The 213-page Supreme Court ruling in Dobbs -v- Jackson (Mississippi case) is FOUND HERE. The ruling in the Dobbs case was 6-3 in favor of allowing Mississippi to place limits on abortion after 15 weeks. However, in combination with the Dobbs decision the court has overturned (by a 5-4 vote) the 1972 Roe -vs- Wade decision that created a constitutional right to abortion.
Chief Justice John Roberts joined with the majority on the Dobbs decision (Mississippi) but said he did not agree with the decision to overturn Roe. The vote to overturn Roe was 5-4. Justices Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh, and Amy Coney Barrett joined Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion.
Due to an unprecedented leak in the Alito draft opinion in May, the Roe decision was anticipated. The leaked draft opinion showed that a majority of the justices were privately poised to remove a constitutional right for abortion; today that step was taken.
SCOTUS BLOG – […] Alito began his 79-page opinion by observing that abortion “presents a profound moral issue on which Americans hold sharply conflicting views.” But the Constitution does not refer to abortion at all, Alito stressed, and nothing in the Constitution implicitly protects the right to an abortion.
Although the Supreme Court’s decisions in Roe and Casey established such a right, Alito continued, those decisions should nonetheless be overruled despite the principle of stare decisis – the idea that courts should not overturn their prior precedent unless there is a compelling reason to do so. Noting that some of the Supreme Court’s other landmark decisions, such as Brown v. Board of Education, rejecting the “separate but equal” doctrine, had overruled precedent, Alito emphasized that Roe was “egregiously wrong and deeply damaging” and – along with Casey – should not be allowed to stand. Instead, Alito concluded, the issue of abortion should “return … to the people’s representatives.” (read more)
Abortion rights activists and politicians have been preparing for this moment for two months. Immediately after the decision to overturn Roe was released all of the far-left activists, media stenographers and politicians began reacting.
This supreme court ruling will lead several news cycles and opposing it will form the cornerstone of the 2022 Democrat mid-term election campaign in every state. The media have been polling this abortion issue since the draft leak in early May.
CNN did an extensive poll on the abortion issue of young people voting – [pdf here]
CTH pulled all the poll data into one easier to read infographic of the responses by age (below). The 18-to-34-year group are not single-issue voters.
31% of that age group say a candidate MUST agree with them on abortion, while 69% say abortion is only one of several factors or not much of a factor.
The 18–34-year group is also reasonably pragmatic. If Roe v Wade overturned, 21% say abortions likely to be banned where they live; 31% say likely harder but not banned; 26% say it wouldn’t make a difference; and 22% not sure what would happen where they live.
Cowardly RINOs voted to support taking away peoples right to have fire arms during thus huge news day intentionally so that their votes would go under the radar. COWARDS!
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/andr.13209
Viable sperm donations dropping among vaccinated young men. Maybe just maybe we were about to see pregnancy numbers drop like a rock. Now there’s an explanation and as a bonus here’s another reason for riots
Wait – what?
You think people are going to riot over ‘sperm donations dropping’?
Lol
I am so happy about this decision.
I see that California, Oregon, and Washington have declared themselves “sanctuary” states.
COW states.
As my friends in the UK would say
“silly cow”
I live in a state with a Trigger law to end pretty much all abortion in my state.😁
Still no group shot with Justice Jumanji?
had to look it up
PER US GOV DATA: approx. 600,000-800,000 child Genocide abortions per yr in US
approx: 12,000-14,000 deaths/murders by firearms
Facts are facts. Democrats are either brainwashed or pure evil
And think about all those murdered children, over a fifty year span of abortions, whose *future* offspring were also denied their place in the generations to follow.
How many additional souls were denied their rightful place in our world?
It’s not either-or. For their take on Scientism, recall the First Law of Research: Facts not corresponding to the theory must be disposed of.
I worry about the safety of Thomas, Alito and Kavanaugh now.
The crazy left will try something
Be praying for their safety.
