Russian Federation President Vladimir Putin holds a press conference at the conclusion of the U.S-China-Russia meeting in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of the APEC summit.

There is a considerable shift in outlook and position within President Putin as he responds to questions from Russian media.  Perhaps, this shift is also what lies behind Jared Kushner’s statements to the Europeans in Berlin, where Kushner emphasized to the EU that Russia was “comfortable” with NATO-like security guarantees for Ukraine {source}.

Kushner’s remarks followed a conversation with President Donald Trump about the trilateral discussion in Shenzhen.

In alignment with the tone shift, the Kremlin quickly uploaded the hour-long press conference to their YouTube channel, with English overlay.  Something has definitely shifted.  WATCH:

The transcript is a work in progress, but is partially provided below:

[Transcript] – President of Russia Vladimir Putin: Good evening.

I suggest we skip opening remarks and go straight to your questions. Please.

Question: Good evening, Mr President.

Nikita Korzun, NTV.

Your trilateral meeting with Xi Jinping and Donald Trump looks absolutely historic. But do you think it was historic in essence? What did you discuss, and what will happen next?

Thank you.

Vladimir Putin: Nobody knows what will happen next. Only God knows that.

However, I would really want it to have a continuation, at least because in terms of comparing notes, in a number of key areas, we have reached if not an agreement, then a mutual understanding.

This primarily concerns its historical significance and the like. There have never been such meetings before. We have held the first meeting, which has opened a new page in the history of diplomacy.

As for what we discussed, by and large, the topics of our meeting did not differ much from those raised at the plenary session. However, since our three countries are permanent members of the UN Security Council, we talked about its reform, a possible reform of the UN and about increasing its potential. All of us agree that this should be done, and that the operation of this universal organisation should be adjusted to modern realities.

We talked about security matters in the broad sense of the word, about preventing the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, nuclear weapons. We talked about issues pertaining to freedom of navigation. We support compliance with all norms of the international law of the sea. We discussed some issues related to the activities of certain organisations, such as the International Criminal Court, which is clearly overstepping its mandate and making political rather than legal decisions. By and large, all sides are in agreement on that.

We also discussed several other issues. You know, what I liked about that meeting, and what made an extremely positive impression on me, is that after we made our official statements, which we prepared in advance, in the presence of media representatives and your colleagues, we held an open discussion. I even think that none of us expected that. However, the President of China, who initiated this meeting, managed to create an atmosphere in which we freely exchanged views on several issues of mutual interest. It was probably the most interesting element of the meeting. Our discussion was held in a completely open and very candid atmosphere. It helped us understand each other better, and I think that this created conditions for future arrangements, no matter whether we do this in the same or in a different format. Overall, it was a very useful meeting.

Question: Good evening. Pavel Zarubin, Rossiya TV channel. You have known Mr Trump for nearly ten years now. We first saw the two of you meet at the G20 summit in Hamburg in 2017. Those meetings were typically followed by major, significant statements, yet they yielded no real results, often leading only to new sanctions instead. Even during Mr Trump’s second term, after the meeting in Anchorage too, the situation has been, to put it mildly, far from straightforward. In your view, is the current United States even capable of reaching agreements, and would they actually honour such agreements if they were to be concluded?

Vladimir Putin: You know, we are watching the situation closely. Members of the media, your colleagues who cover politics, are analysing this too, and they can see that the domestic political situation in the United States, and the country’s political system itself, is far from simple; one might even say it is rather complex. There are many checks and balances in place – various mechanisms designed to maintain a balance of political power. So, from the outside, things might appear inconsistent or not quite how we would like them to be.

But the most important point is this – and I have no doubt about it – President Trump is genuinely committed to resolving conflicts, including the conflict in Ukraine, and he is sincerely interested in improving bilateral relations across a range of areas, including, of course, the US-Russia relationship, which matters to us.

Naturally, we are observing developments. Of course, we would prefer to see things move faster and function more effectively. But we must deal with realities as they are, and we hope that this positive disposition will endure.

I mentioned this during our recent discussions in a multilateral format, and I can repeat it now. After all, we did work with President Trump during his first term. We did not work with him afterwards, once he left the presidency in 2020. Yet, both then and now, we share certain commonalities in our approaches – specifically regarding what are termed “civilisational values.” In that sense, there is something that, if not exactly uniting us, at least points to a certain alignment of views.

