Personally, I think the “ratings agencies” have been corrupted and politicized by this Administration. Because of the agencies failures during the 2008 financial crisis their lack of reliability left them very weak and vulnerable to manipulation and political pressure. However, today S&P just announced that anything short of a $4 Trillion reduction in spending would fall short of preferred assurances. As expected this means a rating downgrade is all but inevitable….. regardless of outcome. (previous thread below from July 12)
Moody’s threatening a bond rating downgrade if the “Debt Ceiling” issue is not resolved has been a major talking point for Obama and his drunken sailor spending crew. But did you ever think that perhaps, just perhaps, it might be actually be purpose driven to “help” Obama. Collusion between Moody’s and the Obama Administration? Why would they do that you ask? Consider this Quid-Pro-Quo possibility… A buried story from last year..
Investigation into Moody’s rating glitch dropped (September 2010) SEC rules out probe into rating agency’s accidental AAA grade for risky investments despite finding that it “voted against taking responsive action”. A report by the US Securities and Exchange Commission has claimed that credit ratings agency Moody’s decided not to take action after discovering a computer glitch had caused it to give controversial investment products a high rating.
However, the SEC will not investigate whether this decision was fraudulent because it took place outside the US.
In May 2008, it was revealed that Moody’s had given AAA ratings to investment products called ‘constant proportion debt obligations’ – thereby implying they were a good investment – as a result of a bug in its financial modeling systems. […]
The SEC decided that it would not investigate the legality of this decision because it had taken place in Europe and therefore may not fall under its jurisdiction. “Because of uncertainty regarding a jurisdictional nexus between the United States and the relevant ratings conduct,” it said, “the Commission declined to pursue a fraud enforcement action in this matter.”
A recent working paper by the US Federal Reserve said the Moody’s computer glitch was not the principal cause for CPDOs being overvalued by investors, pointing out that Standard and Poor’s also gave the products an AAA rating. But it did say that the models used by such agencies to assess the products had drastically underestimated the likelihood of widespread credit defaults. (article link)
Hmmmm, funny that, no? The SEC Chairman ( Mary Schapiro since 2009) is an appointed Presidential position. The Obama Administration, the Treasury Chairman Tim Geithner (who coincidently was head of the New York Federal Reserve) and the Federal Reserve Chair (Bernake) all have interconnectivity to the SEC Chair, Mary Schapiro. They are all visibly staunch advocates for raising the Debt ceiling borrowing limit, they are all Obama appointees, and they all report to Obama.
It is not a stretch to say that Moody’s Rating Agency was very thankful for the SEC decision to drop their investigation.
*Nudge* *Nudge* *Wink* *Wink* Quid Pro Quo? *Ahem* *Cough* *Cough*
To say that President Obama, Timothy Geithner, and Ben Bernake are all benefiting vis-a-vi ‘talking points of advocacy’, from the recent Moody’s rating announcement would be an understatement. It is one of Obama’s key talking points and the Media is selling the “Bond Rating Fear” narrative hard. Consider these recent headlines:
- NPR – Ratings agencies Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s both have warned that
they might downgrade the United States’ AAA bond rating if a deal between the
White House and Congress on raising the debt ceiling isn’t reached before an
Aug. 2 deadline. - CBS News – Moody’s Investors Service announced Wednesday afternoon that it has put the United States’ Aaa bond rating under review “for possible downgrade given the rising possibility that the statutory debt limit will not be raised on a timely basis, leading to a default on US Treasury debt obligations.”
- USA Today – Moody’s Investors Service has placed the nation’s Aaa bond rating on review for possible downgrade, citing “the rising possibility that the statutory debt limit will not be raised on a timely basis, leading to a default on Treasury debt obligations.
- Fox News – Leading credit rating agency Moody’s said Wednesday that the U.S. government’s impeccable credit rating was under review for a potential downgrade as tensions boil over in Washington with time running out to raise the nation’s borrowing limit.
