Given the increasing Rhetoric surrounding this “Jobs Bill” I thought it might be useful to bump this prior thread for review. Republican Senator Mitch McConnell tried to force Democrat Leader Harry Reid to bring it to a vote right now. Harry Reid refused because he does not have the Democrat votes needed to pass the bill.   Obama is pointing his personal rhetoric at the House of Representatives and Republican Majority Whip Eric Cantor in an effort to embarass Cantor and Speaker Boehner into a forced vote. 
Allow me to try to explain why anyone with a modicum of common sense should oppose Obama’s “American Jobs Act“.   There really is a simple reason to stand firm in opposition.  Why?  Well simply put, his proposal does not solve the problem, it only temporarily masks the underlying issue, and arguably makes matters worse.
Consider this apropos metaphor.   Spending more money to artificially stimulate, or fill, the lack of natural economic activity by pumping more federal money into the problem is like trying to fill a sinkhole by pouring more surface soil without actually addressing the original cause of the sinkhole itself.

What causes a sinkhole?  Sinkholes are all about water:

  • Water dissolves minerals in the rock, leaving residue and open spaces within
    the rock. (This is called “weathering”.)
  • Water washes away the soil and residue from the voids in the rock.
  • Lowering of groundwater levels can cause a loss of support for the soft
    material in the rock spaces that can lead to collapse.
  • Changing groundwater gradients (due to removing or introducing water to the system) can cause loose material to flush out quicker from the voids and the surface to collapse in response.
  • Any change to the hydrologic system (putting more water in or taking it out)
    causes the system to become at least temporarily unstable and can lead to
    sinkholes.
  • Sinkholes can result from seasonal changes in the groundwater table, freeze
    and thaw of the ground, and extremes in precipitation (drought vs heavy rain).


Now lets look at an “economic sinkhole” using the same descriptive language but with some adjustments for metaphorical equivalencies:   What causes an Economic Sinkhole?
Economic Sinkholes are all about embedded sub-surface instability or shifting of economic conditions created by fluctuations in economic policy.   Examples would include: changes in tax rates, interest rates, industrial/financial regulation, or large increases in the prices of key commodities such as oil and energy.
Instead of water, sub-surface instability is created by a fast moving stream of changing policies, or fiscal positions, that can affect the bedrock of capital or equity deep within the economy.

  • Instability contracts binding minerals in the economic bed rock, leaving voids and open spaces within the rock. (This is called “economic contraction”.)
  • Instability washes away the confidence and predictability from the economy.
  • Fluctuations in consumer equity flow (credit and spending) can cause a loss of support for the economic purchasing power in the rock spaces and that can lead to collapse.
  • Changing degrees of instability (due to removing or introducing cash to the system) can cause tentative economic material to flush out, or contract, quicker from the voids and allow the surface to collapse in response.
  • Any change to the stability system (putting more cash in, taking it out, or tightening credit) causes the system to become at least temporarily unstable and can lead to economic sinkholes.
  • Economic Sinkholes can result from significant fiscal changes, or economic players (companies) inability to predict future expenses.   This lack of predictability causes fear and volatility; and in the extreme can lead to stoppage of economic activity or freezing.  Then rapid changes in policy can forcibly open the flow and just as quickly contract it.   These extremes in instability (drought vs heavy rain) erode the underlying consistency within the economy.


The approach at federal intervention vis-a-vis spending or stimulus into a naturally contracting economic sinkhole is nothing except trying to fill the jobs hole by dumping in money to:  cover the cost of payrolls,  pay additional unemployment benefits, and “create” a favorable business environment via tax incentives for companies to expend their capital.  However, none of those actions solve the underlying erosion or cause of the sink hole itself.
What happens?
After a period of time the filler material washes out again.  Or in this example the money is spent and the hole reappears.   In actuality the hole never went away, it was only temporarily covered up or filled.    Hence, “saved jobs” are no longer saved without further stimulus spending dumping more filler into the economic hole.
This approach is short-sighted and futile.   Until you actually engage in solving and stopping the cause of the erosion, the water, or in this case the instability, remains undeterred and will continue to wash away any filler material dumped in.   The root of the problem must be addressed.
This is what President Obama and his academic economic team are unable to grasp.  It is also the fundamental flaw behind Keynesian economics under these circumstances.  Government spending to fill gaps in economic activity caused by contraction do not work when there is an underlying unresolved economic issue.    We are in a period of systemic economic instability, and the actions being taken by those who believe in “Keynesian Economic Theory” are making matters worse.
They can continue to dump money into the economic sink hole, but it is not going to grow the economy.   Only by growing the economy, which means the underlying cause of erosion is stopped, can any hope for this approach work.    Yes, it is possible to fill the hole and allow the ground to once again stabilize.   However, the underlying source of the erosion must be addressed first.  
This basic common sense understanding is why people should not support wasting any more money into this bottomless pit.
So what is causing the underlying erosion?   As stated above.  “Instability” and lack of “Predictability”.    Consider this excercise (with only 4 months remaining in 2011):

