In this segment of Glenn Greenwald’s monologue, he outlines the background of the IC opposition to Tulsi Gabbard and how that pressure forced Gabbard to change her position on FISA-702 authorization. {Background}
Tulsi has been a prior critic of the warrantless surveillance of Americans through the FISA-702 process. However, in order to get confirmed to President Trump’s cabinet as the Director of National Intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard has been forced to reverse her opposition to FISA-702. This is how the DC Deep State operates.
Without getting a single Democrat vote, Gabbard would rely upon the Republican senators supporting her. The republican senators will not support her unless she agrees to continue the surveillance state as it is currently utilized. Gabbard is an example of what We The People are up against in this confrontation with DC politicians who support a weaponized surveillance state. WATCH:
To be fair, an argument can be made that Mrs. Gabbard is saying that she is going to keep FISA but have a stricter threshold for its use, and that would still be a change for the better in protecting citizens from its widespread use to surveil us at whim. Keeping FISA doesn’t necessarily mean she can’t affect a lack of it’s use domestically. However, that is somewhat hopeium and wish-casting.
Given the extreme nature of how the 702 processes have been used, and combined with the new AI tools being constructed to exploit the metadata capture of all American citizens to expedite the surveillance results, it is critical to find actionable control mechanisms before the next reauthorization comes up again.
One approach might be to trigger immediate consequences for the unlawful use of the NSA database. The revocation of security clearances in combination with criminal accountability for misuse could easily be written into law. However, once again that relies on the willingness of the supporting lawmakers to agree to some accountability measure. As of right now, there is no such consequence.
Office of Inspector General Michael Horowitz testified April 27, 2023, that more than 3.4 million search queries into the NSA database took place between Dec. 1st, 2020, and Nov. 30th, 2021, by government officials and/or contractors working on behalf of the federal government. These search queries were based on authorizations related to the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA).
[OIG Testimony HERE]
Approximately 30% of those 3.4 million search queries were outside the rules and regulations that govern warrantless searches, what the politically correct government calls “non-compliant searches.” That means more than 1 million searches of private documents and communication of Americans were illegal and outside the rules.
Additionally, IG Horowitz also admitted that somewhere north of 10,000 federal employees have access to conduct these searches of the NSA database; a database which contains the electronic data of every single American, including emails, text messages, social media posts, instant messages, direct messages, phone calls, geolocation identifiers, purchases by electronic funds, banking records and any keystroke any American person puts into any electronic device for any reason.
If we were in a functioning system of government everything would be stopped right now, and no conversation would be taking place that was not about this issue. This is the total and complete surveillance state being talked about as if we were discussing what’s for dinner.
If you ask me why in hindsight, I now take the position that FISA-702 is the gateway to the massive surveillance system currently being put into place using Real ID and the AI facial recognition software provided by Palantir (CIA exploit). In essence, the gateway that allows the full-scale surveillance state, is opened by the prior authorization of FISA-702 that negates any 4th amendment protection.
This is beyond jaw-dropping.
Context: In 2018 CTH revealed through research of their own documents that FBI and DOJ/FBI contractors had done more than 1,000 illegal searches using the NSA database, targeting Republican primary candidates from November 2015 through May 2016. These stunning admissions were from the DOJ’s own reporting to the FISA court.
Few were paying attention.
Although the number of the illegal search queries were redacted, we know the number is four digits from the size of the redacted text. More than 1,000 and less than 9,999.
FAST FORWARD TO 2023 – April 27, 2023, IG Horowitz outlined that more than 1.1 million illegal searches of this database were conducted in 2021 during the first year of the Joe Biden administration.
Additionally, and perhaps more consequentially, to give scope to how the process of total domestic surveillance has expanded, Horowitz now admits in 2021 the number of federal government employees with access to this total metadata collection system now exceeds 10,000 people. STOP THE PRESSES!
Yes, congress is talking about this ‘as if’ there is some level of importance. However, the basic questions are not being asked or have perhaps just become so accepted that legislators have become oblivious to the insanity of it. Beyond the blood boiling questions about searching the NSA database, questions like:
In order for these search queries to take place, there has to be a housing facility to capture it.
Where is all of this electronic data being stored?
Why is all of this electronic data being stored?
Who is in control of this all-encompassing electronic data collection?
Forget the searches for a moment, what act of congress authorized the capture of this private data collection? Essentially electronic intercepts of communication systems that flow throughout our life.
The background context here is congress debating the renewal of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act and the power of the DOJ and FBI to intercept American citizen communication and electronic data via the “702” authorizations, that permit the NSA database to be searched and queried.