- Associated Press – Moody’s Investors Service on Wednesday threatened to lower the United States’ credit rating, saying there is a small but rising risk that the government will default on its debt. The credit rating agency said it will review the U.S. government’s triple-A bond rating because the White House and Congress are running out of time to raise America’s $14.3 trillion borrowing limit and avoid a default.
It is truly remarkable, and obvious, if you look at the same warnings earlier in the year, the verbage has nothing to do with the debt ceiling. In January, and again in April, the same type of articles were written but they focused on the substance of the debt itself and the need to cut the deficit. Now however, there is a distinct change in the headline narrative to push the advocacy of raising the debt limit. Don’t believe me, look for yourself via google search.
The truth of the matter is, these warnings or notices are not uncommon. However, their (Moody’s, and Standard and Poor’s) primary concern has nothing to do with raising the borrowing limit (debt ceiling), their concern lies in the extended debt itself. Raising the debt limit (borrowing more) does not eliminate the credit risk, it only insures our willingness to go further into debt. They are looking more at the financial health of our debt and going deeper does not lower that risk, it only provides a guarantee of intent to borrow.
Prof. Jacobson outlines this well. We already were headed for a downgrade because of too much, not too little, debt.
Yesterday Moody’s issued a warning of a possible debt downgrade if the debt ceiling dispute created a situation in which the U.S. defaulted, even though Moody’s acknowledged that “the risk is low.”
Obama is using the possible downgrade as a major bargaining chip in negotiations with Republicans, threatening to take his case to the public (as if he hasn’t already?):
“Don’t call my bluff,” the president said. “I am not afraid to veto and I will take it to the American people.”
If Moody’s, the credit rating agency that announced a review of U.S. credit, downgrades the United States, President Obama said, ”it will be a tax increase on every American.”
But a threatened downgrade by a major ratings agency is nothing new. Both Moody’s and S&P have been warning for months about possible downgrades unless the U.S. addressed the rising debt problem. The rising debt, not failure to incur more debt, was the concern.
In January, Moody’s issued the following warning:
Moody’s Investors Service said it may need to place a “negative” outlook on the Aaa rating of U.S. debt sooner than anticipated as the country’s budget deficit widens.
The extension of tax cuts enacted under President George W. Bush, the chance that Congress won’t reduce spending and the outcome of the November elections have increased Moody’s uncertainty over the willingness and ability of the U.S. to reduce its debt, the credit-ratings company said yesterday.
“Although no rating action is contemplated at this time, the time frame for possible future actions appears to be shortening, and the probability of assigning a negative outlook in the coming two years is rising,” wrote Steven Hess, a senior credit officer in New York and the author of the report. The rating remains “stable,” according to the report.
Here was a headline from January:

In April, S&P warned of a possible downgrade because of rising U.S. debt levels:
Sounding the alarm about the country’s deep fiscal problems, Standard & Poor’s on Monday downgraded its outlook on the U.S. credit rating to “negative,” raising the likelihood the U.S. will lose its coveted ‘AAA’ rating as Washington struggles to fix its beleaguered balance sheet….
“We believe there is a material risk that U.S. policymakers might not reach an agreement on how to address medium- and long-term budgetary challenges by 2013; if an agreement is not reached and meaningful implementation is not begun by then, this would in our view render the U.S. fiscal profile meaningfully weaker than that of peer ‘AAA’ sovereigns,” S&P said in the statement.
Get it? Regardless of the current political fight over raising the debt ceiling, we were on a path to a debt downgrade not because we were not incurring enough debt, but because we were incurring too much.
So the current debate over a downgrade due to failing to raise the debt limit is a sideshow. The issue is how we put ourselves on a path to lowering our debt, not how we raise the debt level.
Raising the debt limit without a plan to reduce our debt accomplishes nothing.
And we are all being treated like sheeples. “Move along, move along, nothing to see here folks, keep moving…. Trust us, we know what’s best… y’all don’t need to be worrying about the who’s and how’s, we’ve got it covered. Just keep moving”….
“It was not the fault of the Captain of the Titanic.”
But I think those clinging to the life rafts might just disagree…. huh? /SD