  1. What are the federal personal income tax rates going to be next year?  (Obama/Congress)
  2. What are the corporate income tax rates going to be next year? (Obama/Congress)
  3. What are the allowable depreciation rates for next year?  (Obama/Congress)
  4. What are the capital gains tax rates for next year?  (Obama/Congress)
  5. What are the specific “loopholes” or income tax deductions within the tax code that we keep hearing are going to be eliminated?  When? (Obama/Congress)
  6. What is the price of energy going to be next year? (Obama / DOE / EPA)
  7. Will regulatory policies drive up energy costs next year? (Obama / EPA)
  8. What costs will other new regulatory policies have on me next year? (Obama)
  9. What impact will Obamacare have on employer health insurance benefit rates next year?
  10. What Labor Laws or Policies will be in effect next year?   (Obama / NLRB)
  11. What Hiring or Immigration Laws will be in effect next year? (Obama)
  12. Will Employers have to cover health insurance costs for same-sex spouses next year? (Obama/State)
  13. What impacts are the new Banking and Financial Regulatory rules going to have next year?  (Obama/Congress)
  14. Will I have access to capital or equity or loans?   At what rates? (Obama/Banks)
  15. What are the new communication fees (internet etc.) from regulation going to be? (Obama/Congress)
  16. What will the price of unemployment insurance be next year?  (State)

These are just a few.  But you see, all of these questions create uncertainty and instability in every corner of our nations economy.   From the field to the fork each step, or company in the process, encounters the same questions.   From the farmer, to the wholesaler, to the manufacturer, to the retailer, to the consumer, a massive flow of economic uncertainty exists under the surface.   So long as this rapid undercurrent of instability exists any stimulus thrown into the economic hole is just washed away.
No-one knows what exists in the future specifically because of the climate of uncertainty created by all of this instability.   Business, in its largest sense, does not make decisions from week to week or month to month.   Successful business is contingent upon having a business plan.   Predictability is absolutely a necessary component within that plan, and allows or supports economic activity on “main street” and to a lesser extent on Wall Street.
However, one should understand that Wall Street is oddly benefitting from the instability itself.  Because companies are frozen with similar questions, they are capturing record profits because they are focused on controlling day-to-day expenses and not reinvesting.   Large companies are cash heavy and paying record dividends because they are extremely efficient and productive with the current business that does exist.
However, no-one is expanding or looking to grow their operations with all of these looming questions rushing at never before seen rates just below their feet.  Choosing instead to keep inventories at a minimum and keep efficiency within their supply chain and distribution models.
The foundations are fiscally solid for many operations, but fear and uncertainty, or more aptly put, instability, created by this administration and their propensity toward burdensome regulation, combined with their inconsistent structural economic message is alarmingly unnerving.
President Obama, by his actions, is in a large part creating the exact problem he is seeking to resolve.   “HE” is the systemic flaw within the economy.
We are learning rapidly what happens when you put people in charge of the economy that have no actual understanding of economic consequences to decision-making.
Just last year in November President Obama stated he wanted to create certainty with the tax rates.   Then after passing an extension of the tax rates in December, during the lame duck session, he proposes a budget (Feb) consisting of massive tax hikes on individuals, families, corporations and small businesses.    This musical chairs approach toward economic decision-making is making all participants in the economy stand aside and watch from the sidelines trying desperately to figure out when the music is going to stop.
That’s why this “New Version” of stimulus to fill the jobs void is an exercise in futility and should not be supported until President Obama gets serious about setting policy in place, and stopping the irrational politicization of regulatory agencies.

Share