A few days ago, I wrote an allegory, “Rise Up Old Mules“, with the full intention of reviewing comments and following up the next day to see if people still held the knowledge of coded writing. [Idalia delayed my review]
An allegory is a literary work that makes extensive use of symbolism in order to communicate a broader moral or meaning. Nearly every aspect of an allegory—from characters, to objects, to dialogue, to settings, to major plot events—can typically be interpreted as having a secondary, symbolic meaning that fits into the allegory’s broader meaning.
In the writing of our forefathers, and even many writings long before and a few still today, allegories were/are used to convey messages publicly that are interpreted with a silent understanding. They were/are essentially coded messages from rebels, insurgent dissidents, in various societies who were working within the boundaries of government review.
You may have vague reference points from similar formats of communication that took place in various prisoner of war camps.
How do POWs communicate when their captors are constantly monitoring their activity? The never spoken language of POW’s in a prison camp has a similar allegorical communication style.
The best allegories communicate from a factual reference point about subject matter, but then weave the current context or power conflict within it so as not to attract the understanding of censors, monitors or those in power who seek to stop any form of communication that is against the interests of the oppressive regime.
It is a communication style lost over time as successive generations no longer taught or had need for the skillset to understand the implied message. However, in this modern era where six corporations control all media; where there is direct collaboration between the government censors and social media platforms over content; where arbiters of acceptable speech under the auspices of “disinformation review panels” are now deployed using both human review and automated intelligence; it is worthwhile revisiting the old ways to understand a method of discussing rebellion in public.
There is one big benefit to the deployment of AI search spiders crawling all over the internet to analyze and identify subversive speech. AI cannot detect allegorical writing patterns, it never will. Current AI sweeps, crawls and searches are based on human inputs to create the pattern context the AI is launched to discover.
Y’all know, I test weird stuff in the tech communication space just to probe how effective the new mechanics are, and create strategies around their constructs. Allegorical writing was designed to communicate subversive information in the sunlight of public presentation. Historically, human censors could not see the implied meaning in allegorical communication, and the content itself – if correctly structured – carries an inherent deniability.
From my review, about half (+/-) CTH readers understood the implied meaning, about half did not. Approximately 10% were absolutely clueless, and a few even found the inverse meaning within the story.
Approximately half of the CTH audience picking up the implications within an allegory is much better than I expected, much better. This is an interesting outcome, although given the high intelligence and specific demographics of the CTH family it makes sense.
My point is this: teach your friends and family, especially the younger family members, how to understand coded public messaging and what context frames the cornerstone of how it is delivered.
The old ways are going to be important if a few strategically placed voices are going to be forced to mount a successful counterinsurgency against an entire UniParty system, that aligns with an oppressive regime.
Mules = soldiers.
Exceptional Mules = special forces.
Collars = rifles.
The silent wise men at auction = leadership (think founding fathers).
The fields = the battles.
The farmers = YOU!

Yep, I failed your test. I pray I will be able and ready if a call comes.
I did as well.
To the corner on a high stool facing the corner with a dunce cap on for me.
No, go back and READ Sundances articleon “mules” again, after having seen the”cheat sheet” above; THATS how YOU learn, and hence hoe you will teach others.
We learn BY DOING, we learn by making a MISTAKE, or”not getting itthe first time” and there is NO SHAME in learning, every time you makea mistake (and recognise and aknowlege you made a mistake you LEARNED SOMETHING.
No shame in that.
You’re sweet, dutch…love you…
…indeed…
Have had a saying to people that worked for me after they had something go wrong—if everything worked as planned every time you would not know how to fix it when it goes wrong.
Knowing how to do something now means there mistakes in the past.
My Geography teacher in High School gave me six on each hand with a leather strap, after a particularly stupid endeavour on my part, and told me that my graduation was like a drivers license so smarten up.
That was fifty years ago in Scotland.
I too failed the test, my hope is Sundance is more lenient than my teacher. 😉
🏴🏴🏴
Ha!! I don’t know, Dekester…
I fell into the”10% absolutely clueless” category…which I thought a bit harsh.
