The U.S. Supreme Court has blocked the Biden administration from lifting Title 42, which allowed Customs and Border Patrol to expel cross border migrants due to the COVID-19 emergency. [Background of Case Here]
In a 5-4 decision with Justice Gorsuch joining the liberal members, the Supreme Court ruled that Title-42 should remain in effect. It wasn’t really a surprising decision if you think about the Biden administration hypocrisy.
On one hand the Biden administration extended the national COVID-19 emergency through April of 2023.
On the other hand, the same Biden administration was saying there was no COVID-19 emergency as the foundation for their effort to remove Title 42.
The Supreme Court seemed to recognize the inherent contradiction and applied a non-pretending logic. If the national health emergency exists, then Title 42 still applies. It’s really just a simple affirmation of Biden policy. [Ruling Here]
WASHINGTON – In a blow to the Biden administration’s ability to set the nation’s immigration policy, the Supreme Court on Tuesday said the government could not halt the expulsion of migrants for public health reasons under the controversial Title 42 program.
That program, which has been in place since the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic, must continue while courts assess a lawsuit filed by Republican officials in 19 states who say that unwinding the Title 42 policy would unleash a national “catastrophe.”
The emergency intervention from the high court came days after the Trump-era program was set to expire. The justices announced they will hear arguments about the program next year, but limited their review to whether the conservative states may intervene in the litigation. Oral arguments are expected in February. In the meantime, expulsions will continue.
Associate Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan would have denied the emergency request from the states and allowed the administration to lift the Title 42 policy. Associate Justices Neil Gorsuch and Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented from the court’s ruling Tuesday.
While the decision was a legal loss for President Joe Biden, the political implications were less clear: The administration’s effort to lift Title 42 has drawn sharp criticism from Republicans and uncertainty from some Democrats who fear border communities were not prepared for an influx of migrants. The Supreme Court’s decision appeared to defuse that situation for now, even as it left thousands of migrants in limbo. (read more)
Logically, the decision should have been 9-0. Of course, logic is in scarcity these days.
Not only logic but intellectual honesty.
Common sense is uncommon right about now!
Not among the saved it’s not.
I just wish more were among us.
The Supreme Court has become a bit of a wild card actually making some rulings (Roe v Wade, Affirmative Action in College admissions) that the majority of Americans want and expect.
The invaders are still going to pour in but at least it’s something.
Take a win.
In practice, it’s just another UniParty.
Just enough to keep up the pretense and maintain wedge issues that can be fundraised around by the appropriate organizations
So Roe v Wade was bad law from a Constitutional perspective.
The founding fathers could never have thought of a concept so horrible and unnatural.
Regardless the States should decide based on the Constitution.
Yet, God will decide upon anyone involved upon their natural death.
A win is a win.
They’re all too infrequent.
This is no win, this is merely a stalemate. The border is being over run and nothing is being done to slow or stop it. All that SCOTUS did is prevent it from getting worse for a time, but never better.
A loss is where something gets worse.
A win is where something gets better.
A stalemate is where the same thing continues happening.
And a stalemate with tyrants is a loss as far as I’m concerned. Where is SCOTUS setting the stolen 2020 election straight? Why do they have time to worry about what an illegitimate president is or isn’t doing when all they should be focused on is justly removing him from his ill gotten seat…
It’s a delay.
Full arguments have been ordered in April.
It ain’t over yet.
“Biden” was hoisted by his own petard on this one…trying to argue the “pandemic is over” on one hand ( for the draconian shutdown of our liberties) vs “there is no longer a health emergency” so the rest of the world and his wife can enter without let or hindrance….i.e. borders erased to make way for a North America Alliance.
Now the administration has to figure a way to untangle their spider’s web of lies and duplicity.
Let’s see … at the curent rate at which this invasion is runnng, by April we will have about 250,000 more Democrat voters in our house.
Notice no Rs object and have never objected, 47Yinzer.
Tell me the Constitution is still a relevant and enforced document.
See the video on page 2 where the border patrol in El Paso is opening the gate and letting the illegals on the Mexico side into the country. We see that they are put in a van and taken away to be processed. The illegals on the Mexico side found out where to wait for their entry into the US by a tip off on social media according to one of those interviewed on camera. He said he was forced to leave Venezuela and supports everything Biden is doing !! We need that guy and his wife like we need another a hole in our heads. This is against Title 42 but the Border Patrol is apparently assisting them anyway! WTH?
