A federal judge rules that a defendant MUST decrypt a laptop so they can use it to find the evidence they need to incriminate her. I could argue both sides of this one, but I think inevitably I would come down on the side of the accused. If you have the right to remain silent how can they compel you? (more after article)
Colorado – A judge on Monday ordered a Colorado woman to decrypt her laptop computer so prosecutors can use the files against her in a criminal case. The defendant, accused of bank fraud, had unsuccessfully argued that being forced to do so violates the Fifth Amendment’s protection against compelled self-incrimination.
“I conclude that the Fifth Amendment is not implicated by requiring production of the unencrypted contents of the Toshiba Satellite M305 laptop computer,” Colorado U.S. District Judge Robert Blackburn ruled Monday. (.pdf) The authorities seized the laptop from defendant Ramona Fricosu in 2010 with a court warrant while investigating financial fraud.
The case is being closely watched (.pdf) by civil rights groups, as the issue has never been squarely weighed in on by the Supreme Court.
Full disk encryption is an option built into the latest flavors of Windows, Mac OS and Linux, and well-designed encryption protocols used with a long passphrase can take decades to break, even with massive computing power.
The government had argued that there was no Fifth Amendment breach, and that it might “require significant resources and may harm the subject computer” if the authorities tried to crack the encryption.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Patricia Davies said in a court filing (.pdf) that if Judge Blackburn did not rule against the woman, that would amount to “a concession to her and potential criminals (be it in child exploitation, national security, terrorism, financial crimes or drug trafficking cases) that encrypting all inculpatory digital evidence will serve to defeat the efforts of law enforcement officers to obtain such evidence through judicially authorized search warrants, and thus make their prosecution impossible.”
A factually similar dispute involving child pornography ended with a Vermont federal judge ordering the defendant to decrypt the hard drive of his laptop. While that case never reached the Supreme Court, it differed from the Fricosu matter because U.S. border agents already knew there was child porn on the computer because they saw it while the computer was running during a 2006 routine stop along the Canadian border. (read more)
The Fifth Amendment reads: No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury, except in cases arising in the land or naval forces, or in the Militia, when in actual service in time of War or public danger; nor shall any person be subject for the same offense to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb; nor shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself, nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.
If you can be compelled to give decryption codes to your laptop so that prosecutors can gain evidence against you, or face punishment -via continued imprisonment- for non-compliance, then what about your right to remain silent and your right not to self incriminate.?
If an alleged murderer can by rule of law (right within 5th amendment) willfully refuse to disclose the location of a suspected body without punishment, and cannot be forcibly compelled; then how can a suspect of fraud be demanded to decrypt their computer and provide a figurative data-byte body ?
The Fifth Amendment protects witnesses and the accused from being forced to incriminate themselves. To “plead the Fifth” is to refuse to answer a question because the response could provide self-incriminating evidence of an illegal act punishable by fines, penalties or forfeiture. If protection against self-incrimination is implicit in the Miranda rights statement, which protects the “right to remain silent” how can you be compelled? The Supreme Court has held that an accused person may have a reasonable fear of prosecution and yet be innocent of any wrongdoing.
In my opinion the amendment privilege serves to protect the innocent who otherwise might be ensnared by ambiguous circumstances. What do you think?

