There is finally some factual information that has surfaced as a result of Palmer Luckey (Andril, weapons tech) and Elon Musk (SpaceX) that sheds light on the Ukraine issues surrounding Starlink and Starshield.
Zelenskyy is Lying! [23:00]
It started with Palmer Luckey giving a simple explanation about how Musk was put in an untenable position by Volodymyr Zelenskyy and his duplicitous European advocates. Essentially, the U.S. Military and NATO do not want their military satellite constellation known as Starshield to be destroyed by Russia as legitimate military targets. Instead, the advocates for Ukraine want Elon Musk to provide Ukraine with access to the commercial product Starlink so they can hide behind an obfuscation that NATO is not assisting Ukraine directly.
When questioned about it, Musk confirms that Zelenskyy is lying, NATO leaders in Europe are lying and U.S. advocates for Zelenskyy are lying. Starlink is not permitted to be used for offensive military purposes, it is a commercial network, and Musk has no interest in seeing his commercial product destroyed if Russia labels it as a military target. Ukraine has never been given permission to use Starlink for military operations. Zelenskyy is lying. WATCH (prompted):
The United States and EU-NATO have never authorized Ukraine to use Starshield, a completely separate satellite system.
The reasoning is simple, if the U.S/EU-NATO authorize Zelenskyy to use Starshield, Russia may, quite understandably, destroy it because it represents a legitimate military target. It is a risk NATO is unwilling to make.
The remarks by Palmer Luckey are embedded below.
Palmer Luckey on why he believes Elon Musk shouldn’t have to risk the entire Starlink network for Ukraine when the U.S. government isn’t willing to take the same risk with Starshield. https://t.co/CcyQHWg9pO
— Wall St Engine (@wallstengine) November 18, 2026
.…”Nobody in the west actually want’s Ukraine to win; they just want them to not lose for as long as possible.”
With that full understanding at the forefront of any further discussion, now we enter the world of Machiavellian interests.
Canada (Mark Carney) and the EU-NATO coalition demand Elon Musk provide his commercial product to be used by Ukraine for military purposes. This provides them cover and they don’t care if it is targeted or destroyed by Russia.
Canada and Europe do not have a comparable satellite communication system. They don’t care if Starlink is destroyed, because it is a system that is well ahead of their capability. They position a private company, SpaceX, to lose their system because they have no downside to Russia destroying it.
Worse still, the U.S. military don’t care if Musk’s system is destroyed because the powers behind the U.S. military industrial complex don’t like the diminishment of their control. The U.S. military don’t like the capability of a U.S. company to meet or exceed their own capability. It’s like Musk having a private weapon that is on par with, perhaps even superior to, the weapon operated by the military.
The U.S. military has never authorized Zelenskyy to use the military version called Starshield.
The U.S. military don’t want their Starshield satellite targeting system destroyed by Russia. So, they are hiding behind Starlink and European leaders are demanding that Musk put his commercial product at risk to support Ukraine.

So what happens when the radical globalists take over the WH, Congress, SC and all leadership positions in our military in 2029?
Is that when we see the first space dogfights as StarShield tries to take down Starlink and the government blames it on the Russians?
Also doesn’t this mean even today PT does not have control over his own government or military, right?
All those who voted against R’s because of their fear of war get to go to Ukraine!
Your last sentence is ridiculous given how things are playing out. You sound like you are either a bot or a liberal hack; which one are you?
Realistic answer
I don’t believe for a minute that even with the degree of hubris they display, they’re willing to risk rendering space useless.
I think you under estimate both their intentions and their disdain for the people…as well as their belief that they are above it all.
My bet is democrats will federalise Elon’s X and Starlink products and therefore have control of information and the Ukraine debacle. They are already squealing about all his money and obviously think it should be theirs.
I think he would destroy it before giving it up…
YES.
noting: starlink (not shield) has NOT geofenced Ukraine. Could, but has not.
combine these two facts and you get a proper understanding of the dubious arguments made about LINK AND SHIELD.
also noting: SHIELD does NOT have the kind of mesh density to form a practical real time network to direct weapons. Add that fact to the entire discussion. (shield flies 240-400 worldwide. not all of these are available at orbital trajectories that fly over Ukraine. And of the 240-400 one can estimate that about 70 percent are operational ..meaning “can be used” for military purposes. The other 30 percent are “preserved” or off line due to end of life, or from other maintenance or damage reasons) Compare this to starSHIELD, that flies 11,200 operational satellites, with a significant number of that flying directly and operational over Ukraine and Russia.