Our border no longer exists. Rules and laws have been ignored or erased…except for the little people.
There is a purpose for this, Barb. Obrador in Mexico gave the game away when he said the end game was for a North American Alliance. That would be the joining of Canada, the United States, and Mexico into a new one world entity.
This is necessary for global governance by the UN, the WEF and the WHO.
Though one can’t have their definition of “global” governance when at least one half of the world is not participating…
Despotism and psychopathy.
Thanks Betsy. One 0f the disturbing comments by the man and his wife from Venezuela was that he was a journalist who was chased out by the government. He escaped to Ecuador and they were after him there so he came through Mexico to this secret spot to get through our +non-border. His opinion of Biden when asked was he agreed with everything Biden’s doing. Doesn’t gel with why he said he was chased out of Venezuela. Must have lied his behind off! He’ll fit in well with the Democrats!!
Thank God for small miracles.
Thank God for all miracles.
For sure! 🙂
They are building a football size tent in El Paso (I think it’s El Paso) as we speak to hold all of them.
That’s good news for sure that El Paso is expecting only one very skinny illegal alien!
Does that exist, most look under worked and over fed.
Look so much like the one that NY Mayor took down . . .
Well if you watch the video on the next page, you will see they are being let through from the Juarez side of Mexico into El Paso US side by the Border Patrol. They just open the gate and direct them to get on the vans on the US side. Very illegal!! So Title, (Schmitle) 42 appears to be defunct whether the Court supports it or not!! We see you, Homeland INSANITY!! You deserve a greater eternal punishment than any of us mortals can wield!!
Let’s see what the RINOs do………they are a bunch of effiing scum.
The very worst sort of scum
Uniparty.
Exactly.
There are no RINOs.
It is One Party (with a handful of exceptions). Please stop differentiating.
The “republicans” are Not going to do canine 💩 poopy.
They serve the same masters—and it ain’t us.
The govment has left us in limbo along with the invaders, not immigrants.
We don’t have a real government.
We have a govment that is controlled by the corrupt intel agencies.
The govment is circling above us like a buzzard waiting to get its prey.
https://captainconvey.com/thetwitterfiles.html
They’re zombie democRATS.
I welcome the coming schism in America – it will bring clarity.
Well instead of a deluge at the border now it will be just a flood.
FJB, the WEF and the criminal cartels.
Emergency!!!!
So we’ll only stand by and watch 5,000 illegals cross our borders daily.
They’re talking about bringing in 14,000 per day.
How about that “consent of the governed” farce, or that joke about “government for the people by the people”.
Turns out if you’re an American you have less rights than illegal alien foreign nationals that you’re FORCED to finance against your will.
It’s performative. The Xiden junta isn’t expelling anyone anyway.
Exactly. Title 42 gives the executive branch authority to expel if they deem it necessary to public safety. Biden doesn’t and very few illegals are being ER’d aka Expedited Removal.
Last I heard on WarRoom (today), the title 42 expulsions are down to 30% of what they were under the Trump Admin.
Considering the volume of illegal alien squatters crossing the border is up by 100s of 1000s per month, it’s a drop in the 🪣.
The Supreme Court seemed to recognize the inherent contradiction and applied a non-pretending logic. If the national health emergency exists, then Title 42 still applies. It’s really just a simple affirmation of Biden policy.
Following China’s decision will lead us back again so the SC may rule in OBiden’s favor to over run our country.
China to Drop Covid Quarantine for Incoming TravelersFrom Jan. 8, visitors will be required to show only a negative P.C.R. test taken within 48 hours. The restrictions had cut the country off from the rest of the world for nearly three years
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/12/26/world/asia/china-covid-quarantine-travelers.html
I thought the national health emergency still was in place since Nanzi is allowing all our electeds to vote from home.
The Ol’ 5-4 Decision……Lol, just like the 49.5%- 50.5% loss for a Republican/MAGA Candidate…..Just comes down to the wire every time……I mean, the Country is Split Exactly 50/50…Think about the Odds of that…It’s ridiculous and Laughable…That’s why the cheating, fraud, Mail-in ballots, No Voter ID must continue at all costs….It’s 100% Theater….