For instance, we were just discussing the issue of democracy – but what is democracy, really? Is it the liberal order that certain groups have sought, and continue to seek, to impose upon the entire world, fashioned according to their own template? Is that what democracy is? Or is it, in fact, a liberal attempt to monopolise power, a liberal dictatorship? What is it, exactly?

Reaching a common denominator – let alone fully implementing any agreements reached – is no simple task. Nevertheless, the general resolve of those we are engaging with today gives us reason to maintain a positive outlook. It is better to have some form of agreement, even if it is not fully realised, than to have no agreement at all.

Question (retranslated): Spasibo, Mr President.

I am Zou Yun, with China Media Group.

Regarding this historic meeting with President Xi and President Trump, what is the issue, or the issues, that you believe have achieved the greatest progress? And how do you understand the significance of the four proposals put forward by President Xi for global major powers to work together and save our global peace? And also, how would you describe the role of China in achieving those outcomes?

Thank you, Mr President.

Vladimir Putin: In this instance, China’s role has been decisive, as it was President Xi Jinping who initiated this meeting, which has clearly been a success. I would like to reiterate that this was largely because the President of the PRC succeeded in creating a relaxed setting for an open discussion. Furthermore, he set the tone for this frank exchange, in that he acted not only as the host of the meeting itself but also as the one who suggested having this open dialogue. In my view, this is very important as it lays the groundwork for further engagement – not only for the exchange of information, but also for preparatory work on certain decisions, perhaps in a different format. But this format is, in my view, timely and successful, given, as I have already mentioned, that China, Russia and the United States are permanent members of the United Nations Security Council and, as such, international security depends to a considerable extent on us.

Therefore, I would like, firstly, to congratulate the President of the PRC on the success of his event, which proved highly productive, and secondly, to thank him for his initiative. I am confident that all the issues – and I have just named the topics that were tabled for discussion – were addressed promptly, and the very fact that they were discussed, and that common ground was found in order to resolve them, is undoubtedly positive.

Question: Anastasia Savinykh, TASS News Agency.

Mr President, have our starting positions at the talks on European security become tougher than the proposals you advanced in 2021, which the West rejected? Will we demand any compensation from the West for the damage caused to Russia because of sanctions and strikes on our infrastructure with Western weapons? Is there any consensus on the territorial issue and ceasefire, or have the negotiations on this track hit a stalemate?

Thank you.

Vladimir Putin: Speaking about our demands and so on, we have not formulated them in such great detail. But it is certainly a legitimate question, because some people are trying to blame absolutely everything on us.

During my conversations with President Trump and discussions in the trilateral format, I reminded all sides how it all began. Regarding the Ukrainian crisis, it began with the coup d’etat in Kiev. It began with the military operation the new regime launched in the south-eastern regions of Ukraine which had not recognised the results of that coup.

We spent eight years – full eight years – trying to settle that crisis in south-eastern Ukraine. And all these eight years the Kiev regime conducted military operations there. It actually launched a war in south-eastern Ukraine. They publicly stated through their top officials, as all of you probably remember, that they do not intend to implement any peace agreements. Only after that did we recognise the new republics, the Donetsk and Lugansk republics, which were not recognised at that time.

Incidentally, I would like to once again recall that the people who have lived in these territories and acted in full compliance with Article 1 of the UN Charter. They did so in full compliance with international law. Only after that, and even then, not right away – actually, eight years after that – did we recognise their independence, signed an agreement on mutual assistance with them, and started providing assistance to them within the framework of our interstate agreement. This is how the conflict began.

It wasn’t us who started the war. We did not start any war at all. However, hostilities had been ongoing there for eight years: a war, in effect. We are simply trying to bring it to an end by providing assistance to the states that we did not recognise at first, but have now recognised, and with which we have concluded mutual assistance treaties. I reminded our colleagues of this today.

As for the demands, life moves on. There are certain issues or certain demands on our part that may be irrelevant today. Nevertheless, we have discussed these problematic, as I see it, issues and we remain ready to continue working through them with our partners via the appropriate channels.