“do the math” is relevant here.
God Bless America
God Bless America
Thanks reg i always value your input to to our tree be well God Bless
I have seen a number of times that “Starlink is not permitted to be used for offensive military purposes“. But that is not the same as saying it is not possible to use it for offensive military purposes. So, if someone has access to Starlink, can they (without permission of course) make use of it in such a way to conduct offensive military strikes? Even if it does not provide the same targeting accuracy as Starshield, it probably does not matter much when you are launching swarms of hundreds of drones at a single target.
That’s exactly what Ukraine did and why this all came out. They hacked the GPS cards on the drones to make it look like they were staying still or no faster than the 80 mph limit on Starlink.
Forgot to add that when Musk found out, he over rode their hack and slowed them back down. That’s when Zelensky complained his access was cut off.
I am not sure that that would provide the accurate location and I would think they would miss satelite handoffs I would think. Do you have a source for this??
Sundance covered this already. The handoff between satellites is how Ukraine was caught. When a system reported being stationary but the signal was being passed to other Starlink satellites in a way that could only happen if it were flying very quickly, the terminal was banned from the network. I believe Sundance had citations in the previous article. Search this site for Starlink and the article should be in the results.
It’s not like Ukraine doesn’t have some brilliant engineers capable of trying to warp the starlink — that Musk gave them — into a targeting system. That may be why it went offline for a while. Don’t blame them for trying, don’t blame starlink for defending itself.
You are correct.
The terms and conditions for Starlink from previous information and Elon’s statements here, state that “Starlink is NOT for military purposes”.
Zelensky is a pos dictator puppet who is using it against Starlink’s terms and conditions. He has clearly been using Starlink for military purposes. Elon could shut it off because ukraine has violated the terms and conditions, but Elon has allowed ukraine to continue violating the terms and conditions.
zelensky could have made a peace agreement years ago which would have ceded the Russian speaking and ethnically oriented territory of ukraine. It would have ended the war years ago and saved tens of thousands of lives on both sides.
Eastern ukraine had been under attack by western ukraine for a period of time prior to the war, killing the ethnically Russian people of eastern ukraine who were aligned more closely with Russia.
Boris Johnson, former globalist puppet prime minister was sent to ukraine to tell zelensky to not agree to terms of peace. Both he and zelensky will burn for eternity for their actions as will victoria nuland and all the war pigs involved in the color revolution and continuation of this senseless war.
The truth sounds so good, keep it coming
Musk is rich enough to tell the EU/NATO to pound sand
yes,
Mr. Musk is rich
and
Mr. Musk is smart….he can tell whoever to whatever, and Mr. Musk is very fair.
Mr Musk rich and smart enough to pay a legion of much smarter people to create his legacy.
Mr. Muskrat should hire real Americans for a change and stop threatening to fk Americans in the face.
Smart, that’s why he supported Biden and Desantis. Or whoever he thinks is going to win at the time. About as predictable as a two face coin
Put me in the ABSOLUTELY NOT SURPRISED category.
How would someone know if their commercial satellite network is being used for military purposes?
Ask Elon Muak …. 🙂
Do you suppose mobile phone carriers know if a phone is connected to a detonator on a terrorist bomb? I’m sure phone companies don’t permit their services to be used for terrorism. But just because it is not permitted doesn’t mean it can be warily detected or even stopped.
Starlink has a maximum allowed ground speed set for moving vehicles using their system. Ukraine (with assistance?) found a way to spoof Starlink into believing their drones, missiles, etc. were moving below the maximum allowed speed or even standing still. When Starlink discovered what was happening they took measures to detect and override the spoof to shut down service to vehicles exceeding the speed limitation.
This is what ‘Z’ was complaining about when he said Starlink service had been cut off. He meant that the illegal use of Starlink service in high speed vehicles had been shut down. Then he started conflating Starlink and Starshield to confuse the issue.
‘Z’ was using the Starlink service illegally or against terms of service and Starlink shut him down. Did/does Ukraine have access to the U.S. government controlled Starshield system? Is some agency (CeyeA) within the U.S. government providing covert access to Starshield for Ukraine? Is a NATO ally doing so? All good questions that should be answered.
Thanks for that clarification
Someone apparently gives the Uks access to something capable of targeting their drones and I don’t think it’s Mr. Musk. That leaves US alphabet agencies and EU.