Truly stupid.
Exactly. Kabuki theater.
Vote harder
Moar! Harder!
Yes this looks like a short term Win, I myself would rather see decisions coming from a criminal court as to the people in this illegitimate administration and the family of the puppet in the figurehead spot.
You look at this and say to yourself this is common sense and how on earth could it go any other way but from everything we have witnessed go on with these people in control of the levers of power. And nothing they do can shock us anymore. You see how they blatantly stole the presidency . And the whole thing was just an “in your face ” type thing. And all the useful idiots who blindly follow this corrupt regime just don’t care about the damage they have caused to this country by sitting back and allowing them to trample our rights and our constitution. They claim all the time of these things are threats to democracy , but everything they do is exactly what they accuse their opposition of doing. They are the threat to democracy (Brandon ,the media and all the clowns who follow them) ! All of them don’t give a crap for Democracy as long as they get what they want.
Gorsuch……….pffffff
He’s proving to be better than Kavanaugh or Coney-Barrett.
In this case Kavanaugh and Coney-Barrett didn’t deny or dissent.
Gorsuch is right – not the job of the court to keep a“health emergency “ alive – when there clearly isn’t one. Using Covid as an excuse to keep people out isn’t the answer – holding the administration accountable for ignoring laws is what should be happening, but that won’t happen until we the people take back our government from the traitorous lot that currently mismanage our money and affairs.
Wot? Someone tell Gorsuch ChiCom Joe the illegal occupant of the White House said there is a “health emergency” a PHE until 2023!!! So clearly there is one!! If we have to live under the emergency so should illegal aliens which prevents their entering!! Once again illegal aliens are deemed to have more status, more rights than citizens according to Gorsuch!!!
“The Department of Health and Human Services has extended the Federal Public Health Emergency (PHE) an additional 90 days to mid-January 2023. The extension will allow for ongoing flexibilities in areas like telehealth and its continuation. In addition to this 90-day extension, under the Budget Act of 2022, President Biden created a built-in 151-day extension of these flexibilities at the end of any PHE. With that extension, the current flexibilities would be in effect until June 2023.”
Pilgrim Society
TRUTH President Trump @realDonaldTrump
TITLE 42 is saving what’s left of our Country. Ending it, on top of our incredible, but now decimated, STAY IN MEXICO Policy, would greatly speed up the destruction of our Country. Both could have been put into the horrendous Mitch McConnell inspired “gift to the Democrats and China” OMINOUS Bill. What a disaster this Administration, coupled with the almost as bad RINOS, is. JUST CAN’T GET ANY WORSE!
https://truthsocial.com/users/realDonaldTrump/statuses/109585377075950521
Obiden Regime’s Intentional International Open border puts USA in crisis with or with out any Supremem Court Ruling.
Supreme
Et tu Gorsuch?
They also could have added to the ruling that this admin has 30 days to start enforcing all laws on immigration our be under the contempt of court which will result in the Head DHS spending time in jail, and if that does not stop the flow, The VP Heels up Kamala will be next one going to jail.
But no, we have to play games with the life of this country.
Arizona vs Mayorkas … won’t be seeing too many more suits styled like this one, after the Katie Hobbs administration takes over next week.
But Arizona distinguished itself in litigating against Biden’s mismanagement for a couple of outstanding years.
One hopes the incoming Democrat AG won’t sabotage this suit when it’s argued next year.
Interesting in light of facts revealed here: https://rumble.com/v22jcxg-mel-k-and-christie-hutcherson-special-report-betrayal-at-the-border.html
Christie has been reporting on the border issues for some time now. Credible threats to US.
Had to take some heart pills to stop the seizures I was having noticing that Roberts didn’t join the lefties on this one 🤗
And WTF was Gorsuch’s LEGAL reasoning?
Gorsuch also voted to put the BLTEIEIO pervert community under cover of the 1964 civil right act.
Seems like everyone is a victim these days except normal Americans.
https://www.christianpost.com/news/supreme-court-divided-in-lgbt-discrimination-cases-gorsuch-weighs-both-sides.html
Title 42 is not really doing anything to alleviate the influx at the border. Maybe a 1/10th of the illegal crossers are sent back… only to try again and again and again until they make it in.