But in my defense, I wasn’t entirely present on that day…or indeed the entire past hot as H E Double HOCKEY STICKS two months.
That’s my excuse, and I’m sticking to it 😎
It’s interesting how we individuals learn differently.
I learned math from my Granda “ running his line” to the “ bookies” and buying and selling fish.
IMO not enough youngsters are involved in real business transactions as youngsters
Once out of school, all was good.
Our older son had the same challenge. As we walked home from his High School graduation his precise words were “ Thank **** that’s over”
He has never looked back and has, like his younger brother done rather well.
Cheers!
🏴🏴🏴
My husband learned the same from his father in post war Britain. Everything he needed to know to get through this life, he learned. Can’t buy an education like that.
i was provided many lessons starting as a very young child growing up in a rather isolated environment and having many different types of critters to care for, many I was given or gathered myself, both very small and large and tame and wild. In addition, I helped out doing odd jobs during the summer at the ice plant, where the workers and shrimpers knew when I was present in the office or on the deck, all understood their language and behavior was to be done as my father would expect them to remember a lady was in their midst.
Both occasions afforded me many opportunities to learn so much about life and the world at large for such a small child. Once I reached the age of maturity, my beloved father, who was a quiet man of few words, told me told me “You realize you weren’t raised, but sprouted and grew, don’t you?’ It took me years of rolling his comment over and over to figure out what he was talking about, but he, as usual, was right.
I grew into an independent, strong, and passionate person because I received plenty of the proper amounts of sunshine and water necessary to thrive and grow into the person God intended.
I neglected to mention, Arminius was also something I looked up. What a guy
And, I posted all of this in the wrong place, Betsy Jones. My apologies to you and @Arminius. Proofreading is still not my strong point.
Is there a wrong place for such a story? I believe there is not Salty. You write beautifully and movingly. If this was the wrong place then I am so glad you made the error. It seems God made many men like my husband’s father. Yours was another. If only there were more, perhaps this old world would be a better place. How proud he must have been of you, as you are grateful for him. Please don’t apologize…lovely…
I was a C- in a public high school but I will take the cue and begin to study allegory writing.
You are a teacher in addition to having been a public school C student. I learned a new word from your post, allegory! I love it. So many instances where I’ve seen an allegory use yet never thought about what the word was the defined it. Thank you, Arminius!
I hope you will take a moment to look at Betsy Jones post where I posted some comments that I inadvertently placed there which were intended to be posted here. 😒
I wasn’t paying attention as I should have been.
We’re making progress, everyone now understands that the fools in Washington are greedy and corrupt beyond imagination.
There remains only one more characteristic to illustrate in order to remove them from power swiftly – that is: THEY’RE STUPID AS ALL GET-OUT. Once we brand them with this you’re going to be surprised how quickly the apparatus falls apart.
Once the timid people in positions of responsibility start to feel secure that’s when you’ll get your accountability – then it will turn into a flood and some very familiar heads are going to roll.
If you’re quick to ascribe conspiracy you don’t appreciate the role that incompetence has played throughout the course of human history. It’s more like they pick the best wave to ride among the breakers of their incompetence to keep their head above water at whatever moment in time (while constantly lining their own pockets). Operative selfishness. It’s a way of life. Just like the fools you know in your daily lives. Only these seem to get away with it because of the largess of the government; but they’re still Morons, even more so.
People need to learn this so they can identify these losers and marginalize them.
How can a fool be in charge? Very easily:
“Down, on some of those occasions, would come a thick mist, and what happened then? Dick Cook (Expert Alpinist) and I (Astro-Physicist Fred Hoyle) would take off our rucksacks, pull out maps and compasses, obtain bearings, and start arguing about what was to be done. Among twenty persons, there was always somebody who knew better however; someone who would stride away boldly into the mist, proclaiming that he knew to a jot where he was and to a tittle exactly how to proceed. Then the amazing thing happened. The rest of the party always–always, I swear –followed our hero.