As for compromises, of course there are compromises. How could there not be? They were proposed by the American side, and we accepted them exactly as they were presented, including during the talks in Anchorage. So, these compromises do exist, and we have supported them. The question is whether the other parties to the conflict – Ukraine and, in this case, its European sponsors – are prepared to accept them. In other words, do they want to reach an agreement to end hostilities, to end the war, by peaceful means or not? Judging by what we see at the moment, they don’t. But we shall see. Everything flows, everything changes. Perhaps they, too, will eventually realise that it is better to accept these compromises now than to face the reality later that they will have to accept anyway.

As I have said before, one can get the impression that the current authorities in Kiev have no desire to see an end to the hostilities, because that would immediately mean having to hold elections. They might retain power, perhaps, through blatant manipulation. However, it is highly unlikely that the current rulers in Kiev – the present regime – will be able to retain their power and, with it, the sources of income they derive from the war: plundering the national wealth that belongs to the people of Ukraine and siphoning off Western aid. That source of income would dry up. Therefore, they have no incentive to agree to put an end to hostilities or to create conditions for a lasting peace; indeed, as I have said before, a permanent peace, a peace that looks to the future. That is precisely what we are striving for. But if the Ukrainian authorities and their sponsors come to recognise these realities, then I believe the compromises we have been discussing, the ones I have mentioned, can be reached.

Question: Ivan Blagoi, Channel One.

What would you say to those politicians in the West who are currently watching the news and are scared by the prospect of a new Yalta?

Vladimir Putin: Politicians, if they are true politicians, do not simply watch the news. Of course, they take a look to keep abreast of the news agenda. But, by and large, politicians should be making the news, not simply watching what is happening on the international stage.

As for a new Yalta – what was so bad about Yalta? Indeed, what was wrong with it?

Firstly, Yalta enshrined the victory over Nazism. I would not be against that. I believe it would be right to enshrine the victory over neo-Nazism, so that we can speak of eradicating the very ideological roots of xenophobia, Russophobia and other phobias, and of eradicating everything connected with collaborationism during the Second World War and collaboration with Hitler and his regime. What is wrong with that? That is the first point.

Secondly, after all, it was following Yalta that the conditions were created for the establishment of the United Nations. And for 80 years, thanks to those agreements, the world has largely lived without major global military upheavals. Yes, there are many regional conflicts, and they are underway now, but there are no global upheavals. And that is thanks to the agreements reached at Yalta. What is wrong with that?

And, finally, at Yalta, no one carved up the world. I want to emphasise this, and I want everyone to understand it. At Yalta, there was no division of the world into spheres of influence; Yalta simply reflected the realities that had taken shape after the Second World War. And what was to be done back then? Continue the war, or what? At Yalta, the realities were acknowledged, and in today’s conflicts, too, the realities will have to be accepted.

Next question, please.

Question: Yelena Shiryaeva, Mir TV channel.

At the summit in Shenzhen, which is one of the world’s technology hubs, as we were able to see, much was said about the development of the digital economy and artificial intelligence. Did you reach any agreements with the leaders of the United States and China on launching joint projects in this area? And what place does Russia now occupy in the race to develop these technologies?

Thank you.

Vladimir Putin: Your question sounds rather anxious. When people speak of a race, they usually have in mind an arms race, although, of course, artificial intelligence and its development open up a range of opportunities and pose a range of threats.

We have also discussed this during our trilateral meeting today, and there was general agreement that we need to address certain aspects of the use of artificial intelligence so as to ensure that it does not pose any security threats. That is true.

As for Russia’s position, we have companies that are clear leaders in this field, not only in our country but also internationally, actively expanding their operations in many countries around the world. We have a great deal to offer and share with our partners, and all AI-related technologies are developing rapidly in Russia.

For example, you know that Sberbank and Yandex are both very active in this field, along with other companies that are increasingly stepping up their efforts.

We have a global competitive advantage in this area, and I want to emphasise that: a global advantage. As I mentioned earlier today, during the APEC session… Actually, during the trilateral meeting rather; the development of artificial intelligence and data centres requires enormous amounts of energy. According to international organisations, by 2030, which is just around the corner, data centres around the world will consume as much energy as all of Japan does today. And Japan is a highly developed country in terms of technology, industry and its economy as a whole.

In this respect, Russia has a distinct advantage because we are a global leader in the development of nuclear technologies for peaceful purposes. Of the approximately 36, or 33–35, nuclear power plants currently under construction abroad, around 30 are being built by Russia’s Rosatom. We are quite simply the undisputed leader.

