The New York lawsuit against the Trump administration -over disqualification of unlawful aliens in the 2020 election- was dismissed today by the Supreme Court [full pdf here] under procedural grounds.
However, that said, there is a clear indication where the outcome is likely to end-up once the court takes up the case next year.
The high court noted no harm currently exists because the census report hasn’t been delivered to congress to begin the representative apportionment.
The ruling was 6-3 on process, with justices Elena Kagan, Sonia Sotomayor and Stephen Breyer signing a dissent on the case. Justice Breyer wanted to fire a shot into the administration by outlining a liberal opinion/perspective of the issue:
…”The plain meaning of the governing statutes, decades of historical practice, and uniform interpretations from all three branches of Government demonstrate that aliens without lawful status cannot be excluded from the decennial census solely on account of that status,” Breyer wrote. “The Government’s effort to remove them from the apportionment base is unlawful, and I believe this Court should say so.”
Beyond the liberal argument this majority part should alarm everyone:
[…] “Everyone agrees by now that the Government cannot feasibly implement the memorandum by excluding the estimated 10.5 million aliens without lawful status,” the opinion later said. “Yet the only evidence speaking to the predicted change in apportionment unrealistically assumes that the President will exclude the entire undocumented population.” (read more)
In essence what the court is saying is they will not support unlawful aliens being excluded from the census and, as a consequence, congressional representation. It is just too early for them to decide because the harm has not been incurred.
This is an alarming position when cast against the recent SCOTUS decisions on 2020 election. Texas has no standing to file suit based on harm from election fraud, the voices of Texas voters are moot to the court; and now the same court is saying any unlawful alien residing in the United States should be granted a voice in government.
They are forcing our VSG President Trump to pull the maximum load every minute of every day. His success has made them rabid animals. They have now resorted to unprecedented fraud in our faces. The response to this must be swift, complete and as they say, “served cold”!
Basically, what the Supreme Court is saying is that any type of minority especially illegal immigrants, refugees, criminals, Blacks, Hispanics, Muslims, Gays, Lesbians, Transgenders and, of course, Bolsheviks have super-rights while White Christian Americans don’t have any rights at all. According to the Supreme Court a White Christian American baker has to make a wedding cake for a gay wedding because his religious rights don’t count on the other hand an Orthodox Jewish NYPD police applicant has a religious right to wear a yamika, spit curls and beard instead of the required NYPD Uniform and grooming standard.
Muslims and Indians have the same religious freedom in the NYPD as orthodox Jews, but if it makes you feel any better, DeBlasio and Cuomo are imposing harsher crackdowns on the orthodox neighborhoods.
I don’t think that DeBlasio and Cuomo should crack down on Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods at all and giving Muslims and Indians Super-rights as well is exactly my point. When do White Christians get Super-rights or even just plain ordinary rights????
Georgia signature match review announced, will complete by 12/31
https://www.investmentwatchblog.com/georgia-signature-match-review-announced-will-complete-by-12-31/
Somehow I doubt that GA can complete an honest “signature review” by 12/31/20.
This will turn out to be yet another Rubber Stamp on the previously reported fraudulent election results.
I’m curious as to how they could screw this up. A single forged signature without benefit of the original should be very easy to spot. For example, without an original to copy I can guarantee that you wouldn’t be able to forge my signature in a million years. And a batch of ballots mass forged by the same person would be even easier to spot. The forgers didn’t expect things to progress this far, so there was no need for precision and they probably got sloppy. Very sloppy. Remember these are not professional forgers with originals and time, but rather petty criminals probably paid by the hour. I could be wrong. For example, if the forgers had access to a database of originals, such as DMV images and time, then we are facing a different problem altogether. However, no one has suggested that level of sophistication thus far. The fraud has generally been rather sloppy and designed to overwhelm, rather that slip through by stealth, There is a reason the SOS and Abrams did not want signature verification. I expect that the results will be startling. We will know shortly.
I feel like we’re all thumbs in this period of massive stonewalling at critical choke points at every level , states, local and federal.
Left thumb on the wallet.
Right thumb on a hammer…
Supreme Comedy
Per my son:
SCOTUS
Spineless
Cowards
Of
The
United
States
Time for POTUS Trump to declare a Constitutional crisis, then openly rebuke SCOTUS for ignoring that the Constitution only allows US citizens the privilege of voting and not felons, illegals, underage citizens, deceased persons and foreign nationals which evidence indicated happened if only SCOTUS took up the pending cases. He the needs to invoke his September EO while calling up the military and declare the 2020 election invalid/tainted and order a new election with stringent safeguards in place. SCOTUS can whine and complain all they want and declare these actions unConstitutional while POTUS Trump reminds them it is they who are not enforcing the Constitutional rights of we the people and contributing to the 2020 voter fraud. This is a burn the house down moment and rebuild it to the specifications outlined in the Constitution. If SCOTUS can’t act like an independent coequal branch of the government enforcing the Constitution, they also need to be cast aside and rebuilt. Time to round up the traitors.
As far as I can tell, the SCOTUS has not said that illegals can vote. Only that they can be included in the census which is used to apportion seats in the HoR. (As much as I disagree with that interpretation of the Constitution)
But, yes, this is a problem for Conservatives because it will add more seats for the Dem loons in CA to fill.
But, wouldn’t it ALSO add more seats in TX, which is a RED state?
I would like to see the math on this.
Well, it won’t be a red state for long. And with fraudulent elections now the norm the blue states will be from coast to coast.
We don’t really know how much red and blue there is. Probably lots less legal blue votes, MANY more “adjudicated”/switched/”lost” red votes.
The democrats have had 40 years free pass on large election scale election frauds. No telling how much before the 1980s “Consent decree’ to swell their inflated vote numbers..