Dick and I would usually succeed in extricating ourselves from the mist-covered hills and would arrive back at our hotel in time for a bath before dinner. The others would stagger in, hallow-eyed, at later hours running into the early morning, or even more distant time.”
:Obviously they believe their own bullshit which makes them so dangerous and our job so difficult.
Care to explain the relevance of this comment with Sundance’s post?
IMHO, it is elegantly relevant – perhaps another way of saying don’t follow the lemmings, do your own private thinking!
Perhaps – I might add – it was somewhat allegorical! 🙂
gee, I COULD be wrong, but Heats comment seems just a tad,…..ALLEGORICAL, and hence spot on.
Okay, but it’s also real. I’ve seen real people do pretty much exactly this.
The Alegory post message would be by better understood if it followed Sundances rules for posting style to be understood. Double line breaks and spacing would help greatly. The caps worked just fine for emphasis. Lengthy post are always difficult even if you are not using allegorical style.
Dietrich Bonhoeffer had a few words to say on “Stupidity”. Every word accurate.
With a beautiful finish…as one would expect.
https://principia-scientific.com/bonhoeffers-theory-explains-much-of-contemporary-politics-and-culture/
Spectacular article. It has many meaningful dimensions for me. Very comforting too. I will incorporate it into my daily serenity prayer. Thank you.
Copy that 👌 👍 Sundance
Allegorical missives 🤔
Key 🔑 words 😎
😉Designed surface level diversion with undercurrent truth messaging 💯 ✔️ ✅️
Those who know, know.
Que sabe, sabe – as my MIL used to say.
BINGO!!
The Dunbar Effect
Allegory…among other things.
Not sure you could say I consciously got the allegory, but on reading “What Comes After Amen?” my mind went to “Praise the Lord and pass the ammunition!”
Probably thanks to my little old Irish great aunt, of all people.
When I was a little kid visiting her cottage, I asked what all the flag stones that she had made a path out of were for. With a twinkle in her eyes and a smile on her lips she replied, (of course!) “Ammunition!”
I don’t think it’s nice, you laughin’. You see, my mule don’t like people laughing. He gets the crazy idea you’re laughin’ at him. Now if you apologize, like I know you’re going to, I might convince him that you really didn’t mean it. C. Eastwood, Fistful of Dollars. We are here, watching and waiting. Who doesn’t love a good Mule Story?
First thing that came to my mind was “Two Mules For Sister Sara”!
🙂
Me Eastwood and his empty chair speech was another example of allegory.
I was in gulfed into the parallels and imagined what was really being said. Can’t say I knew Mules were soldiers, etc.. but I got the big picture and the analogy used to know what to look for, how to use it and the why. I love it! Thx SD
I failed to associate myself with the mules.
I did relate to the “old” easily.
I actually didn’t get time on that day to do more than glance at it, with no time for comments, being at an all-day event…
Looking back at it now, I simply thought of the mules as representing our millions of deplorables – too dang stubborn to let our country go…
All the rest – zing, directly over my head…
Solders are more like lemmings. Independent thinking is highly discouraged.
SD, that was very obtuse. Really? I was supposed to “get it”. Usually if people are using code, there is general knowledge on what is what.
Action comes after Amen. Amen.
Pass the deviled eggs comes after amen.
I thought passing the collection plate was next.
Intrepid Patriot, my first thought was, now let’s get busy. I’m with you n
Even Christ taught with symbolism and allegory that often went unexplained, and for similar reason: to keep the message from those he didn’t want to have it.
“those that have ears to hear” comes to mind.
The Sun of Good will deliver war as the earths magnetism weakens, it will cause drought, and there will be hunger, disease, and then death.
When I read about the old mules I took it to mean it was time to have a drink (wink, wink) at the Greeen Dragon Tavern. I just didn’t know wjere that was. Also I totally missed the collars analogy.
Will try harder next time
<I totally missed the collars analogy.>
I just received an email from The National Collar Association 🙂
LOL
Collar owners of america is far more effective at protecting your collar. 😉
Not affiliated with Hartz Flea and Tick collars….?
Well, it can be said the right collar WILL keep the fleas and ticks away (parasites of society).