If the inspector general is now admitting the FISA laws have been so comprehensively corrupted such that 3.4 million searches by more than 10,000 federal employees and government contractors now have access, there is no way that any reasonably intelligent person should support such reauthorization. Even contemplating this request is absurd, beyond absurd.
The United States government is admitting to the public that a total and comprehensive surveillance state is currently in place, and 10,000 federal government agents have the authorization to monitor everything we do. This is the admitted and current status of RIGHT NOW.
In eight days, President Donald J Trump is scheduled to be sworn in as President of the United States. In my non-pretending world, this is likely to be the last time in our lifetime to drag the conversation of how we define liberty into the American psyche. All of my research in the past two decades indicates this likelihood is not hyperbole. We have one shot at this, and our time is now.
Liberty, the fundamental decision to retain it or lose it, is the context for all other contexts that have preceded it. The principles of liberty that we have defined for generations cannot exist in an American surveillance state. Thus, the secretive courts, the unlawful usurpation of the 4th Amendment, the short-sighted ramifications of the Patriot Act, the weaponization of our federal law enforcement and police agencies, all of it, must be reviewed through this fundamental core issue, Liberty.



“Republicans” who support no-warrant surveillance of U.S. citizens?
How about COMMUNISTS who pretend to be conservative to get themselves elected? Air them OUT.
Let’s not fool ourselves. The surveillance of Americans by the US government isn’t about Dims and Repugs. While the entire smoldering rot of DC spews the BS of ‘national security”, let’s not forget that the majority of congressional trash have become multi millionaires from insider trading. Does anyone actually think all communications of CEOs etc doesn’t give away motives for stock trades? Please, we’d have to be stupid to ignore the financial angle to surveillance of US citizens
Certainly, in the FISA renewal process there is room to insert stipulations. This is where Tulsi has opportunity to get creative, effectively nullifying those senators’ bribes. As you say, this is THE time and THE place where RINOS and self-proclaimed anti-Trump Dems get off the bus.
Get thrown off the bus. FIFY.
As Greenwald says in his monologue, if she says what they want to hear, in order to get confirmed, and once in by her actions tries to got 702 Program, or hamstring it with restirictions and regulations, they WILL go after her, amd try their considerable best to destroy her.
Hence, anything she does, she needs to make it worthwhile, and not something that can be easily reversed.
Maybe she mostly reports back to PDJT, and lets HIM take actions that draw fire, while she avoids direct fighting?
What would Democrats and RINOs do in a similar circumstance? They would lie to pass muster and then do what they wanted anyways. That’s what Tulsi should do now. After getting approved she can just do what she/President Trump wants. She can just say later on that things weren’t how they appeared from the outside … things changed after she was approved … or she can just say that she is doing something she is not doing … just like Mayorkas does.
Maybe but I don’t see how it is possible to lie our way back into honest government.
She could demand that they be subject to FISA 702 surveillance themselves. Exemptions for no one.
Agree with this Dutch, “…she mostly reports back to PDJT, and lets HIM take actions that draw fire, while she avoids direct fighting”
That said, could POTUS do an executive order to lock down access to the NSA database and implement access approvals based on a need to know basis? While the 702 is the gateway, the NSA database seems an imperative part of moving citizen information abuses forward.
In this context Gabbard, Waltz and others would be charged with this action item attributed to POTUS.
They will do what they have always done, ignore any executive order and gain access to the DB by deep state insiders. Only way is to totally eliminate ALL fed agencies NOT in the constitution, and that includes the FISA court. COS needs to abolish FISA and make it unconstitutional….
A presidential directive to the DNI cuts the Gordian Knot.
President Trump certainly won’t be around and neither will Tulsi with a Republican president loss. I say go for it regardless. Who gives a damn who takes blame with Trump with one term.
Fire away……….
Could she be thinking that by agreeing to accept it to get in’ that she could use it to go after the leftists in the same way they went after Trump? If she doesn’t support it and they let her be confirmed it works to their advantage to keep themselves immune to investigation. Just a thought Dutchman.
IC and their puppets lie perpetually. Hopefully, TG and all Trumpers will give them a big piece of their own medicine, good and hard, where it hurts them most. Which is also what would most benefit our nation.
Pull and ACB and Kavanaugh…tell them what they want to hear and then after confirmation…sorry…FO…
Around mid 2017 I got into an on-line convo with somebody that represented themselves as nsa. Bragged about the digital evidence they’d have of Obumbler’s op against PDJT.
