(Via Adrienne’s Corner) Debt ceiling Kubuki continues while the first woman spends 365 million of your tax dollars to build grocery stores. Wal-Mart, Walgreens and SuperValu are all going to get some of your money to open stores in what the “first woman” calls “food deserts.” I would think a company the size of Wal-Mart reaping billions in profits would be able to open a few stores without money that has been forcibly taken from the citizens of this country in the form of taxes.
I want to make sure I understand what is going on here. On one side you have a president who is threatening grandma with the withholding of her social security check, while on the other side his wife is handing out money. Our money!
This money is to be used to build grocery stores in areas where they will be unable to hire dependable and honest workers, where theft will be astronomical, and the probability of needing armed guards will be almost a certainty.
Several years ago, I made a trip back to St. Paul, MN and needed to pick up a few items. I headed over to the Target on University Ave, which is now mainly a minority area. I was astonished to see armed guards at the front door and a store that was filthy and trashed.
The future of these new stores intended to serve people who presumably can’t travel further than one mile to shop for groceries will be short. But the 365 million will be gone. It is things like this that make sane people think they have slipped down a hole with Alice and are dancing with the rabbits. (read more)
This is an area I have quite a bit of experience with. Classic governmental intervention into free markets. There is a reason Supermarkets and Grocery stores are not there. If they could make money, they would be there already. Various attempts at creating “economic recovery zones” have been tried to get businesses, especially grocery stores, open in poor or blighted neighborhoods, they almost always fail. Using taxpayer money to subsidize private businesses into making decisions they would not otherwise make without the government money is flawed economics. Generally, the subsidy comes in the form of removing impact fees, eliminating property taxes from the business, and providing money to offset -or in some cases wipe out entirely- construction costs. Essentially the business can open a store with little, if any, “up front” costs to the company.
However, the underlying economic issues and urban blight are never resolved and you end up with a business that will only stay open so long as the government pays them to remain open. Many people in the neighborhood may be truly desire a grocery store close to them, but the truth of the matter is they are very challenging to manage. The customer base trashes the place, the security risks are cost prohibitive, and in general terms they are non profitable due to poor base sales figures and high operating costs. They are just too difficult to keep open.
What the average consumer does not appreciate is the slim gross margin that exists in the food retailing business. Most supermarkets on a national average operate on a .02 cents on the dollar profit margin. Think about that. .02 cents per dollar sold. That’s it. Drop a jar of $2 spaghetti sauce on the floor and the store has to sell $100 in groceries just to break even from the loss. The food retailing business is extremely competitive and relies on fast turns of inventory to make money. The break even point for most operators is around $200k a week in sales for a small 30,000 sq ft. store. Anything lower than that and you are losing money immediately. Throw out $1,000/wk in stale, damaged, or outdated product and you’ve got to sell another $50k to break even.
This is a ridiculous waste of Federal Taxpayer money. In essence what you will see is the companies signing up to participate for good Public Relations and positive media attention along with “up front” profit potential from the government funds and the capacity to gain net profit from accelerated depreciation, coincidently another form of subsidy. However, once the PR benefit wears off, and the company has fulfilled their timeline obligation for the negotiated subsidy, they will close the doors faster than a Michelle can order Tamales.
The stores will be trashed, unkept, unclean, and unsafe. Just like the surrounding neighborhood.
Posted in Uncategorized
6 Comments