Nuff said.
But they DO keep pests away…..
That took me a few seconds…
Exactly.not too difficult says I. Mules need to plow fields where other mules tend to graze. Farmers should show their colors to ensure the mules know it is safe to graze. Ancient fields are good places to start muling…..plowing contests to make ready for the spring and subsequent harvest!!
I recently became the proud owner of a large new collar.
So the mules aren’t democrats and the collars aren’t nooses?
The Dems like to be associated with mules / donkeys, having made that their symbol. But the truth is that they are more accurately associated with only one part of the mule; that small round opening just below the mule’s tail. That’s because the quality of what comes out of their mouths is most like what comes out of the south end of the northbound mule.
(Yeah I know I’m still flunking the allegory test….)
Your anatomy skills are top notch.
😎
Muleholes. I’m going to use this☺️
🤣
Love this, NanaB! LOL!!!
Nah, I think you passed with flying colors!
😄
you coulda fooled me. I believe this takes a lot of imagination and it helps to have read many books. I believe I flunked too. But hey, google knows all about this form of conversation. It takes up more than a whole page.
I’m still having a mental block at seeing a collar, of all things, as a rifle. Teeth maybe, but a collar?
A collar would be more like a slave mask or face diaper.
Rifle w/a sling?
Good one, JD! LMFAO
I may or may not have failed the test – all I can say is that there was beer involved.
There will be a season for all mules to gather. Strong from walking the fields, climbing the terrain, always with a keen eye to predation. Exceptional mules must finds ways to get the best out of the herd. The harvest of the farmers is the only think that matters.
That one was excellent. Even I understood.
Read it aloud to Ma.
-She got it
I didn’t associate the players with actual people (soldiers, special forces, etc.), but I came away with the gist of what you were saying–the battle before us (doing the hard work of a farmer), the general workers among the public (the farmers), the leaders (the ones who are wise and strong), the ones who have the special skill set to do unique jobs (the exceptional mules).
I never thought I’d be putting my English degree to use here, though!
Thing about the farmer, the work never ceases.
try to avoid owls.
I’m a disciple of The Art of War and a strong believer of death by a thousand paper cuts.
Then you should be familiar with the tale of the Elephant and the Tiger.
Underground speech is tough on the internet but talking to friends and loved ones is impossible to monitor. Unless one is a mole. My oldest is onboard, my middle is coming around. My youngest took awhile but he’s smart, and it’s taking a bit. People are smart and they sense something is wrong, even the diehard lefties.
Love that tavern sign!
“People are smart and they sense something is wrong” This! Was just speaking with a few different folks this week and pointed out that it seems people are starting to realize the issues and have a voice.
While theoretically, its POSSIBLE to monitor/censor snail mail, its really not very practical, except on a small scale, with INDIVIDUALS, so thats a way to communicate.
Graffitti is another, and btw its not just POW’s,ALL prisoners develop a code.
We just made up words, like “chodos” pronounced like ‘joe dose’ meant the guards were coming, it was also a verb as in “keep chodos” meant keep an eye out for the guards.
Also, used existing words, but gave them a sprcualised meaning. Dopers, back when get high drugs were illegal, had all sorts of words for dope.
No fair Dutch. You learned that as a prisoner. But I’ll keep an eye out for the chodos.
Live Stream – TRACKING HURRICANE IDALIA: Latest Track, Interactive Forecast Q&A, New Models – WFLA Tampa
https://commoncts.blogspot.com/2023/08/live-stream-tracking-hurricane-idalia.html
Well played sir, well played.
I knew immediately. sundance doesn’t normally write pieces like that.
Shave and a haircut, 2 bits.
I flunked as well.
I have long lamented we have very limited means of secure communication/coordination.
Unless black market technology has a solution (not likely) .. Our fall back methods my have to be short wave and familiar faces.
Familiar faces = “It is past time to get to know your neighbor”..
Black market is actually VERY likely, I would say.
But yes, MORE face to face, hand written letters, less face in a phone,…
Graffitti is effective, for all sorts of messages, with losts of symbolism, allegories, etc.