In 2016 Hillary et al’s total surprise at her defeat makes me think millions of votes fraud. Milllions more on top of that to be sure for the CCP’s demented rental candidate, Zhou (“joe”)B. in 2020.
Giving illegal immigrants apportioned representation in the HR is in fact giving illegal immigrants the right to vote via representatives in Congress.
Right now the number of voting representatives is fixed by law at 435 with 6 non voting members for at total of 461. Unless to total number of voting members is increased, a state gaining a represntative means another state loses a representative. Illegals who broke the law to enter this country are currently used in the census to apportion the number of representives a state gets even though they committed a federal felony, legally cannot vote and take advantage of taxpayer funding enrolling in programs originally intended for citizens.It’s nothing more than a ploy to increase the voting bloc of blue states. Just the basic liberal pay for vote scheme.
Well they must because they’re refusiing to take any case that clearly shows voter fraud with illegals and others who should be Constitutionally barred from voting. No matter how you cut it, refusing to view legtimate evidence is nothing more than an admission of acceptance.
Obstruction of Justice
I don’t care what color the state is. What rights are we giving the illegals by counting them to be represented?
Well, for one, they shouldn’t even be in the USA in order to be counted or represented. Why does it seem no one used that simple common sense reality.
They have no standing to be represented – end of story, really. Paired with what Dewayne posted above (edit: post is actually below), it is a no-brainer for any court, especially the SC, to rule on.
It is time to reign in the SC. This court is very biased and has shown that they in fact want to destroy the middle class and America as a whole. I have a feeling that many of them are compromised by the deep state.
Trump’s greatest legacy, his magna conlationem, is that he exposed the deep state. He may never know the debt we owe him. Perhaps more than any other patriot of historical American renown, he has exposed the deep state, The enemy within, the useful idiots, whether political parties, ⬇︎upreme court, intelligence (both foreign and domestic), ⬇︎ustice, media, or your neighbor.
Give them no quarter, no sympathy, no credit, no consideration. #WeKnow. And #WeWon’tForget. It doesn’t mean you’re not civil to your neighbor as far as it goes; it means you know that he’s the one who’ll snitch on you when the time comes; he’s the moiser looking out of his curtain to see if your family is over for Christmas; if you’re wearing your mask, an overheard conversation, an innocuous FB post, “Avenge me! Avenge me! Avenge, America!!”
All Democrats, #NeverTrumpers, Rino’s, All Republicans who didn’t stand up, ….your neighbors. #BeAware
https://duckduckgo.com/?q=red+dawn+revenge+me+you+tube&iax=videos&ia=videos&iai=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DW6qWnmb_22s
Any statement claiming “everyone agrees” on something signals its fraud From the outset. What Breyer is really saying in his opinion is that since all the branches have failed to deal with the issue of illegal immigration except to ignore it, the illegal immigrants should just be given what they came here illegally to get. What a moronic opinion. FWIW, if I was born in some of these hell hole countries I’d take my chances and try to get into the USA any way I could. I don’t blame them.
At this point, it is obvious that the Supreme Court is completely politicized and compromised that I do not pay any attention to what the say….always taking the squishy way out of every decision. I blame the chief justice for this.
Here is a link to a blog with several articles discussing the cases before SCOTUS and dissecting the Texas case. He has his own case before SCOTUS that sounds promising. Well worth a look-see and a deep dive. I followed Donofrio while he challenged Obama’s Natural Born Citizen (NBC) qualification for President in 2007/2008, and then his uncovering of Justia-gate – the intentional scrubbing of all online legal references that supported the original intent of the NBC clause. He fought gallantly for his cases to be heard but at every turn the judiciary refused to here the merits of his cases. Deja vu.
https://naturalborncitizen.wordpress.com/
President Trump is a great American. He has exposed the Deep State. From the very first day he focused on Illegal Aliens and China. John Roberts May he silenced US, but he lost because Trump awakened a sleeping giant.
Really, we did not deserve a man in full like President Donald Trump. A gift to the world that will last through the ages. Thank you dear President for your fantastic
service.
Found in the bin…. 🙁
The thank you to PTrump to continue for the next 4yrs. PTrump is in the same position as the founding fathers’ declaring War on Great Britain.
We now have no voice.. any petitions by the States are now pointless folly..
The Concept of America was conceptual as much as it was logical.. our Founders called it Common Sense..
But weak men.. Traitors.. have sold out this prime number part of America.. the part that many brave men fought and died for.. sold it out for their own composite temporary gain..
The Union itself without America makes it just another collapsing carcass for the vultures to scavenge..
So why stay in agreement with their Union that is collapsing into Tyranny.. why get caught in their foreign entanglements.. why go down with them..
It’s their mess.. not ours..
..Secede..
I copied this recently and haven’t called yet, but after seeing this I plan to call on Monday. Unbelievable.
Time to burn up some phone lines. This is ridiculous. Pass it on.
PATRIOTS! CALL SCOTUS & DEMAND THEY HEAR CASES RELATED TO VOTER FRAUD! 202-479-3011 choose OPTION 5 right away. LEAVE A MESSAGE
I plan to bring up what Sundance said.
By rejecting the Texas case on election fraud the voices of Texas voters and many others were silenced…
but it looks like SCOTUS will not exclude unlawful aliens from the census which means illegal aliens will have a voice in our government but Texas voters and many others regarding voter fraud will not. Unreal.
SCOTUS probably needs to give California and New York 2/5 representation credit for the illegal aliens. They could call it the Dread Roberts Rule. Unfortunately, nobody has standing to litigate.
Remember them. In 2022 remember them. Only vote for those who will vote to impeach the felons on the Supreme Court. All SEVEN of them.
Stephen Breyer, which part of the word “illegal” do you not understand?
So criminal aliens get representation in Congress?