My only question of him was… please point to the article & section of the constitution that authorizes the gubmint/nsa to scoop up & store every single person’s digital data.
It was the end of the conversation.
The problem with your question to him was the answer, FISA-702. That is why, just as we the people removed the Biden et al. crime family from DC, we must stand together to rid this country of FISA-702. Our, U.S. citizens, 4th amendment constitutional rights MUST BE RESTORED! And one way is to REQUIRE it be ALL or nothing. In other words, keeping it in place, while excluding themselves from it, is NOT equal protection under the law! THAT is the lawsuit. It is cut and dry. A class action lawsuit (I loathe them by the way, and don’t get me started on the recent Apple Siri class action lawsuit, 🤬), a class action lawsuit for equal protection. I dare a federal judge to say no to that, and if filed in Judge Aileen Cannon’s district, it would stand a chance to get done right in a district court, rather than on appeal.
I hate these people sooo much.
Anyone who has been targeted unjustly like Tulsi or Kash may do whatever it takes to get their eyes on the corrupt system to prove their case to the American public.
If most people are still unaware of the destructive nature of total surveillance, we maybe will finally have someone on the inside who can speak with authority and conviction of all the abuses that are documented and declassified for all of us to see.
THEN WE WILL KNOW WHO CARES ABOUT LIBERTY
Is all this data being shared with the EU?
So the EU ignore the millions of illegal aliens who entered their countries but targets legitimate citizens?
It’s a social credit score and if they don’t like you, you will not be allowed in.
ETIAS Requirements for American Citizens
https://www.etiaseu.com/us-citizens
ETIAS and Criminal Record: What You Need to Know for
https://martintaggart.com/etias-criminal-record/
You’re getting to scary to read. MAGA!!
Perhaps she is lying. Why would anyone think the Senators are entitled to the truth? The people are but not these parasites.
a scalpel approach will never work….
If we had a representative Congress and we didn’t want warrantless surveillance of Americans through the FISA-702 process then we wouldn’t have it now would we? The problem is the renewal of FISA has the support of Congress our so called “representatives” but not the support of us We The MAGA People! Until the Republican Uniparty members and RINOs are replaced with MAGA Republicans warrantless surveillance of American citizens will continue! Why President Trump can’t issue an EO stopping the illegal surveillance of American citizens using FISA 702s is beyond me? JMO
Or hopefully she’s lying righteously to get in office. Just claim she changed her mind the day after she’s confirmed. Screw these crap weasel congressmen.
Many Republicans who opposed Tulsi Gabbard no doubt had no problem voting to confirm…
Merrick Garland
Matthew Graves
DC Judge Chutkan
DC Judge Metha
DC Judge Boasberg
Mayorkas
Granholm
…and dozens of other Marxists nominated by Obama and Biden!
Hopefully she’s just saying what they want to hear and once she gets in she rips out the illegal surveillance system.
All kabuki ONCE AGAIN…. white noise….BS….WHATEVER you want to call it….anyone HONESTLY think 47 and “The Team” aren’t discussing EVERY tactical decision and directing subsequent moves on the board….?
Working WITH EACH OTHER to get confirmed….all it takes is for Jordan or Rand Paul to haul her up in front of the Houses on national TV and ASK HER ABOUT THE 702’s……have her EXPOSE WHAT THEY are doing and WHO THEY are…..EXPOSED to their constituents and MAGA MASSES as the feckless lying P’s OS THEY ARE…..
Looks like the best Gabbard can do in the near term is to be a mole in the Surveillance State, and assemble their framework and inner workings.
They’ll try to isolate her. She can leak egregious stuff, but the Uniparty can block investigations. And so can Bondi.
Trump would have to speak out, to get traction here. That’s not his way, but it should be in this case.
Here’s a basic question Why is fisa surveillance for the American people so important to Congress?
Seriously, I wanna know.
They know enough about it to know that they don’t want it for themselves, which is the reason they included an exemption for themselves, but why is it so important to Congress that the constitution be violated and that American citizens be spied on?
what is their rationalization to themselves For knowingly, breaking their oath of office against the constitution?
What do they get out of Spying on American people?
Just go full monty on this issue. The Senate does not have a leg to stand on. Who are they protecting?
When the Patriot Act did not have a sunset provision we all should have known that this snowball was rolling downhill and would get bigger and bigger.
she can take her spying on the American people and stick it up her volcano……and what has trump said about her flip flop? I haven’t heard a word from trump….
Tulsi could always say, “I was against the FISA-702, before I was for the FISA-702, before I was against the FISA-702…”