from governmental and non-governmental sources for suspicious behavior through pattern analysis AND to share the databases with foreign states.
    December 17, 2012 – Trey Gowdy & Jason Chaffetz send letter to Eric Holder expressing concerns over the rules change governing the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC). Under the new powers, the NCTC can store dossiers on U.S. citizens, even if those citizens are not suspected of any criminal activity. Reps. Chaffetz and Gowdy are alarmed these alterations were made to current policy without public input, notification, or approval”.
    NCTC = FBI….

  145. William Schneider says:

    Thanks Sundance for working this madness out for us who have day jobs. Your insights are priceless. Again I pray you have the presidents ear-or at least one of his inner circle who can be trusted.

  146. Wick46 says:

    I have an educated guess on the identities of two other contractors in addition to Fusion GPS that were accessing the NSA database after 2012. One that I am fairly confident of is Booz Allen Hamilton. The other might be Pluribus International Corporation. B.A.H. employed Edward Snowden who leaked NSA classified info. in 2013 and they also at one point employed James Clapper. Pluribus employed Reality Winner who leaked NSA classified info. in 2017 which lead to her conviction. Seems likely that Snowden and Winner were given access to the NSA database in order to perform work their respective companies were doing for the U.S. Intelligence community.

  147. Amy Lulu says:

    Joe DiGenova compliments The Conservative Treehouse and @Sundance! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AQhzliyWRck

Comments are closed.