So the targeting by Z continues so the question becomes are his drones traveling under 80 miles per hour or is Z being given starship by the US keyholders. Or are they just running this off GPS, publically available satellite imaging and ground surveillance.? Possible they are doing final leg handoffs to local remote pilots. If it was the former the tell would be the equipment. By now we would have seen highly public arrests
It becomes more and more obvious how evil and corrupt the cokehead globalist puppet Zee really is. His enablers in the EU/NATO are just as bad. That dump Ukraine has always been a corrupt cesspool. Musk should shut down his entire Starlink system there, that would end their BS
How would Russia shoot down 11,500 starlink satellites?
He wouldn’t need to shoot down all of them.
The debris generated from the kessler effect would cripple many more satellites subsequent to the initial strikes.
And also destroy all of their satellites as well? I doubt it.
Orbital debris is an issue now that requires avoidance from time to time in low Earth orbit.
It will not improve for the better if in some near term conflict several dozen satellites are destroyed in low Earth orbit.
You fly a rocket through them. It’s not complicated once you’re up there.
See my comment above. Destroying Starlink satellites by creating debris would also destroy Russia and China and Indias satellites. That is not a good outcome for Russia. Persistent cyber attacks would be far more likely.
Starlink satellites are in lower orbits than most. All someone would have to do is create a debris fied in that particular altitude. Other satellites in higher orbits would not be affected.
Gonna show my ignorance here.
Why doesn’t Elon just withdraw Starlink from the arena?
I am reminded of the old Tom Lehrer lyric, “‘Once the rockets go up, who cares where they go down. That’s not my department,’ says Wernher von Braun.”
And the bunkers keep being built for unknown reasons.
Live tracker for the astroid that enters earth’s geostationary belt in 2029. https://apophisalert.com/tracker
Musk has preplanned for an incoming astroid.
It’s a parody of what von Braun actually said when colleagues celebrated the first successful V1: “Yes, but it landed on the wrong planet.”
Did a Brit have a hand in writing this? I note the use of a plural verb with a singular (collective) noun. In America, that is bad grammar.
Please turn off Starlink.
If the dems take over in 2029 the results will catastrophic. They will use the same tactics in Georgia, Texas etc. Again and again if they are not stopped now. We will NOT be able to vote out of this no matter how hard we try.
It will be WWIII.
Zelensky is liar, really? Because for a minute there I thought he was being honest.
he/they are lying about
EVERYTHING
Soup to Nuts
But the war in Ukraine is real. They wouldn’t lie about that right?
Musk would never lie either btw… he’s one of us like Putin. Sarc
Ridiculous
Good ol’ Elon !!
The U.S. military don’t like the capability of a U.S. company to meet or exceed their own capability. It’s like Musk having a private weapon that is on par with, perhaps even superior to, the weapon operated by the military.
Our founding fathers, when discussing the subject of weapons, felt that the people had a right to weapons equal to or better than the government…
“Nobody in the west actually want’s Ukraine to win; they just want them to not lose for as long as possible.”
In other words the NATO strategy in Ukraine is a repeat of LBJ’s losing strategy for Vietnam.
Johnson was afraid to escalate for fear of provoking the Soviets. He would not do what was needed to win the war. He wanted to fund his “Great Society” programs. He tried balancing domestic and war spending, aka “Guns and Butter.” But he wouldn’t end the war either because he didn’t want to be blamed for losing: “I am not going to lose Vietnam, I am not going to be the president who saw Southeast Asia go the way China went.” he told ,” he told the ambassador to South Vietnam, Henry Cabot Lodge Jr., two days after assuming office.
So the war dragged on year after year and thousands of young Americans and a million Vietnamese died.
No sure whose comment to reply to tonight. When Elon said Zelensky is lying. For me, I was hoping Elon or Lucky would have mentioned Zelensky being a cocaine addict. Of course Zelinsky is lying. That is the profile of cocaine addict.
Ipersonally know a former cocaine addict, one that I’ve known since I was five years old. Through the years this person has told me that they were on the mission that dumped Osama Bin Laden’s body at sea , that they were a Navy Seal, etc, etc. etc. Hard to separate truth from fiction. But assuredly, the body of my friend has been broken and has to travel to a VA hospital to get p*ss poor care.
Someone is supporting Zelinsky’s cocaine addiction. Could it be the Ursula, Carney? Que bono? Or who benefits from Zelinsky being a cocaine addict? Someone has a vested interest in keeping Zelinsky high on cocaine so that he cannot separate fact from fiction.
Eric Clapton – Cocaine.
“Zelenskyy is lying. ”
Imagine that….