The crazy left and others will always “try something” that creates confusion and fear to separate us from God.
There is nothing new under the sun.
As long as we are right with God, we have nothing to fear in this world. I commend those who refuse to ‘bend a knee’ to evil, especially when they realize that doing so will cost them something.
That consequence is temporary and means nothing, compared to what it costs us if we surrender to evil.
Trump was right.
The US was in the bottom 7 of 198 nations that allow abortion on demand after 20 weeks.
Since yesterday, we are no longer standing with China and North Korea.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2017/10/09/is-the-united-states-one-of-seven-countries-that-allow-elective-abortions-after-20-weeks-of-pregnancy/
.
I haven’t weighed in on the court’s decision yet because I suspect that the many hours that it took me today to read and study in depth all of it, including the appendices and concurring and dissenting opinions and footnotes is just not something that many people, including various pundits actually have done.
I will say this though: for me the opinion demonstrates that Alito’s intellect is orders of magnitude greater than Kavanaugh’s or Roberts’s, and that Clarence Thomas is in a stratospheric category beyond that all by himself.
Remarkable to me, and distressing too, is that Roberts either did not understand the majority decision or else is seriously compromised. Alan Dershowitz today has been parroting his opinion that the decision should have been narrower (or something) without saying that this is also Roberts’s concurring opinion. Dersh, of course is a committed leftist. But what is up with Roberts? intellectually limited or also pandering to the left?
Meanwhile, as I write this, people in my neighborhood are setting off fireworks. 🙂
.
Robert’s known as an “incrementalist” re: Dobbs and Roe v Wade
.
Majority opinion explained why that could not be done here — more gentle than I would have been. There was no option to be “incremental”. Anything pretending to be would only have compounded the problems of unworkable judicial “legislating” but also was an “option” explicitly rejected by both sides in the case.
.
Concur, on Alito and Thomas (also after having read the decision). The additional notations are destined to be notations in others’ treatments of this decision going forward. Their output is a pleasure to read.
Roberts seems to be owned for some time now.
I thought it was a known fact that Roberts is compromised. Adopting children from Ireland is illegal for non-Irish citizens and Roberts had them trafficked to South America where he picked them up.
https://debatepolitics.com/threads/wikipedia-on-chief-justice-roberts-felony-adoption-of-irish-children-w-22.227984/
Every citizen has a right to LIFE LIFE LIFE , Liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.
Anyone who kills their baby, whether the child is in the womb or in the crib is committing an egregiously sinful act of MURDER. OUR CONSTITUTION FORBIDS IT.
People need to start waking up to the seriousness of sex. It’s not designed for just pleasure, morons.
IT’S YOUR BODY DOING WHAT IT HAS BEEN DESIGNED TO DO. It’s not about your HEALTH at all!
What’s she so mad at Roberts for? Didn’t read it? Lol.
Too bad for her, I kinda had half a crush on Monica until this
I could see what Bill was going for, that thong probably looked pretty good with the moonlight coming thru the windows of the Oval in the dark
Hey, chubby girls need love too – gnomesayin’ ?
Oh, so Monica is doing the pronoun nonsense? She deserved Bill.
That 18-34 yr. demographic, consists of people born and raised during a time that murdering a fetus was accepted behavior. Why would they feel any different now? The roots of our demise lie far, far back in our history.
I think you misunderstood. That demo, which includes myself, are actually more pro life than Gen Xers. Sundance is saying that the young folks aren’t really up in arms over Roe.
What? American citizens now free to engage in politics? The system’s not set up for that!
good one, Joe
To ensure our Rights come from God and not from the government, current SCOTUS corrected their predecessors error of “giving” the right to abortion through RvW.
Only God can give.
Governments can only take.
The Supreme Court did NOT overturn a Constitutional Right to an Abortion. No such “right” exists anywhere, and certainly not within the Constitution which grants or provides for exactly ZERO Rights.
The Constitution mandates that the Federal Government’s purpose for existence is to Protect our God-Given Natural Rights.