When it comes to small nuclear power plants, we are the only ones actually building them. We have already built some for ourselves. As you know, they are operating in the North, and two more platforms are currently being made. Many countries want to do this, and many say they are ready, but no one apart from us has actually done it yet.

We also have vast, world-class reserves of hydrocarbons, including oil, gas and coal, as well as enormous hydropower potential. And, of course, we have renewable energy sources, such as solar power and others. We have all of these resources, and we are actively developing them. In this sense, Russia has significant competitive advantages, which makes us an excellent partner for the many countries seeking to develop artificial intelligence, which, is, in fact, practically everyone. So, we have already developed strong technological capabilities. I have mentioned two companies working in this field. So there are substantial, objective opportunities for cooperation, and we are fully prepared to pursue them.

Question: Olga Knyazeva, Vesti.

In recent days, there have been serious attacks – several attacks – on the Crimean Bridge, and substantial damage has been reported. I would like to hear your response.

Vladimir Putin: Well, first of all, I should like to say that the Crimean Bridge is an exclusively civilian facility. For a considerable time now – incidentally, I gave a direct instruction to this effect – we have not used the Crimean Bridge either to transport military equipment or to move ammunition. We have not even transported oil and petroleum products across the bridge. It is an exclusively civilian facility.

Let me remind you that in June this year, the head of the Kiev regime announced that within 40 days they would inflict irreparable damage on Russia and destroy our energy sector. Yes, I have already spoken about this: they did cause damage. But on August 5, as is well known, the 40-day deadline expired. The result was far from what they had expected. Yes, they began striking our tankers in the Black Sea. In response, as everyone is well aware, we took reciprocal measures. But our retaliatory actions proved far costlier for the [Kiev] regime than its attempts to damage our economy. And now we hear from all sides: please stop; let us reach an understanding: either we establish a moratorium at sea, or we will not strike the energy sector.

Frankly, I discussed this matter with colleagues from the Security Council and asked everyone to consider it further and return to this issue in the hope that perhaps something could be agreed. But following the strikes on the Crimean Bridge, there will be no negotiations. We will respond to these strikes. And I want everyone to know this. I believe that our retaliatory actions, as I have just said, will be far more painful than what the Kiev regime did to the bridge.

We will, of course, restore the bridge. In fact, there are two bridges there: a road bridge and a railway bridge. The road bridge has suffered serious damage; the railway bridge, I believe, has already been restored.

With modern weaponry and precision munitions, this is not particularly difficult to achieve. The question now concerns retaliatory measures. They will follow.

Question: Ilya Yezhov, RIA Novosti.

I would like to ask you about the APEC summit. The event is taking place in Shenzhen, and you have had a very packed schedule. How would you assess this forum? What are its main outcomes? And, perhaps, you could share what you consider to be the major result for Russia?

Thank you very much.

Vladimir Putin: First of all, we have all had the chance to get to know Shenzhen. It is an obvious success story for the People’s Republic of China – such colossal progress over the course of 40 years. It is essentially a megacity born – and not just any megacity, but a hub for intellectual and high-tech development. We congratulate our Chinese friends on this achievement.

As for the outcomes, first, I want to say that our work within the APEC framework is of great importance to us. A few years ago – I mentioned this today – we set ourselves a target of 40 percent growth in trade with the region; it has now exceeded 60 percent. We set that target well before the difficult events involving Ukraine. Why? Because this part of the world is developing rapidly, and we have natural partners here. The events in Ukraine and the so-called sanctions imposed against Russia – which are illegitimate and contrary to international law – have only accelerated this process. To reiterate: we were aiming for 40 percent growth, and now it is over 60. So this is significant for us.

We consider the outcomes to be positive, as we did more than just discuss topics which are of interest to all the participating countries – or, more accurately, all the participating economies. Twenty-one economies took part in today’s event, representing the entire region.

And it is crucial that we have once again reaffirmed the fundamental principles of economic relations. These include freedom of economic relations, ruling out restrictions of any kind, freedom of navigation – which we also discussed – and so on.

If we manage to put these principles into practice – at least here, within this region – it will undoubtedly serve as a major factor for the development of the global economy and for the Russian Federation.

{Transcript to be Continued}

Share