Already starting to happen.
Having gone to Catholic schools all my life, I definitely got 100%.
Uh Oh…decode this
FAFO!
My first thought exactly!
Next comes “OUCH!” , then “YIKES!”
Very Funny!!!!
Lawfare is about to be devoured?
Is LGB allegorical writing ?
Absolutely, une double entendre!`
Dont know if these are allegories, but anyone know where I can find some Hotel California quinine? What about some Medication for Allan Iverson?
Completely understood it except for the “old mules”. Interesting that these are your messages. Seems very similar to Q posts.
Retired history teacher here, working hard to absorb as much info as I can to be prepared for discussion and, well, teaching. Allegories are tough, but catchable, and necessary. Sundance I have paraphrased and made your comment my mantra…we must see things as they are, not as we wish them to be. I repeat this daily, and with firm resolve.
Thank you for this space.
The left can’t meme, the would-be Overlords have no sense of humor and AI cannot “read” allegory . . .
that is very good intelligence to possess and to operate around!
Problem is.. You won’t believe how fast the enemy can adapt.
IF they desire sufficient resources toward their problem
Their arrogance will be their downfall
The enemy is too immature and impulsive to adapt.
Agree on that.
They have only one tattered playbook with all the pages starting to fall out.
translated to mean the dutch chodos are jackasses?
The enemy is short on sense of humor.
Hence the importance of reading the classics…..especially of those authors commenting upon the form of govt under which they lived knowing that to be found out meant death….
Again
The dumbing down of our children was not by mistake….
Love it Sundance that you went there…..
Plato’s allegory of the cave. Great place to start!
It’s as if Plato could see into the present day and all the people who are so attached to what they see and hear on their televisions. The world hasn’t changed much in all these years, I guess. The truth must be spoken to the chained, even if it means ridicule for those trying to help the chained understand what is true and what are the shadows cast upon the television for consumption of the masses from the overlords.
You hit upon such an important point, Salty1. The world HASN’T changed much…perhaps circumstances have, but the people within…haven’t changed at all. What drives people in power, or in want of power, to do what they do is fairly consistent. I think that’s why those who fail to heed the lessons of the past do repeat its mistakes.
So Plato knew then about humanity what we’re still learning now.
This new post and the Rise Up one brings pancakes to mind!
Wolverines too!
Password…..A good way to get rid of those who are donation suppressors and Trump vote suppressors.
Ive been wondering when Sundance is going to kick this site into password status.
Passwords, at this point in time, need to remain confidential.
Only seasoned Treepers will then be on this site.
It will be blissful and thoughtful.
Yes, it will be blissful, thoughtful and very small. I know I don’t know the passwords so when that day comes I’ll just stick with prayer since nothing else works anyway.
I still recall the password.
Yes, it DOES have that pancakie smell to it, with a hint of real butter and maple syrup, lol.
By the way I had been meaning to learn how to make pancakes from scratch, so I’m now using sundance’s recipe as a springboard.
I make them with buttermilk and whole-grain pastry flour, and thin them with milk into crepes to be filled with raspberries from my overgrown patch.
I got it. But I am a simple person and I work with horses.
Everyone knows an old horse can work much longer and harder than a young horse.
Anyone who works with horses knows that is not true.
The young ones are lacking skills, the middle age horses (7-19 yo) have the skills if they want to use them, and the old horses just want to be left alone.
🙂
We disagree.
An old horse is a friend of longstanding, and also one of great understanding and will do what you ask of him , sometimes before you ask.
I have felt the shifting of destiny for much of my life.
It’s said in the good book that what others have meant for evil can be used for good in serving his will. To build up those imperfect individuals for the perfect task. Formative moments at those precise junctures of life.
For all those readers out there, ask yourselves; will you answer the ghost that stirs the hearts of men?
Small hard balls are the choice of professional golfers.
There is an old movie with Red Skelton and Eleanor Powell called Ship Ahoy.
Back then and in the movie there are tons of hand signals and gestures most in this country could recognize when heard or seen.
They also had code In tap dance that most could pick up even children and it use to be taught widely amongst our population.