Biden and DHS should be prosecuted for treason.
Et tu Gorsuch?
China is see sawing on 50MM new cases and new variant vs opening up. US cities and schools are chomping at the bit to require masks. Are the border ppl even screened? What are the CV19 levels of those in mass shelters?
There’s no proof at all that China is seeing anywhere near that many cases. The masses are being spoon-fed that by the communist regime.
In my opinion they are lying about that to try and hide the fact that their zero covid policies were only ever about more control over their people.
It also gave them perfect cover to due mass rounding ups of their political dissidents and make them disappear under the guise of “ died of Covid .”
Once they incinerate them they simply hand their ashes to family saying they died of the virus.
Perfect explanation.
Obiden Regime’s Intentional International Open border puts USA in crisis with or with out any Supremem Court Ruling.
Until OBiden Regime gets their way…..
Has Justice Gorsuch FORGOTTEN who put him on the Supreme Court? Me thinks he Speaks with forked tongue!!!!
I might have preferred accelerationism myself. The demographic makeover is already well assured. Now it’s just a question of how long it takes.
“At this point, what difference does it make. “
They don’t follow any laws.
The people with the power to make a difference in Americans lives – are only in it for their own power.
American citizens can be damned.
We are not sheep – but sacrificial lambs for the slaughter.
The fact people continually believe there is hope, or a way out, or applaud “a win is a win” are deluded.
It’s over – there are no good guys riding to the rescue.
Even the “uni-party” are nothing but subservient little yes men answering to nothing but a greater evil.
Adios America – I knew you and still love the ideal that you were.
“a Republic – if you can keep it” ….it’s gone.
Prepare for The Great Rebuild.
These people aren’t smart enough to maintain their Utopia.
But evil enough to destroy it all while trying.
Are non vaxxed Canadians going to be permitted to enter the U.S. ever again?
Even Trudeau eased up, but Biden’s masters are still flaunting the hypocrisy between Northern an southern borders.
Has Sotomayer ever deviated from Kagan? We know Jackson won’t either, she is a clown as we all could see during her “coronation.”
I wonder what it must feel like to live life with no interest in having an independent perspective. That doesn’t actually seem like living a life at all, no matter how much insincere adulation or money your controllers give you.
Get busy living or get busy dying, that’s G-d damned right.
What was Gorsuch’s tortured logic?
The govment has left us in limbo along with the invaders, not immigrants.
We don’t have a real government.
We have a govment that is controlled by the corrupt intel agencies.
The govment is circling above us like a buzzard waiting to get its prey.
https://captainconvey.com/thetwitterfiles.html
😳
I’d fill the Rio Grande with dangerous critters and publicize that to the Invaders world wide.
Why haven’t we conservatives told the Chamber of Commerce/Club for Growth traitors that we will not do business with them since they are the ones flooding us with illegals, destroying schools, neighborhoods, cities?
Why aren’t any well-known conservative radio/tv/podcast/bloggers asking us to do this?
In a related Court case,, because its ALL ‘RELATED’ Judge had intially affirmed KL’s case, on two counts as “legitimate”; he therefore denied Hobbs ask, for $500,000 in punitive sanctions.
I.E. it is legally affirmed that the case HAD MERIT.
IF, upon appeal the decision NOT to hear the other counts, such as Sig verification, COULD be overturned.
A major disadvantage if election cases, is the relative SPEED with which the claiment must prepare a case.
That means delays benefit the CLAIMENT (KL) as it gives them more TIME, to gather evidence.
As to how this RELATES, to the SCOTUS decision, whats happening in Ukraine, Hong Kong, the whole World, see KL on War Room, link at TGP.
KL lays it ALL on the line, really speaks TRUTH, right out loud, and no apologies!
Hope she uses that time to find sharp and ferocious trial attorneys with an extreme case of MAGA.
Remember, these people are our replacements.
‘The next generation will pay a heavy price for our negligence.
A federal court blocked JoBama from ending title 42 last May, but the invasion keeps getting worse.
I’m sure they’ll ignore the ruling from the supreme court with zero consequences.
Neil Gorsuch turns out to be a tool for the left. What a surprise.
Mitch McConnell loves Amy Crony Barrett.
He’s from Colorado, makes sense.
