Short circuiting the political process

From the Norwegian Website (DocumentNo) Political violence is inimical to the political process and changes it outside of its normal civic parameteres, Hannah Arendt writes in the book by that very name: Political violence.
That is the awesome realization that comes to mind considering what Anderes Behring Breivik did. He not only committed a heineous crime, he will affect the political process in Norway and a lot of other countries. That is a sinister truth.
Realization of this threat may lessen its impact.
Behring Breivik resembles the jihadists he purportedly opposed. The methods are the message.
Like the 9/11 suicide bomber, who also saw themselves as knights, he takes history into his own hands, acting like a god and destroyer.

The powers that be, i.e. the media, commentators, politcians try to excorcise the demon by calling it hate. But Behring Breivik was dabbling in some of the fundamental questions of our time. Excorcising those questions will not make them go away.
Hate is a word that pales beside the enormity of what Behring Breivik did. He tried to change history, just like the 9/11-bombers, by extreme violence and gruesomeness.
What is striking in his writings is not first and foremost hate, which is usually connected to emotions. Feelings are not predominant, but plenty of cold logic. Behring Breivik has assembled a theory of history and feels obligated to act on its behalf. It is megalomania on an epic scale.
People are truly frightened by this spectacle and rightfully so. In the Middle East such persons wield state power and strive to acquire nuclear bombs.
Those persons and forces think of violence as a legitimate tool, not constrained violence, as executed by a legal state, but unrestrained violence, against civilians. That was what was let loose in Europe in the 20th century. Now modern terror are replicating this threat.
In an age of technology one person can destroy thousands of lives and communicate his acts to the whole world. What was lacking to conform to the jihadist picture was a testament and a video. Now we have both.
One should not be relieved that this act was committed by a Norwegian and not a islamist, in the sense that this is a see-saw, understanding it as a zero-sum game. That is a dangerous political construct.
Terror is threatening the political process whoever is perpetrating it. Any attempt to utilize this for political gain, by blaming political opponents and smearing them, is playing into the terrorists hands.
Violence and mass terror as Friday’s acts certainly was, will affect the politial process. But how? A heavy responsbility weighs on the shoulders of those who wield media and political power. There is already a tendency to play the blame game: accusing websites of fomenting hate crimes.
There certainly are a few hatedriven websites, but they have little traffic. People tire of them easily. Others have a wider audience because they present genuine, serious articles, news stories and give room for debate. Document.no has attempted to fill such a role in Norway.
One should not underestimate people’s common sense. It is simply not the case that hate draws an audience.
But there is a case to be made that a stifling climate in main stream media elicits frustration and anger amongst many. As one can easily observe this anger is spewing out from comments in online papers. The editors employ “professional” firms who vet their comments. Major Norwegian and Swedish papers are employing a company in Varberg, Sweden, who moderate their readers comments, thus placing an important part of their communication with readers in other people’s hands. To me that seems like a betrayal of the contract that implicitly exists between editors and public.
A lot of people can tell frustrating tales of being censored or having totally normal communication removed, simply because they contained some words or expressions that at the appropriate time were considered unacceptable.
There is every reason to fear that this paranoia will gain momentum after 22/7 in Norway. People are afraid and susecptible to what they are being told about who is dangerous.
But legitimate political debate cannot be banished without serious political repercussions.
USA and Europe are undergoing major changes, and are in the thick of a debt crises that will affect all of society. There are fundamental conflicts that need to be solved in a democratic way. That presupposes an open debate.   (visit site)

The editors of the site Document.No have an interesting perspective on the mentality behind the Norwegian Breivik.   They write about it HERE.  (partial script below)

Who is Anders Behring Breivik, who now stands accused of executing the worst terrorattack and massacre in Norwegian history. The public wants to know: How this was possible. Was there no early warning, that should have been detected?

Behring Breivik was an active commentator on this site in the fall of 2009, especially. In the course of a few months he wrote some 75 pieces, some of them quite extensive.

They offer some interesting insights into his ideas at the time. He writes mostly about what Americans call the cultural war; focused on immigration, demography, identity, and politics in the broader sense.

His main enemy is not muslims, but multiculturalists and what he calls cultural marxists. This is a term that some on the political right uses. It is vague and can be used about almost anything. Because it is so imprecise this editor raised an inner red flag when Behring Breivik used it about the Frankfurter School. This was an important philosophical school in Germany, after the war, led by Adorno and Horkheimer. That Behring Breivik classified them as cultural marxists indicated that he did not really know cultural history. But that does not make him an extremist.  (Continue Reading)

Share