Too damned old to plow, but I can still piss in their water bucket.
Lol
Prairie Fire copies. MACVSOG.
Mission;
“…an intensified program of harassment, diversion, political pressure, the capture of prisoners, physical destruction, acquisition of intelligence, generation of propaganda, and diversion of resources, against the Democratic…’
The stop at the end in the actual saying was necessary for today’s missions. No offense intended to the original saying.
When things go dark we need to find fields to gather the mules. Like the first major holiday after the dark meet in a field known as “gettysburg” or “Antietam “ or “Charleston” or “harpers ferry” or Ticonderoga” for you east coast farmers.
Not sure if I thought mules were “soldiers”, but definitely insurgents, dissidents, working behind the scenes to accomplish the goals. Never ceasing until mission accomplished, willing to be yoked by an older, wiser, leader. But the singularity of the leader, the farmer, working alone, yet in concert with millions of other farmers. Rifles assumed.
I thought it a perfect allegory of what we must do. And btw, working mules aren’t off talking (braying) in the fields. The farmèr is soft spoken, quiet, determined.
I love this idea of using allegory. I’ve long wanted to develop codespeak for use with family.
Thank you!!
I loved helping my children study Plato’s “Allegory of the Cave” when they attended high school. It is a good place to begin for those who want to do a deeper dive understanding symbolism and metaphors.
Sundance is correct; such language comes in handy. Occupied Paris is another time and place where people relied on metaphors and a certain style of comedy to communicate safely in dangerous times.
https://greekreporter.com/2022/10/24/plato-allegory-cave-connection-present-greece/
google was a education on allegories. i went through a whole page of allegories and still didn’t read them all.
I picked up on about half.
However, one thing I know for sure is that if Sundance posts a pancake recipe…
You need to open it up and read it fully. 😁
I absolutely failed your test. I am usually good about these things, but as I read, I knew there was something more there than the words themselves. So, paying more attention in the future.
I enjoy coming to the CTH and leaving a little more educated and a little more wiser with a couple more arrows in my quiver. I hope and pray others find more than what they originally came here for.
Remember those that wanted to be left alone are watching, waiting and preparing.
The house of We the People
Our nation is like a great house that was built over 250 years ago. This house was built on the strongest designed foundations ever conceived, The Constitution of United States of America. This foundation was so well made that other new nations who later would build their own new homes would copy this design.
At first this house of the Americans would have only 13 rooms but as the years and decades came and went the owners of this house would add on until eventually it was a mansion with 50 grand rooms. Like any home there is always something that needs to be fixed,repaired or brought up to date and the owners of this house would use the materials and methods known to them at that time to conduct such necessities.
Unfortunately sometimes these repairs or upgrades where not always done in the best way…shortcuts, substandard materials or graft where common practices. Not because the owners didn’t love their great home but the owners, being human, are susceptible to greed and laziness.
Eventually like with any old house the owners reach a conundrum, they wish to improve their home even more but they are unable to build any further because the old materials and methods used will not support the new construction.
In order for the owners to achieve their dream of building a better home for themselves the decision to tear the great house down to its foundation and rebuild anew with modern materials and means in order to ensure a home for them that is stronger and designed to last for future generations is made.
This is well within the rights of We the People, the blood was shed over 250 years ago.
TEC 8/5/21
The US Constitution is the most perfect document that was ever conceived because it was written by a moral and just group of men who worked hard and diligently to create something that would last and benefit ALL the citizens of its nation.
TEC 1/8/23
I was just thinking about the Navajo “code talkers” of World War II. The Japanese were never able to break the “code” of the Navajo language used in top secret communications of the United States in the Pacific.
There is also a successful history of “zootsuit” “abner” and “panhandle” as example code words of the U.S. Navy in World War II.
There are ways to fool the enemy and determined Americans will find those ways.
Here we have a fine mule
I sent my three college-aged grandsons copies of “Rise Up Old Mules.” They will understand.
Didn’t Al Gore invent the Allegory?
No, you’re thinking of the superhighway 🙂