President Obama Leading From Behind…. Again...
I find myself compelled to expose the hidden Obama agenda once again. This time regarding Gay Marriage in general, and the New York “Marriage Equality Act” specifically. This one was tactically brilliant.
Please don’t think for a minute that Obama’s recent trip to New York City for fundraising was coincidental to their new “Gay Rights” initiative. For the sake of honest dialogue it must be openly discussed and brought to light.
Obama has been feeling significant heat from hardline leftys’ for his refusal to put himself and his progressive positions out in the line of fire regarding Gay Rights. Obama was stuck between a rock and proverbial hard place. Obama is worried about reelection and he sees openly advocating for gay marriage as a “dangerous third rail issue” which would “out him” as being too ideologically connected to the radical left. Indeed it could reasonably be argued that as a nation we are not yet comfortable, or ready, to accept open homosexual equality with marriage.
One only has to look at HARD LEFT leaning California to see how even amid liberal strongholds acceptance of gay marriage is an extremely divisive issue. When put to a full state vote the electorate has rejected it several times, despite how easy it was to put signatures together for a ballot initiative.
But lately Obama has been pressured by those advocating for gay rights to support gay marriage. It is a dilemma he does not want to face, and his handlers have been twisting themselves into contorted pretzel like positions to avoid taking an open position.
Enter the great State of New York to Obama’s rescue.
“Coincidently”, Obama has a massive fundraising effort with New York progressives on the same week he (through his spokespeople) is being raked across the proverbial gay coals at progressive ‘Net Root Nation’ for his wishy-washy mediocre support of gay rights. How can his New York crew of usurpers help? Easy. By framing their Statewide legislative Marriage Equality Act to specifically include verbage not mandating residency. Through New York structuring its legislation to legally bind same-sex couples regardless of residency they have established a constitutional crisis which will end up in the courts.
The concept of “Reciprocity” dictates that states will accept other states legally binding contracts on individuals for the sake of legal positions, or challenges. All previous Gay Marriage legislation has specifically worded such legislation to only apply to couples residing within the state of origin. Meaning if a gay couple married in Connecticut their marriage was only legally recognized in Connecticut. In Pennsylvania their marriage contract was not required to be lawfully recognized the same way it would be in Connecticut. New York has not done this. New York has initiated legislation that would legally bind all entities to recognize the marriage occurring in New York regardless of the state law, or absence thereof, outside of New York.
What they have effectively done is provide a pathway for the courts to determine reciprocity or recognition of residents who marry in New York but reside elsewhere.
This is a huge “off the hook” for President Obama, who can now say he supports the marriage equality legislation as a states right issue knowing full well that eventually it will come before the courts. What this New York pro-Obama legislation provides is a framework for national discussion and necessary federal intervention into the social issue of marriage. So it “becomes” a matter that the federal government must address. Win/Win for team re-elect Obama. Without President Obama staking his electability on the divisive issue he can wait until it becomes necessary for federal legislature to act.
Obama doesn’t have to bring it up now or request it to be considered, it will by necessary pathway reach him. He no longer has to take a stand. He can say he supports states rights and keep moderates happy, while saying he supports gay rights and waiting for necessary federal legislation that he does not specifically request.
Issue avoided. Electability risk removed. Progressive agenda advanced.
See how he rolls?
Perhaps a more looming ideological and moral question for consideration is the selfish formulation of the New York legislation itself. Indeed they are putting their own citizenry at risk to advance a larger cause. A same-sex couple who marries in New York next month could see the validity of their marriage evaporate in a few years if the courts strike down the law due to excessive social and legal reach outside the state of NY. (Reciprocity) If you look into the specific verbage of the New York law you can see that they actually plan for this to happen. There is no severability of constitutional issue. If any part of the Marriage Equality Act is struck down then every person who married automatically has their marriage voided under the law.
This is a legislative game of chicken and positioning. New York creating a situation for defenders and gay advocates of National Marriage Equality by providing a talking point and actually creating “victims” in New York who would suffer if the law was struck down. A great moral justification for advocacy. One can picture Obama taking that mantle up quite readily, and defending those poor hapless victims of insufferable prejudice in New York. Oh the humanity. Of course by then we would have forgotten how the entire issue was constructed in the first place and instead only be considering the resulting impact.
One has to wonder if gays in New York feel it worthwhile to take such a legislative risk? I mean its a little selfish of New York gay advocates to put the hearts, and legality, of their specific citizens on the line to advance a larger national agenda.
Or maybe not?
