Based on an inquiry from reader MRM I am going to post the contents of a Financial Times article and then try to answer the question of motive. [-It is important to remember that the “motives” of the Financial Times are not arbitrary or unaffiliated to the outcome of the debate. Indeed they have a vested interest in the raising of the debt ceiling so it is important to keep that in mind as you digest their material-]…
(Financial Times) Amid disturbing signs that the US recovery has stalled, President Barack Obama took a huge gamble in his approach to the debt-ceiling talks last week. Believing he had an understanding with John Boehner, leader of the Republicans in the House of Representatives, he declared he wanted a $4 trillion, “grand bargain” on the budget. Barely a day later, Mr Boehner said the deal was off. By Sunday evening, with talks about to resume at the White House, the president’s gambit appeared to have failed.
The weak economy makes a budget breakthrough all the more urgent. Jobs figures released on Friday were shockingly bad. They show that the US unemployment rate has risen again, to 9.2 per cent. In June, net job creation all but stopped. Even if uncertainty over the fiscal outlook is not the main reason for the setback, it certainly is not helping.
Quite what Mr Obama was thinking – and where things go from here – is unclear. Was his intervention a tactical feint, to weaken his Republican opponents? Was it a sudden conversion to the case for fiscal consolidation? What did the president expect to achieve?
We know that nothing Obama does is without political slant or perspective. Indeed, Valerie Jarrett’s primary responsibility is to place all decisions and possibilities with policy through the prism of political risk or benefit and then determine direction. Nothing Obama does is non-political. This fact is beyond argument and must be afforded consideration. The author of this article does not take that position as a substantive starting point or distinction, therefore some of the query falls short on substance…./SD
Whatever else the policy was, it was new. Until recently Treasury officials had believed that the big fiscal issues could not be resolved with the debt-ceiling clock running down. After standing aside for months, Mr Obama took the opposite approach: nothing short of a grand bargain would work. He even promised to veto a stopgap measure. Liberal Democrats were stunned, because savings of more than $4 trillion cannot be found without changing Social Security and Medicare, which the party wants to keep off-limits. Mr Obama was offering these programmes up for cuts.
As we pointed out earlier in the week the Administration must have done some internal polling data and realized they were on the losing side of the issue as it was currently framed. Hence, Obama made a strategic decision to engage the narrative by advancing on the Republicans home turf and putting the ball in their court.
In return, he demanded movement from Republicans on revenues. This appeased few Democrats, much as they want to see taxes rise as part of a long-term budget solution, because the president was ready to settle for a ratio of three dollars of spending cuts for every dollar of extra revenue. These are proportions that a moderate Republican might prefer, if there were any such thing as a moderate Republican.
Obama had drummed the “Millionaires and Billionaires” ad infinitum. In addition the new catch phrase of “corporate jet owners” was solidly in place. His revenue position was firm, set in stone, and without compromise. The Democrats and the media were acutely selling this point, and the public was on his side, kind of…. After a few weeks, some pushback from the Republicans began to erode the “tax the rich” talking points. arguments such as “remember the luxury tax”, made people pause and reconsider the Obama narrative.
Many Democrats concluded that Mr Obama was preparing to reward the enemy, yet again, for its obduracy. With no shred of intellectual justification, and controlling just one house of Congress, the Republicans say, “No tax increases, ever” – and Mr Obama, instead of resisting, moves three-quarters of the way toward their position. Merely for the sake of appearing to take charge, he all but surrenders.
Then what happened? Mr Boehner’s House Republicans tell their leader they will settle for nothing less than unconditional surrender. The modest revenue increases envisaged by Mr Obama are still too much. The president tried for a bold solution that would have reflected well on both him and Mr Boehner. Liberal Democrats and, most crucially, rank-and-file Republicans in the House, were having none of it. For the moment, the president and the speaker of the House look equally impaired.