Didn’t the court also tell Biden to leave stay in Mexico in place a while back he has ignored that ruling so will he get
away with not paying attention to this one…
Thank God most of the Justices used their brains for something besides a hatrack
We are experiencing how a government of “lifetime” appointments destroys a country.
When you are dealing with the hard-core criminals in the Biden crime organization, you will not see respect for ANY rulings by ANY court.
We are living in a country where “might makes right.” The courts do not have armed divisions of troops to enforce their rulings.
The founders of the United States wisely saw a peoples’ right to keep and bear arms is necessary to preserve the liberty of the people. The Second Amendment was created to address the very lawlessness and widespread government corruption we face today.
Mao Zedong was correct when he said “Political power grows out of the barrel of a gun.”
Yea great.
Block a title wave in the dirt trails coming in from the south.
Nothing mean a dam thing.
Just a smile on the face of thug getting free billfold he found in slacks of a running guy yelling help.
The people in the pic above the hound in the apartment burning down around his ears look like they had a heavy lunch.
Absolutely meaningless. Biden is intent on open borders, inviting in the world.
There are no expulsions.
There will be no expulsions.
This is not stoppable. Who can make Biden deport/expel anyone?
Legalizing Border Crossing for All: The Next Stage of Biden’s Migration CrisisCIS gets rare access to a secretive, expanding program that makes border crossing “legal”
https://cis.org/Bensman/Legalizing-Border-Crossing-All-Next-Stage-Bidens-Migration-Crisis
CBP Document Details Mass Release of Illegal Aliens under BidenMore than 1.3 million so far, plus hundreds of thousands of gotaways
https://cis.org/Arthur/CBP-Document-Details-Mass-Release-Illegal-Aliens-under-Biden
Just claim you are gay
https://www.borderreport.com/immigration/lgbt-migrants-receiving-humanitarian-parole-at-california-port-of-entry/
As long as the fake emergency health declarations remain in effect, the more likely mass mail in ballot harvesting will remain the new abnormal.
Must be nice being on the exempt list
4 Communists and traitors of the country AND Constitution…they REALLY do want to destroy the USA. Gorsuck is no conservative.
and I was told that the border governors bus in illegal aliens
This has the potential to be a sleeper case with huge impact.
The Supreme Court isn’t ruling on the merits of the Biden Administration’s decision to revoke Title 42. That’s a different case from the Fifth Circuit brought by Louisiana that is working its way to the Supreme Court.
This case is where a group of immigrant rights plaintiffs brought a suit for the purpose of settling with the DOJ and getting a court order to end Title 42, in an effort to render the other case moot. Democrats do this all the time, especially in discrimination and environmental cases, where plaintiffs sue a Democrat city or county and then the Democrat city or county settles with them and they were never adversarial in the first place. It’s a way for Democrats to end run the legislative process.
What the Supreme Court is hearing arguments on is whether the 19 states can intervene to stop the collusive lawsuit and provide some real opposition. It doesn’t have anything to do with whether Title 42 is a good idea or not. It’s whether there can be a check and balance to this practice of using the judicial process to enact laws that Democrats can’t pass through legislation.
Unfortunately FJB will still be the illegitimate president in 23 when the emergency declaration expires. Then the gates of hell will open. Any other sane country would declare a real national emergency and get back to the remain in Mexico policy, Uniparty sucks.
Wait for them to declare a Climate Emergency to replace the Covid emergency. Drops the Title 42 requirement. All restrictions and powers remain in place and more.
A Climate Emergency would be kind of preposterous for reason of the Earth existing ~6 billion years (by carbon dating) and then suddenly what will be done in the coming 2 years will matter as make or break the planet 😀
Yes until CO2 drops below 1.5 molecules per 10,000 it’s clearly an emergency.
Why 1.5? That’s when plants die and all surface life as well.
CO2 is the molecule of life.
So at the end of the last ice age we approached 2. After that the planet warmed due to orbital mechanics and thus it was 3 before mankind had any influence what so ever.
Now are you sitting down?
Oh the horror mankind as driven this number to 4 molecules in 10,000 and if we burn all the fossil energy it may rise to 6.
Never mind that all this fossil energy was put into the crust at over 20 molecules per 10,000 at the very height of life upon are planet.
Davos is Satan, and CO2 is life, any questions.