I’m posting this because McCotter tries to justify and explain his disparagements toward the Tea Party. Personally, I disagree with his fundamental premise therefore his explanations are shallow water, but that’s just me. Decide for yourself.
The comment they refer to in this conversation is the speech that McCotter gave on the House floor. His exact quote was:
We cannot unite America if we divide the movement,” McCotter warned. “Consequently, the time has come for the Tea party to grow up and the Republican Party to wake up and come together to serve and save this great nation.”
As you can easily hear, McCotter’s words scream pragmatism, and he conveys a message to warn the Tea Party that like all similar groundswell movements they run the risk of being marginalized. He brings this sentiment home with a repeated assertion that you cannot treat every single vote with the same level of importance and you must be cautious to differentiate and choose your battles. This is a historical central tenant of pragmatists and those who advocate for pragmatic principles. I can visibly see Zürich Mike nodding his head with agreement toward McCotter in the background.
However, I fundamentally disagree and I think that McCotter and like-minded “inside the beltway conservatives” are missing a central point. We are not acting like every vote is life or death, only the ones that have fiscal impact OR create a divergence from constitutional limits, practices and values. Embedded on those central core values within the Tea Party movement there cannot be any compromise. Ever. And for McCotter to say “grow up”, “shut up”, or “knock it off”, when confronted by unwavering principle, quite frankly shows a pontificating arrogance.
Thankfully in this interview Dennis Miller keenly points out that it is the very “passion” of the Tea Party that is boldly moving, or attempting to move/restore, some semblance of fiscal sanity. The politicos cannot, or should not, devalue that passion with their dismissive intolerance of a principled stand. That reflective response screams of a “that’s not the way things are done around here” mentality. The very mentality we seek to eliminate.
In essence by castigating the Tea Party as childish stubborn minded ideologues, they, and in this case McCotter, fail to recognize the magnitude of the crisis and they visually appear become cognitively dissonant. This is an emotional battle, and as a wise person has recently stated “Morale is EVERYTHING”. For McCotter to dismissively require the Tea Party to acquiesce to the establishment ‘betters’, and shut up or quiet down, he is fundamentally disconnecting himself on an emotional and intellectual level from the very spirit that creates the passion within the movement itself.
That’s my take. What say you?