Remember, the fact that long-term structural changes to the budget being necessary are NOT talking points. They are factually based. Obama knows this, he knows that we are spending more than we are taking in, and he knows that any of his outlined increases are not going to close that gap. Period. Despite the ideological selling points of the left, and their outright refusal to accept the facts, it is nonetheless certain that entitlements MUST be adjusted, reformed, or changed in a substantive way if we are to find even a short-term way to operate government.
Could Mr Obama’s calculations have been more devious than this? Could this breakdown have been the White House plan all along? A theory to this effect is circulating. Maybe the president decided that the debt talks were going to fail anyway, and his main concern was to make sure that Republicans got the blame when they did.
Perhaps Mr Obama was pulling what Paul Krugman of the New York Times called an anti-Corleone: make them an offer they can’t accept. This tactic always had a fair chance of succeeding, because of the GOP’s mulishness on taxes. There was a fair prospect that the Republicans would reject even modest extra revenues, regardless of the spending-cut prize – even defying their own leaders to do it. And so they have.
*Key Point* Yes, this is what Obama was doing. Remember, Obama ALWAYS leads from behind, he knows that to deal with an issue in a non-crisis timeframe always provides an optic of judgement for what is being done.
Obama believes in a ‘manage at time of crisis’ level of comfort. “Never letting a good crisis go to waste” is more than a talking point, it is a strategic manuever. By pushing things to the very last-minute any action taken by Obama can be sold under the guise of “he had to do it” thereby letting him off the hook for any failure or “unintended consequence”. Obama and crew are very good at using deadlines, and the subsequently created crisis, as excuses for their policy. It is a keen part of a skill set Obama learned as a community organizer. It is the “Fabian Socialist” way.
When I was saying several days ago that we needed to give Obama what he was asking for it was because I knew this was the direction he would take. He would frame the optical narrative of himself as being a pragmatist and coming to the middle. Even though he knew ultimately he was conceding to something the Republicans could not accept. They completely fell into the trap.
But there is a catch, of course, even if the plan is working out: the cost of blaming a debt-ceiling breakdown on Republicans is a debt-ceiling breakdown. I doubt you could call plotting such an outcome, if that is what the president is doing, responsible leadership.
Obama does not care about the outcome, he only cares about how the outcome looks. Again, this author provides an altruistic character trait to Obama that does not exist. It is all about political optics all the time. Period.
I think it more plausible that the president was sincere – far too late, but sincere nonetheless. By intervening in the budget talks and staking his own reputation on a dramatic new proposal, he hoped to break the stalemate. He knew he risked his party’s anger by putting entitlement reform, which is necessary, on the table. By doing so, he hoped to force Republicans to soften their resistance to tax increases, which are also necessary. A more balanced approach to long-term fiscal restraint would be possible – and if all went well, Mr Obama would get the credit.
This opinion is exactly what the Obama team want to create. This is the picture they want painted by the media. Poor pragmatic Obama reached across the aisle and offered himself upon the altar of sacrifice. “See he’s not an ideologue”….. Well played Mr. President, well-played.
It was too little leadership, too late. To make this strategy succeed, Mr Obama needed the pressure of public opinion to force Republicans to compromise. That pressure is still too weak, and the time to fix this is running out fast. Mr Obama has infuriated much of his party – again. And he has failed to budge a pathologically intransigent Republican party – again. He has come to a moment that could settle the fate of his presidency.
Does he press on for the big deal, fighting for public support at this absurdly late hour, risking even more? Or does he climb down from his threat to veto a smaller measure, settle on terms dictated by the GOP, and look still further diminished? Neither choice looks promising. Meanwhile, the debt-ceiling clock runs down.
The public pressure is too weak because despite the opinion of left in framing the electorate as stupid sheep, the American people are smarter now and they are more acutely engaged in substantive understanding. As Sarah Palin said so easily, and so accurately, we can add. We know stupid. We know what does not make sense. We can see through the smoke and mirrors.
Obama is playing the Debt Ceiling for political advantage. He is using a false claim of pragmatism to gain more leverage on raising taxes and the ultimate goal of SPENDING. Real structural spending constraints will ABSOLUTELY mean a smaller government. Obama will have nothing, NOTHING, to do with a smaller government. Period…../SD
